41 © aut hor/aut horsht t ps://doi .org /10. 26493/2350-54 43.13(1)41-62 Sensory Representations of Plague: The Plague Altar from the Mid-18th Century in St Andrew’s Church, Makole, Slovenia Čutne reprezentacije kuge: kužni oltar iz sredine 18. stoletja v cerkvi sv. Andreja v Makolah, Slovenija Mojca Ramšak University of Ljubljana, Faculty of Chemistry and Chemical Technology, Heritage Science Laboratory Univerza v Ljubljani, Fakulteta za kemijo in kemijsko tehnologijo, Laboratorij za dediščinsko znanost mojca.ramsak@guest.arnes.si Abstract The article examines the sensory experiences associated with death during the plague and contextualis- es them within a specific historical and geographical framework. The author focuses on the plague altar from the mid-eighteenth century in the Haloze Church of St Andrew in Makole, Slovenia. In particu- lar, she analyses the lower part of the altarpiece, which is attributed to an unknown artist. The plague al- tar not only conveys religious messages, but also reflects the knowledge and belief in the miasma theo- ry of the time in question, in particular the understanding of the smell of the plague, the regulations on the plague and the organisation of civil protection. These themes vividly illustrate the depictions of the plague on the altar and offer insights into society’s reactions to illness and death in this period. Keywords: plague, plague altar, smell of plague, miasma, Slovenia Izvleček Članek obravnava čutne izkušnje, povezane s smrtjo v času kuge, in jih kontekstualizira v določenem zgodovinskem ter geografskem okviru. Avtorica se osredotoča na kužni oltar iz sredine 18. stoletja v ha- loški cerkvi sv. Andreja v Makolah v Sloveniji. Analizira predvsem spodnji del oltarne slike, ki je pripisan neznanemu umetniku. Kužni oltar ne prenaša samo verskih sporočil, ampak odraža tudi znanje in vero v teorijo miazme v obravnavanem obdobju, zlasti razumevanje vonja kuge, predpisov o kugi in organi- zacije zaščite prebivalstva. Te teme nazorno ilustrirajo upodobitve kuge na oltarju in ponujajo vpogled v odzive družbe na bolezni ter smrt v tistem času. Ključne besede: kuga, kužni oltar, vonj kuge, miazma, Slovenija Introduction a) On the plague altar from Makole In June 2024, I became aware of the plague al-tar of St Sebastian in St Andrew’s Church in Makole, Slovenia, a significant historical arte- fact from the mid-eighteenth century. I was in- trigued by its role in contemporary folk religios- ity and its connection to local narratives about the plague, and arranged to visit the altar. On 22 June 2024, I conducted an interview with the parish clerk, who gave me insights into the altar’s significance today and shared stories about the plague that have survived in the community. The plague altar, which was created be- tween 1751 and 1756 by the sculptor Jožef Štraub, is a wooden altar that was restored in 2018 due to significant damage, and features polychrome statues of angels and saints, including St Charles Borromeo and St Roch, who are depicted as pa- tron saints against the plague. The altarpiece shows a painting of St Peter and St Sebastian, the latter traditionally associated with infec- tious diseases, holding arrows symbolising his martyrdom. The lower part of the altar shows a poign- ant plague scene painted by an unknown artist. st u d ia u n iv er si ta t is h er ed it a t i, le t n ik 13 (2 02 5) , š t ev il k a 1 / v o lu m e 13 (2 02 5) , n u m be r 1 42 It shows the suffering of the sick and dying, to- gether with figures carrying away the deceased or helping the sick. This artwork reflects the im- portance of protecting the living from conta- gion while also emphasising the cultural tradi- tion of honouring the dead, even in the midst of the horrors of an epidemic. The painting also shows a woman holding a handkerchief to her nose to show that she is aware of the unpleasant odour of the corpses, the burnt infected cloths and/or the risk of airborne contagion. This ges- ture is not only a sign that she recognises the mi- asma theory, which attributes the transmission of disease to foul air, but also illustrates the hu- man reaction to the devastating effects of the epidemic. The depiction of the plague at the bottom of the painting made a deep impression on me. I could well imagine the emotions it evoked in those who visited the church and heard stories about the plague that had been passed down through generations. These images, along with the sculptural representations of saints and an- gels who served as protectors against the plague, acted as a form of visual communication. Ac- cording to a church representative I spoke to, some older parishioners still occasionally pray for health at this side altar. However, there is currently a lack of information or explanation about this particular depiction. This gap exists because the altarpiece was primarily analysed from an art historical point of view. One art his- torian noted that ‘the quality of the lower part of the altarpiece’, which illustrates the effects of the epidemic, ‘is not comparable to the surrounding sculptural works on the altarpiece’ (see: Kostan- jšek Brglez 2019, 74; Šerbelj 1983, 205), which led to a greater focus on these elements. b) On altars associated with health and disease Plague epidemics are remembered in the col- lective consciousness today as the deadliest. It is therefore not surprising that the responses to them throughout history have been not only medical but also religious (Atalić 2019, 232). In the field of health and illness, altars associated with health and disease serve as powerful meta- phors for the focus and practises that individuals and communities use to promote wellness and address health challenges. These altars embody a rich tapestry of cultural meaning, interwoven with spiritual and ritual elements that emphasise their importance in the pursuit of health. Offer- ings and prayers are made at these sacred sites to implore healing and protection from illness. This reflects a deep-rooted belief in the intercon- nectedness of the physical, spiritual and commu- nal aspects of health. Figure 1: The plague altar in the church of St Andrew in Makole, Slovenia (Kostanjšek Brglez 2022b, 40). Se n so ry R ep r es en ta t io n s o f P la g u e 43 Altars associated with health and disease are consecrated structures used in various reli- gious or ceremonial traditions for the offering of sacrifices. These altars serve as the centre of rituals aimed at appeasing deities or spirits be- lieved to influence health and disease. They are often used to invoke protection from illness, ex- press gratitude for healing or ask for forgiveness to alleviate further illness. The plague altar is a particular type of altar whose concept emphasis- es the community’s desire for divine assistance in combatting plagues and epidemics and re- flects a deep spiritual connection to health and well-being. In ancient cultures such as those of Greece and Rome, altars were often dedicated to gods and goddesses associated with health, healing, and disease. Asclepius, the Greek god of medi- cine, for example, had sanctuaries where people made offerings to him in order to find healing. His sanctuaries, called ‘Asklepieia’ (in Ancient Greek Asklepieion; in Latin aesculapīum), were places where people sought healing for illnesses. According to Christopoulou-Aletra et al. (2010), over 300 Asklepieia were discovered through- out ancient Greece. Among the most famous temples were Trikka, Epidaurus, Kos, Ath- ens, Corinth and Pergamon. Asclepius’ daugh- ters were Hygeia (goddess of health, cleanliness and hygiene) and Panacea (a goddess of univer- sal remedy). In indigenous and folk religious practis- es, there were altars or sacred places dedicated to spirits or ancestors who were believed to in- fluence health and disease. Offerings could be made at these altars or rituals performed to pro- tect the community from illness. In his work The Sacred and The Profane: The Nature of Religion, published in 1987, Mircea Eliade explores the complicated connections between different re- ligious practises and their effects on health and healing. He examines how different cultures incorporate spiritual rituals, beliefs and sym- bols into their concepts of well-being and sug- gests that these practises often serve not only as a means of treating physical ailments but also as pathways to psychological and spiritual well-be- ing. Eliade’s analysis emphasises the importance of understanding health in a broader cultural and religious context. He emphasises that heal- ing is often seen as a holistic process that encom- passes body, mind and spirit. In this way, he il- luminates the ways in which religious traditions shape individuals’ perceptions of health and the methods they use to heal. In mediaeval and Renaissance Christianity, Christian communities erected altars dedicated to saints associated with healing and protection, such as St Roch or St Sebastian, during times of plague. These altars were used for prayers and pleas for deliverance from the plague. Christian communities’ most lasting evi- dence of their presence are, in particular, the votive churches built in honour of the patron saints against plague epidemics (Atalić 2019, 214). Some of the most important Christian saints who are considered patron saints against the plague are St Roch and St Sebastian, the best-known saints, but also St George, St Ed- mund, St Beat, St Barbara, St Francis Xavier, St Saturnin, St Coloman, St Anthony, St Aloysi- us Gonzaga and St Rosalia. In the Christian tra- dition, these saints are traditionally invoked to protect against the plague. In Slovenia, there are 33 churches dedicated to St Roch and around 30 churches dedicated to St Sebastian (‘Sveti Rok – romar in spokornik’ n.d.). Furthermore, in churches not dedicated to these saints, there are many plague altars with a combination of sever- al plague saints, and there are also plague signs dedicated to them all over the countryside and in towns. Obviously, plague epidemics left their mark on art. In connection with them and other dis- eases, many works of art were created in the sev- enteenth and eighteenth centuries, both out- doors and in sacred spaces. In