7 ANNALES · Ser. hist. nat. · 27 · 2017 · 1 original scientifi c article DOI 10.19233/ASHN.2017.02 received: 2017-02-16 DITTRICHIA GRAVEOLENS – HOW DOES SOIL SALINITY DETERMINE DISTRIBUTION, MORPHOLOGY, AND REPRODUCTIVE POTENTIAL? Nina ŠAJNA Faculty of Natural Sciences and Mathematics University of Maribor, Koroška 160, Maribor, Slovenia nina.sajna@um.si Kristijan ADAMLJE Faculty of Natural Sciences and Mathematics University of Maribor, Koroška 160, Maribor, Slovenia Mitja KALIGARIČ Faculty of Natural Sciences and Mathematics University of Maribor, Koroška 160, Maribor, Slovenia & Faculty of Life Sciences, 2311 Pivola, Slovenia ABSTRACT Road salting in winter, which improves the safety of road travel, has a strong impact on species inhabiting road verges, since it creates habitats with increased salinity. Higher levels of soil salinity represent a habitat that can be occupied by plants exhibiting special adaptations and tolerance. As a result, Dittrichia graveolens, which is indigenous in the Mediterranean area, is moving inland and can be found in several Central European countries. We studied how soil salinity determines the D. graveolens plant height, reproductive potential and distribution along the road verge. Plant height was related to soil electrical conductivity (EC) – a measure for salinity. Our results show that the species grows best in soils where the EC ranges from 110 to 170 µS/cm, while at values less than 100 µS/ cm, no plants were observed. Key words: invasive species, road verges, road salting, Slovenia DITTRICHIA GRAVEOLENS – COME LA SALINITÀ DEL SUOLO DETERMINA DISTRIBUZIONE, MORFOLOGIA E POTENZIALITÀ RIPRODUTTIVA DELLA SPECIE? SINTESI La salatura delle strade in inverno, che migliora la sicurezza dei viaggi, ha un forte impatto sulle specie che vivono sui bordi stradali, in quanto crea habitat con salinità elevata. I livelli più alti di salinità del suolo caratterizzano un habitat che può essere occupato da piante che presentano adattamenti e tolleranze speciali. Di conseguenza, Dittrichia graveolens, pianta indigena nell’area mediterranea, si sta muovendo verso l’interno e può essere trovata in diversi paesi dell’Europa centrale. Gli autori hanno studiato come la salinità del suolo determina l’altezza della pianta di D. graveolens, il potenziale riproduttivo e la distribuzione lungo il bordo stradale. L’altezza della pianta è legata alla conduttività elettrica del suolo (CE) – una misura per la salinità. I risultati mostrano che la specie cresce meglio su terreni in cui la CE varia da 110 a 170 µS/cm, mentre dove i valori sono inferiori a 100 µS/cm non sono state osservate piante. Parole chiave: specie invasiva, bordi stradali, salatura delle strade, Slovenia 8 ANNALES · Ser. hist. nat. · 27 · 2017 · 1 Nina ŠAJNA et al.: DITTRICHIA GRAVEOLENS – HOW DOES SOIL SALINITY DETERMINE DISTRIBUTION, ..., 7–12 INTRODUCTION The introductions of the majority of naturalized alien plants to Europe has happened since 1750 (Williamson et al., 2009) and has resulted in the establishment of more than 3700 species, while the current invasion rate is estimated at 6.2 new species per year (Lambdon et al., 2008). These species belong to more than 200 plant families, among which Asteraceae, Poaceae, Rosaceae and Brassicaceae are predominant (Pyšek et al., 2009). These are large families with many species represen- tatives known to be weeds. Approximately one half of naturalized alien plants in Europe are alien plants from another continent (e.g. North and South America, Asia), while the other half is represented by species from an- other part of Europe, where the plants are native. Many of common agricultural weeds invasive in Europe are also native to the Mediterranean (Pyšek et al., 2009). There are numerous routes and vectors for alien species introduction; however, we focus here on high- ways, which represent an opportunity for introduction into a new region and at the same time promote further dispersal with the help of vehicular