RELATION BETWEEN TWO AEROBIC CAPACITY TESTS AND COMPETITIVE SUCCESSFULNESS OF JUNIOR TENNIS PLAYERS POVEZAVA MED DVEMA TESTOMA AEROBNIH KAPACITET IN TEKMOVALNO USPEŠNOSTJO MLADIH TENIŠKIH IGRALCEV Aleš Filipčič 1 Srečo Završki 2 5 Filipčič, A., & Završki, S. (2002). Relation between two aerobic capacity tests and competitive successfulness… KinSI 8(1), 5–9 Abstract A sample of 42 tennis players, between 12 and 14 years of age, performed a laboratory test on a treadmill and a running test on an athletic track. Both were used to measure aerobic capacity of the subjects. Two predictive variables were chosen ma- ximal O 2 consumption, running test on 2400 m and a criterion variable – competitive successfulness. The correlation between the predictive variables and competitive successfulness was analysed with the Pearson correlation coefficient. The results show that the correlation of competitive successful- ness with running endurance and aerobic power is weak, but statistically significant. Keywords: tennis, endurance, competitive success- fulness, correlation Contact address 1 Aleš Filipčič University of Ljubljana – Faculty of Sport Gortanova 22 SI-1000 Ljubljana Slovenia Phone: +386 1 520-77-00 Fax: + 386 1 520-77-50 E-mail: Ales.Filipcic@sp.uni-lj.si 2 (High School Jurij Vega, Idrija) Izvleček Na vzorcu 42 teniških igralcev, starih od 12 do 14 let, sta bila opravljena laboratorijski test na tekoči preprogi ter tekaški test na atletski stezi. Z obema smo želeli izmeriti aerobne kapacitete merjencev in ugotoviti kakšna je možnost napovedovanja tek- movalne uspešnosti ob pomoči obeh testov. Izbra- li smo dve napovedni spremenljivki – maksimalna poraba kisika, tekaški test na 2400 m in eno krite- rijsko spremenljivko (tekmovalna uspešnost). Pove- zanost med izbranima spremenljivkama in tekmo- valno uspešnostjo v tenisu je bila analizirana s Pearsonovim korelacijskim koeficientom. Rezultati kažejo, da so povezave med tekmovalno uspe- šnostjo in tekaško vzdržljivostjo ter aerobno moč- jo šibko izražene, vendar statistično značilne. Niz- ka in statistično neznačilna povezanost se kaže med obema napovednima spremenljivkama. Ključne besede: tenis, vzdržljivost, tekmovalna us- pešnost, povezanost (Received: 18. 08. 1999 – Accepted: 18. 04. 2002) Introduction Body movement during a tennis game is determi- ned by the volume, intensity and player’s tactics. The amount of work is determined by the length of a match, the number of performed shots, the num- ber of played points, games and sets, and the total distance the player covers on the court during a match. The intensity depends primarily on playing surface and the velocity of the ball in flight – which affects the frequency of shots – and on the breaks between the individual points, games and sets. In the game, various modes of movement occur: run- ning forward, backward, running sideways with stepping across and with forward paces, fast starts, various types of jumps and turning movements, as well as sliding and falling (Filipčič, 1990). Measurements of metabolism in tennis point more to an anaerobic–alactate and lactate consumption of energy; however, it is necessary to emphasise that tennis matches can last several hours, which means that due to the limited processes, the mode of energy consumption during the game varies. A top tennis player must therefore have well develo- ped both anaerobic and aerobic energy mecha- nisms. In the active part of the tennis game the en- ergy processes are mainly anaerobic. The results obtained in the tests carried out by German experts have shown that the values of the measured lacta- tes for tennis players during the game are in the range between 3 and 12 mmol/l (Weber, 1989). The values of lactate are slightly higher in playing on fast courts, where movements and activities of tennis players are of very high intensity and short duration. The functional dimension occurring in a tennis match can be defined in terms of the distribution of time between play and breaks, and in the intensity of the activity itself. The measurements of time pa- rameters have shown that the effective part of the game represents 20 – 30 % of the total duration of the tennis match on slow surfaces, while on faster surfaces the percentage of the play is even lower. A point on a clay court lasts on an average from 6 to 8 seconds, while on grass and fast surfaces the average duration of a point is from 4 to 6 seconds. Tennis players exchange the ball on an average 2.9 times in this time. The remaining time is used for changing sides, interruptions and for resting (Schönborn, 1999). Maximal aerobic processes occur in a tennis match to a smaller extent. It is typical for these processes to take place in the presence of oxygen and be li- mited in time. Although maximal activation of ae- robic processes in tennis is not necessary, these processes are very important for the development of the tennis contest and for the training process of tennis players, and above all, for younger tennis players, where