Digitalna knjižnica Slovenije
Narodna in univerzitetna knjižnica
Splošne knjižnice
Celjsko območje
Vse knjižnice območja
Osrednja knjižnica Celje
Knjižnica Laško
Osrednja knjižnica Mozirje
Knjižnica Šentjur
Knjižnica Šmarje
Knjižnica Velenje
Medobčinska splošna knjižnica Žalec
Dolenjsko območje
Knjižnica Mirana Jarca Novo mesto
Knjižnica Brežice
Knjižnica Kočevje
Valvasorjeva knjižnica Krško
Knjižnica Miklova hiša, Ribnica
Gorenjsko območje
Mestna knjižnica Kranj
Občinska knjižnica Jesenice
Knjižnica A. T. Linharta, Radovljica
Knjižnica Ivana Tavčarja, Škofja Loka
Knjižnica dr. Toneta Pretnarja, Tržič
Goriško območje
Vse knjižnice območja
Goriška knjižnica Franceta Bevka Nova Gorica
Lavričeva knjižnica, Ajdovščina
Mestna knjižnica in čitalnica Idrija
Knjižnica Cirila Kosmača Tolmin
Koroško območje
Koroška osrednja knjižnica dr. Franca Sušnika Ravne na Koroškem
Knjižnica Radlje ob Dravi
Knjižnica Ksaverja Meška, Slovenj Gradec
Obalno-kraško območje
Osrednja knjižnica Srečka Vilharja Koper
Knjižnica Makse Samsa, Ilirska Bistrica
Mestna knjižnica Izola - Biblioteca civica di Isola->Matična knjižnica Izola
Mestna knjižnica Piran
Kosovelova knjižnica Sežana
Osrednjeslovensko območje
Mestna knjižnica Ljubljana
Knjižnica Jožeta Udoviča, Cerknica
Knjižnica Domžale
Knjižnica Grosuplje
Knjižnica Franceta Balantiča Kamnik
Knjižnica Litija
Knjižnica Logatec
Knjižnica Medvode
Cankarjeva knjižnica Vrhnika
Pomursko območje
Pokrajinska in študijska knjižnica Murska Sobota
Javni zavod Knjižnica Gornja Radgona
Splošna knjižnica Ljutomer
Spodnjedravsko območje
Knjižnica Ivana Potrča Ptuj
Knjižnica Franca Ksavra Meška Ormož
Štajersko območje
Mariborska knjižnica
Knjižnica Lenart
Knjižnica Josipa Vošnjaka Slovenska Bistrica
Druge knjižnice
Bayerische StaatsBibliotek
Centralna pravosodna knjižnica
Centralna tehniška knjižnica Univerze v Ljubljani
Knjižnica Dušana Černeta Trst
Kraljeva knjižnica, Danska nacionalna knjižnica in univerzitetna knjižnica v Kopenhagnu
Narodna in študijska knjižnica
Österreichische Nationalbibliothek
Semeniška knjižnica
Slovenska študijska knjižnica Celovec
Škrabčeva knjižnica
Univerzitetna knjižnica Maribor
Arhivi in muzeji
Arhiv Republike Slovenije
Goriški muzej
Loški muzej Škofja Loka
Muzej in galerije mesta Ljubljana
Muzej Miklova hiša
Muzej novejše zgodovine Celje
Narodni muzej Slovenije
Pokrajinski arhiv Maribor
Pokrajinski muzej Kočevje
Prirodoslovni muzej Slovenije
Slovenian Museum and Archives - Slovenski muzej in arhiv
Slovenski etnografski muzej
Slovenski šolski muzej
Škofijski arhiv Koper
Menu
SLO
|
ENG
author
full-text
keywords
date
title
source
publisher
collection
AND
OR
NOT
author
full-text
keywords
date
title
source
publisher
collection
AND
OR
NOT
author
full-text
keywords
date
title
source
publisher
collection
AND
OR
NOT
author
full-text
keywords
date
title
source
publisher
collection
AND
OR
NOT
ADVANCED SEARCH
About us
Cooperation
Terms of use
dLib Statistics
Partners
News
Virtual exhibitions
Contact us
My dLib.si
Email
:
Pass.:
Login
Register!
Forgoten password
home
query
URN:NBN:SI:DOC-P80NR77K
Zapri
Zapri
Absence of an oral hearing in administrative disputes : a comparative analysis of Slovenia and Croatia
1. PDF document (378 kB)
1. TXT document (84 kB)
Add to EndNote (RIS format)
Contibutor(s)
Rašić, Mario (author)
Language
english
Source
Central European Public Administration Review
Year
2023
Numbering
volume 21,
issue 2
Publisher
Fakulteta za upravo
Provider
Univerza v Ljubljani, Fakulteta za upravo
(Obvezni izvod spletne publikacije)
description
Purpose: The right to an oral hearing is an essential element of Article 6 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. This is particularly emphasised in administrative procedures where the parties are in a hierarchical relationship. The absence of an oral hearing can significantly limit a party’s right to a fair trial. Therefore, this paper aims to explore the positive law and state of play in the Republic of Slovenia and the Republic of Croatia regarding the right to an oral hearing. The purpose of this paper is to analyse relevant legislation and case law with the goal of proposing future legislation that better aligns with effective legal protection. Design/Methodology/Approach: Desk research was conducted to analyse current legal solutions and case law using sociological research methods. These involved analysing domestic and international legal texts and reviewing the rules governing national administrative procedures in the countries included in the research, as well as against decisions of the European Court of Human Rights. In addition, the research used a combination of primary and secondary data sources. Findings: Administrative courts should prioritise procedural justice and equality of arms, even when there is no clear need for oral hearings, especially if one of the parties requests to appear before the court. To minimise damaging discretion, both parties should consent to relinquishing the right to an oral hearing, which should be mandatory by default. Academic contribution to the field: The primary contribution of this paper lies in its de lege ferenda suggestions regarding the right to an oral hearing, which could potentially enhance the protection of human rights in relation to a fair trial in both administrative disputes and administrative procedures. Originality/Value: This research is original as it presents a comparative analysis of administrative procedure and disputes in selected Member States. To the best of the author’s knowledge, no such comparative study has been conducted before. The findings of this research could have significant value as they highlight the need for improving procedural justice and equality of arms in ensuring a fair trial in administrative disputes.
Rights
URN
URN:NBN:SI:DOC-P80NR77K
COBISSID
178327299
DOI
10.17573/cepar.2023.2.07
Added
07.06.2024
Metadata
Citation
APA:
Rašić, Mario (2023). Absence of an oral hearing in administrative disputes.
Central European Public Administration Review
, volume 21, issue 2, str. 141-164, 170
.
URN:NBN:SI:DOC-P80NR77K
from http://www.dlib.si
MLA:
Rašić, Mario. "Absence of an oral hearing in administrative disputes."
Central European Public Administration Review
volume 21. issue 2 (2023) str. 141-164, 170.
<http://www.dlib.si/?URN=URN:NBN:SI:DOC-P80NR77K>
Central European public administration review
2018-
(Assembly record)