transportation along road corridors (Pollnac et al., 2012 and references therein). In Central Europe several invasive species are known as “Autobahn-Pfl anzen”, among them Dittri- chia graveolens (L.) Greuter (syn. Inula graveolens (L.) Desf.), Senecio inaequidens DC. and Atriplex micrantha Ledeb. – examples of alien plant species which are able to spread rapidly along roads (Heger & Böhmer, 2006). Even though highways are highly disturbed, stressful, and fragmenting structures in the human-dominated landscape, their maintenance results in the creation of road verges – often dry, sunny, nutrient-poor and grav- el-like habitats, which are dominated by environmental conditions different from most natural habitats in their vicinity. Additionally, human activities can impact road verges in such way that they represent a new, artifi cial habitat, one not previously existing. They exhibit altered physical and chemical soil characteristics; for example, texture, compaction, water content, leakage of deicing chemicals causing salinity, nitrogen deposition and pollution (Thompson et al., 1986; Cale & Hobbs, 1991; Truscott et al., 2005). Additionally, they represent highly disturbed habitats for plants because of repeated distur- bance from maintenance like mowing, shrub clearing or herbicide application (Gelbard & Belnap, 2003). The use of deicing chemicals has a profound impact on road verge habitats, since it can cause soil salinity and saline spray, directly impacting standing vegetation. Therefore, such habitats can be occupied by plants exhibiting special adaptations or tolerance, among which maritime species are particularly successful (Scott & Davison, 1982). Invasions have been reported for Spergularia me- dia and S. marina (Kocián, 2015b), Atriplex micrantha (Smettan, 2002), the grasses Puccinellia distans, P. ma- ritima, P. fasciculata, Aster tripolium, Plantago maritima and P. coronopus (Scott & Davison, 1982) and many more. Additionally, such habitats are less likely to be dominated by numerous native plants. The combination of a high variety of non-native seeds transported along roads and the presence of road verge habitats sparsely occupied by native species makes road verges into opportunity habitats for alien plants. We were therefore interested in the occurrence of a plant of southern origin, annual species Dittrichia graveolens, which has been spreading along Slovenian highways. It is distributed across the central part of the country where there is a harsher climate, while it does not occur in the coastal region of Slovenia (Frajman & Kaligarič, 2009), where a closely related perennial, D. viscosa, can be found native to Istria (Wraber, 1999; Jogan et al., 2001). We hypothesized that D. graveolens is not a particularly good competitor, and therefore not present in the sub-Mediterranean region, while at the same time it is tolerant of higher concentrations of salinity, which enables its establishment further north because of winter road maintenance with deicers. MATERIAL AND METHODS Study species Dittrichia graveolens is an annual herbaceous plant in the family Asteraceae. It reaches heights of 10 to 50 cm (own observation). Leaves and stem, as well as the capitulum involucre are densely glandular and hairy. Yellow fl owers are female if lingulate and hermaph- rodite if tubular (Brullo & de Marco, 2000). In Central Europe the fl owering occurs from September to October (Kocián, 2015a). Achenes are 1.8-2 mm long, with a 4 mm pappus (Brullo & de Marco, 2000). It is native to the Mediterranean basin and partly to the Western Atlantic coast and the Middle East (Brullo & de Marco, 2000). It has invaded other European regions and regions of the world with similar climates, including California, Aus- tralia and New Zealand (Preston, 2006). In Slovenia it was fi rst observed in 2008 along Highways A1 from Šen- tilj to Koper and A2 from Karavanke tunnel to Obrežje, with its densest stands on the A1 between Ljubljana and Blagovica, and