the intensity of the tennis game is lo- wer. Aerobic processes find full expression espe- cially in very long – several hours – lasting matc- hes. Known data on Dutch players, shows that the optimal value of VO 2 max for top male adult players is between 63 and 67 ml/kg/min, and for female players between 53 and 57 ml/kg/min. Alongside these values, they also found that at this level, furt- her development of aerobic capacities can reflect negatively on abilities, where speed is important (Pluim, 2000). In the current study we were interested to assess the possibility of predicting competitive successful- ness with a laboratory test on a treadmill and a 2400 m running test on an athletic track. Maximal aerobic power namely tells us about the capacity of the aerobic energy processes, while running endu- rance is a specific psychomotor ability. We namely wished to find out if the duration of a tennis match, which can last for quite a while, is correlated with the running endurance of a young tennis player. The existence of such a relation would namely lead to a conclusion that endurance in tennis can be im- proved with exercise, where running has a relati- vely large role. This interest was entirely practical, namely, which one of these two procedures to use for monitoring athletes’ state of preparedness in the specified field. Methods Subjects The sample of subjects consisted of 42 active ten- nis players in the category of boys, 12 to 14 years of age. The study covered only the players fulfilling the following conditions: • that they were ranked on the scale of the Tennis Association of Slovenia in the category of boys up to the age of 14; • that they were included in the process of regular training; • that they completed the test relevant to the re- search. 6 Filipčič, A., & Završki, S. (2002). Relation between two aerobic capacity tests and competitive successfulness… KinSI 8(1), 5–9 Procedures The measurements lasted two days. On the first day the subjects completed the treadmill test, on the second day the test at the track. The functional test was carried out on a treadmill (Woodway) for analysing the cardio-respiratory, er- go-spirometric and metabolic parameters (Oxycon Beta). Description of the test: The subject begins the run at a speed of 6 km/h. The first four minutes he runs at this speed. After running for four minutes, the speed is increased to 9 km/h. The subject then runs four minutes at this speed. After running for four minutes, the slope of the treadmill is increased by 5 degrees, and the speed decreases to 8 km/h. The speed of the treadmill increases in the continuation of the test by 1 km/h per minute. The measured subject perseveres in carrying out the test up to the level of his maximal abilities. In setting up the protocol of the tests, the standards recommended by American College of Sports Me- dicine (Lea & Febiger, 1986) have been observed. maximal O 2 consumption (ml/min), in the RT2400 (running test 2400 m) the result was the time (se- conds) in which the subjects covered the 2400 m distance. Criterion Variable In defining the criterion variable we have taken in- to account all competitions of boys up to 14 years of age, which took place in the period of one com- petitive season (the last 52 weeks). The players had different numbers of tournaments, so we selected the most suitable criterion variable CS (competiti- ve successfulness), which determines the relations- hip between the number of the collected points in tournaments and the number of tournaments pla- yed. Since certain departures from linearity were observed, we used the logarithm of the criterion to linearise the association between the predictors and the criterion. Data analysis The collected data was processed by means of the SPSS program package for Windows (Release 11.0). To establish the influence of predictor variab- les on competitive successfulness, descriptive sta- tistics and Pearson product-moment correlation were used. Results 7 Filipčič, A., & Završki, S. (2002). Relation between two aerobic capacity tests and competitive successfulness… KinSI 8(1), 5–9 Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation Skewness Kurtosis Kolmogorov– Sig. Smirnov Test VO 2 max 1475 3885 2530.00 611.21 .328 -.424 .993 .135 RT 2400 532 868 640.61 68.10 1.331 2.971 .135 .993 CS -3.51 3.18 -.6312 1.89765 .024 -1.203 .668 .668 Table 1: Descriptive Statistics Table 2: Correlations between predictor variables and criterion variable CS VO 2 max CS Pearson Correlation Sig. (2-tailed) VO 2 max Pearson Correlation .519 Sig. (2-tailed) .000 RT 2400 Pearson Correlation –.429 –.104 Sig. (2-tailed) .000 .513 The running test was performed on an athletic track. The subjects covered a 2400 m distance. They ran in groups of 10. Variables Two assessments of aerobic capacity were chosen. In the treadmill test we decided on the VO 2 max – General characteristics of the subject sample Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation Age /years/ 12 14 13.77 0.83 In