the period in question, we can hardly find a church or parish that did not have at least one plague altar or a depiction of one of the plague patrons (Kostan- jšek Brglez 2022a, 52). Just as people in the Ba- roque period erected plague signs, churches and st u d ia u n iv er si ta t is h er ed it a t i, le t n ik 13 (2 02 5) , š t ev il k a 1 / v o lu m e 13 (2 02 5) , n u m be r 1 44 altars to commemorate the plague epidemics or to give thanks for their end, they did not give up their belief in the help of the saints later on, ei- ther (Kostanjšek Brglez 2022b, 40). c) On the method of interpretation of the plague altar In this analysis, I have drawn on Roland Barthes’ concepts of punctum and studium (Barthes 1981) to guide my exploration of the topic. My initial emotional response and personal impressions – which Barthes refers to as punctum – served as a catalyst for a more in-depth examination of the historical events and public health implications surrounding the plague in the region, which align with Barthes’ notion of studium. This dual approach allowed me to combine my subjective experiences with a broader contextual under- standing, enabling a comprehensive examina- tion of the interplay between individual percep- tion and collective historical narratives. According to Barthes (1981, 26–28), the punctum is a personal detail in a photograph that ‘pierces’ or ‘pricks’ a particular viewer and has a private meaning that has nothing to do with a cultural code. The punctum refers to those features of a photograph (in this case the painting) that seem to create or convey mean- ing without invoking a recognisable symbolic system. This kind of meaning is unique and de- pends on the reaction of the individual viewer of the image. The punctum not only pricks the viewer but also leaves a lasting bruise and evokes a deep feeling of emotion. On the other hand, studium refers to the factor that initially draws the viewer’s attention to a photograph. It refers to the intention of the photographer (in this case, the painter). The viewers can determine the studium of a photograph with their logi- cal, intellectual mind. The studium describes el- ements of an image and not the sum of the in- formation and meaning of the image. The study points to historical, social or cultural meanings that are extracted through semiotic analysis. In other words, you can recognise references to cul- ture and time in the image. Sometimes these are juxtaposed ideas that contradict each other or make a cultural or political statement, but some- times they do not. The reference may be abstract or implied. Whatever the context, it captivates the viewer. In this analysis, the two concepts are linked in such a way that punctum signifies an anthro- pological close-up perspective that reflects what the author considers important, while studi- um refers to a culturally and historically specif- ic context. The literature I have used to understand the message of the plague altar includes sourc- es such as ethnographic and historical studies, medical texts, legal documents, medical histori- cal accounts and extracts from the literature de- scribing the plague, which form a comprehen- sive basis for the interpretation of the plague altar. The Plague: Transmission, Clinical Manifestations and History a) From the history of medicine about plague The plague, caused by the bacterium identified by Alexandre Yersin in an outbreak in Hong Kong in 1894 (later named Yersinia pestis in his honour), has been responsible for major pan- demics throughout history. Understanding the different forms of plague and its transmission is crucial to understanding its devastating impact on society. The spread of the disease usually fol- lows a specific pattern: from wild rodents to ur- ban rats and finally to humans after the rats have died out. Modern medicine distinguish- es between three main forms of plague: bubon- ic plague (nodular plague), which has been the most widespread throughout history, pneu- monic plague and septicaemic plague, in which the bacillus is found in inflamed lymph nodes, sputum and blood. Bubonic plague is transmit- ted by infected flea bites and is characterised by swollen, tender lymph nodes (buboes) near the original site of infection. If left untreated, the bacteria can enter the bloodstream and spread to various organs such as the liver, kidneys, spleen, lungs, meninges and eyes, sometimes Se n so ry R ep r es en ta t io n s o f P la g u e 45 causing an ulcer at the site of the initial infec- tion. If septicaemia occurs early, death can oc- cur before buboes appear. Pneumonic plague, on the other hand, develops either as a com- plication of bubonic plague or through direct transmission via infected droplets in the air we breathe. It occurs rapidly, with symptoms 1–3 days after infection, and is characterised by se- vere pneumonia, shortness of breath, high fe- ver and bloody mucus. This form is almost al- ways fatal if untreated and requires antibiotic treatment within 15–18 hours of the onset of symptoms to have the best chance of survival. While human-to-human transmission