between Vransko and Slovenske Konjice (Frajman & Kaligarič, 2009). It grows on road verges as well as in the central reserve. Substrate sampling and salinity measurements At the end of September and the beginning of Octo- ber in 2009, we selected parts of Highway A1 (connect- ing Šentilj and Koper, passing Maribor, Ljubljana) for the collection of plants and substrate samples. The road has two lanes in each direction and a central reserve overgrown by taller vegetation. The fi rst site was located 1 km from the highway service area at Lukovica in the 9 ANNALES · Ser. hist. nat. · 27 · 2017 · 1 Nina ŠAJNA et al.: DITTRICHIA GRAVEOLENS – HOW DOES SOIL SALINITY DETERMINE DISTRIBUTION, ..., 7–12 direction of Trojane. A dense stand of D. graveolens plants extended for several kilometers along the entire road verge. The second site was located at the Ravne service area near Kozina. No continuous stands were observed there. Individuals of D. graveolens were found in smaller, discrete groups, only occasionally in dense stands along shorter road segments. Substrate samples were collected directly at the road margin to a maximum of 50 cm away, as the closest sample to the road, and then at distances 100 cm, 120 cm, and 200 cm perpendicularly to the road margin. In this direction, a prominent gradient in plant height was observed (Fig. 1). At both locations, soil samples were collected from plots where D. graveolens was present. We collected 1 kg of substrate sample on each site for salinity analysis. For the two control samples, we collected the substrate at Kozina from sites where no D. graveolens individuals were sighted. Samples were sieved to remove larger stones, mixed with deionized water in a ratio of 1:9 and shaken for 1 h. The conductivity of the prepared solution was measured by a portable conductometer MA 5950 (Metrel, Slove- nia) at room temperature (20 °C) after the solution had been allowed to settle for 30 min. Conductivity readings were corrected regarding the temperature at which they were taken, if necessary. For comparison of substrate salinity along the dis- tance away from the road, a Welch-ANOVA was used to test for signifi cant differences, since the results yielded heterogeneous variances according to Levene’s test. Reproductive potential of D. graveolens In evaluating the reproductive potential of D. gra- veolens plants, we recognized three categories of plant height: 1 – from 5 to 15 cm; 2 – from 16 to 25 cm; 3 – larger than 25 cm. The potential reproductive success of D. graveolens plants was estimated by counting the number of fl ower heads per plant in each category. Av- erage seed (achene) number per single fl ower head was estimated after counting seeds for 50 randomly selected fl ower heads for each height category, which were collected in Lukovica. The data obtained were used for calculating the total seed number for an individual plant. RESULTS Observation on sites with D. graveolens stands showed that plant height and plant density increase with distance from the road margin. Differences were also observed in the abundance of D. graveolens plants be- tween the Lukovica and Kozina locations. Additionally, as expected, those sites without D. graveolens in Kozina showed the lowest salinity values. The salinity of the substrate at Lukovica changed signifi cantly within the 2 m distance next to the road (Welch ANOVA at p>0.05; Fig. 2), because of lower salinity fi gures at a distance of 1 m. However, if we exclude those measurements within 50 cm of the road, an increase in salinity was observed from 1 m to 2 m away from the road margin – in the same direction as plant size increased. Up to 50 cm away, individual plants were 5 to 15 cm tall; from 1 to 1.5 m distance from the road, plants reached 10 to 30 cm of height, Fig. 1: Increasing height of Dittrichia graveolens indi- viduals away from the road margin at the Lukovica site. Sl. 1: Višina osebkov vrste Dittrichia graveolens narašča z oddaljenostjo od cestnega roba na lokaciji Lukovica. Fig. 2: Mean salinity values of the substrate away from the road margin were signifi cantly different within the 2 m distance (Welch ANOVA, p<0.05) at the Lukovica location. Different letters indicate signifi cantly differ- ent means. Sl. 2: Srednje vrednosti slanosti substrata so se statistič- no značilno (Welcheva ANOVA, p<0,05) razlikovale z oddaljenostjo od cestnega roba znotraj razdalje 2 m na lokaciji Lukovica. Različne črke označujejo statistično značilno različne srednje vrednosti. 