training /years/ 1 7 4.15 1.62 Height /cm/ 139.9 184.5 159.829 9.942 Weight /kg/ 32.0 70.6 47.456 9.505 We were interested in this research in the relations- hip between aerobic power and running enduran- ce in tennis, when played by young athletes. Table 1 shows the basic statistical parameters. The values of Kolmogorov-Smirnov test show a normal distri- bution of the results in all three used variables. The correlations between the variables (Table 2) show a medium high and statistically significant as- sociation between CS, VO 2 max and RT2400. The variable VO 2 max has a somewhat higher correla- tion with the criterion. Discussion If we inspect the correlation of both predictor va- riables with the criterion also graphically we can conclude that the correlation between VO 2 max and CS (Fig. 1) is weak, even if statistically signifi- cant, as can be seen from the great dispersion of the results at the individual values of competitive successfulness. The correlation between RT2400 and CS (Fig. 2) is weak, negative, but logically positive and statisti- cally significant. It would be very difficult to claim that there is any sort of dependence, leading to a conclusion that CS might be in any way dependent on running endurance. This leads us to the conclu- sion that CS depends more on other factors, which were not analysed in this research. The correlation between VO 2 max and RT2400 (Fig. 3) is weak (-.104), negative, but logically positive and statistically non-significant. This is because young tennis players are not runners, are not moti- vated for running, therefore their results do not ex- press just their aerobic capacity, but include also their (non)motivation for running. All this leads us to conclude that the correlation of both variables (RT2400 and VO 2 max) with the cri- terion variable (SC) is statistically significant, but weak (Fig. 1 and 2). The lowest correlation is bet- ween the two predictor variables. Competitive suc- cessfulness is therefore less dependent on aerobic power and running endurance and more on fac- tors, which were not dealt with in this study. The analysis of the association of both predictor va- riables with the criterion showed that it is not pos- sible to predict competitive successfulness of young tennis players well enough with these two tests of aerobic capacity, which was also the reason 8 Filipčič, A., & Završki, S. (2002). Relation between two aerobic capacity tests and competitive successfulness… KinSI 8(1), 5–9 Fig. 1: Correlation between VO 2 max and CS Fig. 2: Correlation between RT2400 and CS Fig. 3: Correlation between RT2400 and VO 2 max why multiple regression analysis was not perfor- med. The reasons for the rather low predictive po- wer lie probably in the characteristics of the used subject sample and the characteristics of tennis and the factors, which are important determinants of success in tennis. It is possible that the analysed sample of young tennis players is inappropriate from the age point of view, too small and hetero- geneous. The main reasons for the weak correla- tion probably lie with the bad aerobic power of young tennis players. Competitive successfulness does not have a marked association with aerobic power or running endurance, which can lead us to conclude that some other kind of endurance is more important already for the younger categories of tennis players. Recent analyses of duration of points in matches of elite tennis players on surfaces of medium speed show that 86% of the points are shorter than 10 s in duration and 14% of the points last from 10 to 25 s (Schönborn, 1999). In light of this data on elite tennis players, we can conclude with high certainty that anaerobic endurance has an important role already for young tennis players. It is therefore necessary to determine precisely the optimal level of development of aerobic enduran- ce, which would enable the players to overcome the workloads of longer duration in the training process and competitions. It would probably be useful in future to try two things: repeat both measurement procedures on a larger sample of adult tennis players and perform a similar study in the field of anaerobic endurance of tennis players. References 1. Filipčič, A. (1990). Oris problematike razvijanja vzdržljivosti teniških igralcev [An Outline of the Problems Related to the Development of Endurance in Tennis Players]. Ljubljana: Fakulteta za šport. 2. Lea, A., & Febiger, B. (1986). Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription (3 rd Ed.). Indianapolis: ACSM (American College of Sports Medicine). 3. Pluim, B. M. (2000). Exercise Physiology. Amsterdam: Royal Net- herlands Lawn Tennis Association. 4. Schönborn, R. (1999). Advanced Techniques for Competitive Ten- nis. Aachen: Meyer und Meyer Sport. 5. Weber, K. (1989). Theory and practise of tennis-specific enduran- ce. ITF Coaches Review, 1 (5), 7-14. 9 Filipčič, A., & Završki, S. (2002). Relation between two aerobic capacity tests and competitive successfulness… KinSI 8(1), 5–9