is rare in asymptomatic cases, pneumonic plague pa- tients can spread the disease to close contacts as it progresses. Therefore, all plague patients must be isolated for 48 hours after starting an- tibiotics, and pneumonic plague patients must be completely isolated until sputum cultures are negative. Without treatment, the mortality rate is around 50%, with pneumonic plague be- ing particularly deadly if not treated promptly with appropriate antibiotics (Turkington and Lee Ashby 2007, 237–239). Understanding the different forms of plague and its transmission is crucial to under- standing the devastating impact of these diseas- es on society. Historical records do not always provide enough information about the symp- toms to say with certainty what type of plague people contracted and died from. But, while modern science has given us a clear understand- ing of the mechanisms and forms of plague, this knowledge was not available to mediaeval physicians and the populations who faced the disease. This gap between contemporary and historical medical knowledge is particularly rel- evant when examining the historical records of plague outbreaks and their impact on mediae- val society. Among the many health challenges facing mediaeval cities, none was as devastating as the recurring epidemics, especially those that con- temporaries referred to as the plague. By far the greatest mass mortality of the Middle Ages was caused around the middle of the fourteenth cen- tury by the pandemic known as the Black Death (bubonic plague), which was responsible for the selective but widespread death of up to a third of the population in the middle of the fourteenth century and which continued to afflict Europe repeatedly until the eighteenth century, and led to a general demographic collapse. Without modern medical knowledge, physicians attrib- uted these outbreaks to various causes, relying mainly on the miasma theory of atmospher- ic impurity. The Black Death led to the further development of the ‘pestilential miasma’ theo- ry. While fleeing infected cities was considered the best defence, quarantine measures were not widespread in the Middle Ages (Jankrift 2016; Miethke 2016). b) Slovenian accounts of plague Among the early medical writers addressing the plague in the Slovenian context, the Renais- sance thinker David Verbec, who was active in Germany, made significant contributions. He wrote a critical treatise on the plague in Latin in 1618, A Book of Medical Investigations on a Disputation on the Plague (orig. Exercitatio- num medicarum super disputatione quadam de peste liber unus). In this work, he provided a pre- cise description of the disease, which was still widespread in Central Europe at the time, con- templated its nature and transmission and acted against quacks. The treatise proved to be so con- troversial and misunderstood that he left his po- sition in Ulm and moved to Augsburg in 1620. During his time in Ulm, Verbec wrote sever- al works on the plague. While his Tractatus de peste (Treatise on the Plague, Kempten 1617) is only known by its title, his main work Exer- citationum medicarum super disputatione quad- am de peste liber unus (published in Kempten in 1618) offers a comprehensive critique of J. Schegkius’ De pestis curatione Germanicum con- silium (German Policy on Pest Control). This text examines the nomenclature of the plague, the causes, the symptoms, the clinical forms and the course of the disease. Verbec rejected st u d ia u n iv er si ta t is h er ed it a t i, le t n ik 13 (2 02 5) , š t ev il k a 1 / v o lu m e 13 (2 02 5) , n u m be r 1 46 theriac1 and mithridate2 as universal remedies and argued in favour of specific treatments. Above all, he analysed the concept of disease ‘seeds’ (seminarium) and contagion, distin- guishing – in contrast to Schegkius – between contagion and physical contact (tactus, contac- tus) with the diseased. His vivid description of the symptoms suggests first-hand experience as a physician, while his analysis of contagion both draws on ancient authors and anticipates the later work of Marko Anton Plenčič. A later work, Exercitationum de peste libri duo (Investi- gations About the Plague Book Two, Kempten 1619), which is only indirectly known, could have been a continuation of these studies (Ver- bec 1618; Mušič 1982). The study of plague in Slovenian territories has developed through several distinct phases and has been shaped by several generations of his- torians who gradually developed an understand- ing of this important epidemiological and social phenomenon. Janez Vajkard Valvasor’s Die Ehre dess Hertzogthums Crain (1689) provided the first comprehensive account of the plague epidemics in Carniola, documenting outbreaks, folk reme- dies and social reactions to the disease. Vladimir Travner’s monograph Kuga na Slovenskem (1934) represents the next important milestone that sys- tematically dealt with the plague epidemics in the Slovenian lands, focussing on public health measures and mortality rates. Ema Umek’s study ‘Kuga na Štajerskem v letih 1679–1683’ (1958) made an important contribution to the under- standing of the last major epidemic in Styria, while Majda Smole wrote a study on the plague in Carniola in the sixteenth century (1957). Božo Otorepec documented the occurrence of the plague in central Slovenia in ‘Gradivo za 1 Theriac: the term ‘theriac’ comes from the Greek word θηριακή (thēriakē), which means ‘of wild animals’. It was a complex me- dicinal concoction containing various ingredients such as opium, myrrh, saffron, ginger, cinnamon and castor oil. Theriac was believed to have protective properties against poisons and was used as a universal antidote in ancient times. It was particularly popular in the Roman and Byzantine eras and was often associated with the treatment of snake bites and other toxic exposures. 