10 ANNALES · Ser. hist. nat. · 27 · 2017 · 1 Nina ŠAJNA et al.: DITTRICHIA GRAVEOLENS – HOW DOES SOIL SALINITY DETERMINE DISTRIBUTION, ..., 7–12 and more than 2 m away, some individuals were taller than 40 cm. Plants grew in soils with salinity from 110 to 237 µS/cm at both locations. Average soil salinity on two sites in Kozina without D. graveolens plants was 97 and 82 µS/cm. Dittrichia graveolens plants showed high reproduc- tive potential, which increased with the plant’s height and differed signifi cantly among height categories (Welch ANOVA, p<0.05; Fig. 3). The average number of seeds (achenes) in a single fl ower head was 30 seeds, and it showed low variability among individuals of different size. According to that, estimated seed production of plants was about 90 seeds per plant in the fi rst and 4380 seeds per plant in the third height category. In relation to distance to the road margin, in its near proximity plants produced on average 500 seeds; however, even at 1 m distance we found plants exhibiting high reproductive potential with more than 2000 seeds per plant. DISCUSSION Deicing chemicals, which help to improve road safety, are regularly used on Highway A1 during winter. However, we expected that on road segments toward the south of the country deicing salts would be less fre- quently used because of the rarer incidence of snowfall and freezing conditions. Even though the sampling was rather simple, our results indicate that the occurrence of D. graveolens might be connected to increased soil salinity values. Less densely developed and not contin- uously occurring D. graveolens stands were observed in the southern part of this motorway. On all the sites with D. graveolens plants, salinity was higher, while at values below 100 µS/cm, no plants were observed. Dittrichia graveolens, besides being halotolerant for soil salinity, has an additional competitive advantage over native plants: it is an annual species, surviving winter as seeds that can avoid the direct negative impact of saline spray, which perennial native species would have to endure. Additionally, the salinity gradient measured at the road verge corresponds with previous similar reports, showing a sharp decline in soil salinity over the fi rst 2 m distance from salted roads (Thompson et al., 1986). Our results show that the saline opportunity habitat for D. graveolens is located only on a narrow strip 1 m or less from the road, up to the distance where the decline in salinity enables the native, more competitive species to begin to dominate the habitat. The rarer occurrence of D. graveolens in the southern part of the highway, which lies in a region with a sub-Mediterranean climate, suggests that the establishment of D. graveolens in less saline soil is limited because the species is a weak com- petitor compared to native sub-Mediterranean species and not because of unsuitable climatic conditions. This is furthermore underpinned by numerous records of D. graveolens along the roads in those Central European countries (Kocián, 2015a) that have a rather cold cli- mate. Our results also show that plants 1 m from the road were already 30 cm high, and these were the plants showing the highest seed production. Our previous studies on Aster squamatus, we stressed that one char- acteristic that can be key for successful invasion of alien invasive Asteraceae, especially if they can become established in less productive habitats (including saline or semi-saline