Staging the ethical in the state of emergency in J. M. Coetzee's Waiting for the barbarians

english

2017

volume 40, issue 2

literature and ethics   South African literature    Agamben, Giorgio: Homo sacer 

Slovensko društvo za primerjalno književnost
(Obvezni izvod spletne publikacije)

In this article I analyze the novel by J. M. Coetzee, Waiting for the Barbarians (1980), in an attempt to show how it stages an insufficiency of the ethical reaction, by positioning it upon a social stage which determines its reach and effects. I proceed by reading this stage in the categories of Giorgio Agamben's concept of the state of emergency, which spans throughout all of the novel%s events, and defines the relations between its main characters, the Magistrate (novel's narrator and protagonist), the "barbarian girl," and Colonel Joll. My main focus rests on two episodes: firstly, I present how the Magistrates supposed humane treatment of the "barbarian girl" is in fact only a humanization of the imperial domination, and secondly I analyze the scene of mass torture of the "barbarians," led by Colonel Joll, in which the Magistrate's reaction is shown to be misplaced and insufficient. Finally, by reverting to Badiou's understanding of ethics, I show that both the Magistrate and Colonel Joll function within the boundaries of the imperial logic, and how the Magistrate's ethical reactions remain ineffective precisely because they do not question the very foundations, the supposed universal law, from which they stem, and therefore never manage to reach the objective level of action. In this sense Coetzee%s novel, on the level of form, fulfills that which is presented as lacking on the level of its content - by making its readers find a position outside of the logic of its characters, it presents them with the insufficiency of ethics devoid of any relation to politics.

12.07.2018