2 Mithridate: mithridate refers specifically to a type of theriac named after Mithridates VI, the king of Pontus who ruled from 120 to 63 BC. According to historical accounts, Mithridates developed this antidote to protect himself from poisoning, as he was known to have been the target of numerous assassination attempts. Mithridates consisted of various ingredients, similar to theriac, and was considered a general antidote for a variety of poisons. Over time, the term ‘mithridate’ has come to refer to any all-purpose antidote. Both theriac and mithridate reflect the ancient understanding of pharmacology and efforts to create rem- edies for the dangers of poisons in the environment. zgodovino Ljubljane v srednjem veku’ (1965), mentioning the plague in July 1466 and the ban on the city of Udine travelling to Ljubljana due to suspicion of the plague in June 1496 (Otorep- ec 1965, X/81, X/94). More recent research has produced new methodological approaches and in-depth regional studies. In his works on the plague, particularly in the Lower Carniola re- gion, Boris Golec (2022) illuminated the epide- miological picture of Lower Carniola and made the radical observation that the sources docu- menting these epidemics often contain exagger- ated death figures, making it difficult to accu- rately assess the actual situation. Many historical records that mention high death rates are often inaccurate and the demographic consequences of the epidemics were in reality less dramatic than depicted. The epidemics also caused economic difficulties as the closures and quarantines dis- rupted trade routes, leading to poverty and short- ages. Although the epidemics were destructive by nature, their actual consequences were often overlooked, although they remain in the collec- tive memory (Golec 2022). Urška Bratož (for- merly Železnik) made important contributions to the understanding of the social aspects of epi- demics in the Littoral region. She investigated the plague outbreaks in the towns of the northern Adriatic in the seventeenth and eighteenth cen- turies, focussing on legal records, containment measures and the impact on the population, es- pecially during the 1630–1631 epidemic in Koper, and comparing the methods of plague control be- tween Venetian Istria and the Austrian territories (Železnik 2007; 2013; 2015; Bratož 2020). Based on this work, several important find- ings about the plague in the Slovenian territo- ries have emerged. The disease spread mainly Se n so ry R ep r es en ta t io n s o f P la g u e 47 along the trade routes from the Italian harbours through the Karst region into the interior, with major outbreaks occurring in Ljubljana, Cel- je, Ptuj and the coastal towns between the four- teenth and seventeenth centuries. Together, the authors documented the development of public health measures, from early mediaeval isolation practises to the establishment of formal quaran- tine stations (lazareti) in the seventeenth centu- ry. The introduction of the cordon sanitaire along the military frontier was particularly signifi- cant. Social reactions included the emergence of plague saints (especially Saint Roch), the found- ing of votive churches and the development of specialised medical practises. The economic im- pact was severe: some towns lost up to a third of their population during major outbreaks, lead- ing to significant changes in urban development and social structures. The profound impact of the plague is also reflected in the Slovenian language. The Slove- nian language already mentions the word kuga (plague) in the Slovenian-Latin German diction- ary by Hieronymus Megister from 1603 (Stabej 2023). The term kuga is also mentioned by the priest Janez Svetokriški in works published at the end of the seventeenth and beginning of the eighteenth century, in the context that the plague is raging in the Italian region (v laški deželi), that the plague is coming, that the cat- tle plague is killing the animals or that someone smells of plague (Snoj 2014). Lexicographers and translators Matija Kastelec and Gregor Vorenc list various terms for the plague in their Slove- nian-Latin dictionary (1680–1710): contagium, contagio, contagies, pestilens and pestis, which is a harmful and deadly disease that kills everyone (Stabej 2014). The Slovenian Linguistic Atlas 1 (Horvat 2011) documents that the lexeme kuga (plague) is