habitats), is the late onset of fl owering Fig. 3: Reproductive potential of D. graveolens plants, collected in Lukovica, from different height categories (1: 5–15 cm; 2: 16–25 cm; 3: >25 cm) measured through the number of fl ower heads per single plant. Sl. 3: Reproduktivni potencial D. graveolens na lokaciji Lukovica izmerjen kot število koškov na posamezno rastlino, ki so pripadale trem velikostnim razredom (1: 5–15 cm; 2: 16–25 cm; 3: >25 cm). Fig. 4: Dry fruiting Dittrichia graveolens plants at the Kozina location on 25th October 2009. Sl. 4: Posušene plodeče rastline D. graveolens opazo- vane 25. oktobra 2009 na lokaciji Kozina. 11 ANNALES · Ser. hist. nat. · 27 · 2017 · 1 Nina ŠAJNA et al.: DITTRICHIA GRAVEOLENS – HOW DOES SOIL SALINITY DETERMINE DISTRIBUTION, ..., 7–12 (Šajna et al., 2014; Šajna 2016). Dittrichia graveolens starts to fl ower in September, and fl owering lasts until October (Kocián, 2015a). We observed several dried fruiting plants at full height (Fig. 4). This is an indication that fully developed plants, able to produce seeds, are rarely impacted by mowing during road verge maintenance because mow- ing happens too early and because larger plants grow in the depression of the road verge, away from the road margin. Location by the road represents immediate potential for seed dispersal via the slipstream of passing vehicles (von der Lippe et al., 2013), while the road corridor functions as a route of secondary dispersal. Such dispersal via traffi c, enabling very rapid and often unnoticed invasions, has been recorded for many inva- sive plant species (von der Lippe & Kowarik, 2007). ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank two anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments and corrections, which improved the previ- ous version of the manuscript. M. Kaligarič acknowl- edges the support of the P1-0164 grant, funded by the Slovenian Research Agency. DITTRICHIA GRAVEOLENS – KAKO SLANOST TAL DOLOČA NJENO RAZŠIRJENOST, MORFOLOGIJO IN REPRODUKTIVNI POTENCIAL? Nina ŠAJNA Faculty of Natural Sciences and Mathematics University of Maribor, Koroška 160, Maribor, Slovenia nina.sajna@um.si Kristijan ADAMLJE Marnova ulica 31, 1410 Zagorje ob Savi, Slovenia Mitja KALIGARIČ Faculty of Natural Sciences and Mathematics University of Maribor & Faculty of Life Sciences, 2311 Pivola, Slovenia POVZETEK Soljenje cest pozimi pripomore k varnosti prometa, a ima močan vpliv na vrste, ki poseljujejo cestne robove. Ustvarja rastišča s slanimi tlemi, ki jih lahko poselijo rastline s posebnimi prilagoditvami in toleranco na slanost. Tak primer je avtohtona mediteranska vrsta Dittrichia graveolens, ki se ob cestnih robovih seli v osrednjo Evropo in jo najdemo že v mnogih državah. Proučevali smo, kako slanost tal določa višino rastlin D. graveolens, njihov reproduktivni potencial in razširjenost ob cestnem robu. Višina rastlin je bila odvisna od električne prevodnosti (EC) tal – merilo za slanost. Naši rezultati kažejo, da vrsta najbolje uspeva v tleh z vrednostmi EC med 110 in 170 µS/ cm, medtem ko je pri vrednostih pod 100 µS/cm nismo opazili. Uspeli smo identifi cirati tri velikostne razrede, ki se razlikujejo v reproduktivnem potencialu. Ključne besede: invazivna vrsta, cestni rob, soljenje cest, Slovenija 12 ANNALES · Ser. hist. nat. · 27 · 2017 · 1 Nina ŠAJNA et al.: DITTRICHIA GRAVEOLENS – HOW DOES SOIL SALINITY DETERMINE DISTRIBUTION, ..., 7–12 REFERENCES Brullo, S. & G. de Marco (2000): Taxonomical re- vision of the genus Dittrichia (Asteraceae). Portugaliae Acta Biol., 19, 341-354. Cale, P. & R. Hobbs (1991): Condition of roadside vegetation in relation to nutrient status. In: Saunders, D.A. & R.J. Hobbs (eds.): Nature conservation 2: The role of corridors, Surrey Beatty & Sons, Chipping Nor- ton, pp. 353-362. Frajman, B. & M. Kaligarič (2009): Dittrichia grave- olens, nova tujerodna vrsta slovenske fl ore. Hladnikia, 24, 35-43. Gelbard, J.L. & J. Belnap (2003): Roads as conduits for exotic plant invasions in a semiarid landscape. Con- serv. Biol., 17, 420-432. Heger, T. & H.J. Böhmer (2006): NOBANIS – In- vasive Alien Species Fact Sheet – Senecio inaequidens. – From: Online Database of the European Network on Invasive Alien Species – NOBANIS www.nobanis.org. Date of access 23/11/2016 Jogan, N., T. Bačič, B. Frajman, I. Leskovar, D. Na- glič, A. Podobnik, B. Rozman, S. Strgulc Krajšek & B. Trčak (2001): Gradivo za Atlas fl ore Slovenije. Center za kartografi jo favne in fl ore, Miklavž na Dravskem polju, 443 pp. Kocián, P. (2015a): Dittrichia graveolens (L.) Greuter – a new alien species in Poland. Acta Musei Silesiae, Scientiae Naturales, 64, 193-197. Kocián, P. (2015b): Novelties in the roadside fl ora of Moravia and Silesia (Czech Republic) –1. Spergularia media. Acta Musei Silesiae, Scientiae Naturales, 64, 263-267. Lambdon, P.W., P. Pyšek, C. Basnou, M. Hejda, M. Arianoutsou, F. Essl, V. Jarosik, J. Pergl, M. Winter, P. Anastasiu, P. Andriopoulos, I. Bazos, G. Brundu, L. Celesti-Grapow, P. Chassot, P. Delipetrou, M. Josefsson, S. Kark, S. Klotz, Y. Kokkoris, I. Kühn, H. Marchante, I. Perglova, J. Pino, M. Vilà, A. Zikos, D. Roy & P.E. Hulme (2008): Alien fl ora of Europe: species diversity, tempo- ral trends, geographical patterns and research needs. Preslia, 80, 101-149. Pollnac, F., T. Seipel, C. Repath & L.J. Rew (2012): Plant invasion at landscape and local scales along roadways in the mountainous region of the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem. Biol. Invasions, 14, 1753-1763. Preston, R.E. (2006): Dittrichia. In: Flora of North America Editorial Committee (eds.): Flora of North America North of Mexico, Vols. 19-21. Oxford Univer- sity Press, New York and Oxford, 473 pp. Pyšek, P., P.W. Lambdon, M. Arianoutsou, I. Kühn, J. Pino & M. Winter (2009): Alien vascular plants of Eu- rope. In: Handbook of Alien Species in Europe. DAISIE (eds.): Springer, pp. 43-61. Smettan, H.W. (2002): Klebriger Alant (Dittrichia graveolens) und Verschiedensamige Melde (Atriplex micrantha) am Autobahnmittelstreifen in Südbayern. Ber. Bayer. Bot. Ges., 72, 111-116. Šajna, N., M. Kaligarič & D. Ivajnšič (2014): Re- production biology of an alien invasive plant: a case of drought-tolerant Aster squamatus on the Northern Adriatic seacoast, Slovenia. In: Rannow, S. & M. Neu- bert (eds.): Managing protected areas in Central and Eastern Europe under climate change, Advances in global change research, Vol. 58. Springer, Dordrecht, pp. 279-288. Šajna, N. (2016): Alien plant species invading rare and protected habitats in Slovenia. In: I.S. Travlos (ed.): Weed and pest control - molecular biology, practices and environmental impact, Nova Publishers, New York, pp. 35-54. Scott, N.E. & A.W. Davison (1982): De-icing salt and the invasion of road verges by maritime plants. Watso- nia, 14, 41-52. Thompson, J.R., A.J. Rutter & P.S. Ridout (1986): The salinity of motorway soils. 2. Distance from the carriage- way and other sources of local variation in salinity. J. Appl. Ecol., 23, 269-280. Truscott, A.M., S.C.F. Palmer, G.M. McGowan, J.N. Cape & S. Smart (2005): Vegetation composition of roadside verges in Scotland: the effects of nitrogen deposition, disturbance and management. Environ. Pollut., 136, 109-118. von der Lippe, M., J.M. Bullock, I. Kowarik, T. Knopp & M. Wichmann (2013): Human-mediated dispersal of seeds by the airfl ow of vehicles. PLOS ONE 8: e52733. von der Lippe, M. & I. Kowarik (2007): Long-dis- tance dispersal of plants by vehicles as a driver of plant invasions. Conserv. Biol., 21, 986-996. Williamson, M., K. Dehnen-Schmutz, I. Kühn, M. Hill, S. Klotz, A. Milbau, A., J. Stout & P. Pyšek (2009): The distribution of range sizes of native and alien plants in four European countries and the effects of residence time. Divers. Distrib., 15, 158-166. Wraber, T. (1999): Dittrichia. In: Martinčič, A., T. Wraber, N. Jogan, V. Ravnik, A. Podobnik, B. Turk & B. Vreš (eds.): Mala fl ora Slovenije, Tehniška založba Slovenije, Ljubljana, pp. 558.