used throughout Slovenia for ‘serious infectious disease of the lymph nodes, lungs or blood’. While this is the standard literary term, there are some regional variants, such as pest or pešt, which occur on the Slovenian coast, in the Italian region of Friuli-Venezia Giulia and in Austrian Carinthia (Horvat 2011). Beyond historical and linguistic evidence, the plague also left a significant mark on Slove- nian literature. The depiction of plague symp- toms in Slovenian literary works – including Fran Ksaver Meško’s Črna smrt (1911), Januš Golec’s ‘Zlato in kuga pod križem’ (1934) and Ivan Pregelj’s Plebanus Joannes (1920) – shows striking similarities. The core symptoms de- scribed throughout include fever, unconscious- ness, nausea, chills and pain, which testifies to the uniformity of the plague depictions in these works. In Črna smrt (Black Death) and ‘Zlato in kuga pod križem’ (Gold and the Plague un- der the Cross), the presence of dark spots on the bodies of the victims explicitly indicates bu- bonic plague. Plebanus Joannes offers a distinc- tive depiction that emphasises additional symp- toms: the characteristic smell of the patient, the swollen skin, the presence of pus and the altered physical appearance. In contrast, ‘Zlato in kuga pod križem’ offers a remarkably condensed de- scription of the plague. While the literary depic- tions vary according to period and style, the ba- sic similarity of the symptoms described remains in all these works, indicating a common under- standing of the manifestation of the disease that has persisted throughout Slovenian cultural his- tory (Godec Čizmarevič 2022, 74). Dr Vladimir Travner, a lawyer and local historian, states in his book on the plague in Slo- venia (Kuga na Slovenskem, 1934), in which he lists the causes and consequences of this disease based on historical sources, that plague epidem- ics hit the Slovenian population hard several times in the past. According to Travner, in Slo- venia, we can count more than 150 plague years, from 792, when we have the first more precise information about the plague, to 1732, when it occurred for the last time (Travner 1934, 141). Zmazek (2022) states that the plague broke out several times: in the years 1348–1350, 1480 and during the sixteenth and seventeenth centu- ries (mainly in the years 1644–1650 and 1678– 1683). Until the middle of the sixteenth century, the plague came to Slovenian territory main- ly from the east (from Turkey and Hungary, st u d ia u n iv er si ta t is h er ed it a t i, le t n ik 13 (2 02 5) , š t ev il k a 1 / v o lu m e 13 (2 02 5) , n u m be r 1 48 in connection with the Hungarian and Turkish invasions) and a few times also from the south (from the Republic of Venice, due to lively trade). After 1550, the plague almost always came from the north in Lower Styria and most of Carniola and from the south in Littoral (Primorska) and Lower Carniola (Notranjska), which was relat- ed to the political, economic and transport con- nections of the individual countries at that time. The centres and starting points of the plague ep- idemics were almost always towns with heavy traffic, and from there the disease usually spread rapidly in the surrounding area. The border re- gions, especially Podravje, Bela Krajina, Tržaš- ka and Goriška, were particularly frequently and severely affected. The area around Ljublja- na and Gorenjska was less affected, as the au- thorities had already done everything necessary to contain the destructive force of the epidem- ic before it spread through the heart of Slove- nia. The conditions that enabled and accelerat- ed the epidemics were, as elsewhere in Europe, mainly poor hygienic, housing and sanitary conditions (cramped, stuffy and often populat- ed by rodents, fleas and lice, poor and monot- onous diet, lack of hygiene, lack of sanitary fa- cilities, lack of or severely inadequate medical care), difficult economic conditions, unfavour- able weather conditions (floods, droughts) and other natural disasters (earthquakes, locust at- tacks) and the associated crop failures and fam- ines (Zmazek 2022). Travner states that the epidemics claimed so many victims over many centuries – especially in the Middle Ages – because sanitary and hygien- ic conditions were extremely neglected. Space in the cities was very limited due to the walls. As a result, the streets were narrow and dark. They had no sewerage system. But if there were ditches, they were so narrow and slightly sloped that the heat could not drain away well. In bad weather, it flooded the streets and squares and formed large, dirty and smelly puddles. Rub- bish and waste was usually dumped in front of the houses and rarely taken away. The cesspits were usually poorly constructed so that their contents often spilled into the neighbourhood. Even in larger towns there were stables next to the houses, from which animals (especially pigs) often escaped into the streets and squares. Car- rion (dogs, cats, chickens, rats and others) often lay in public places for days and weeks, spreading an unbearable stench. At best, they swept dead animals, waste, rubbish, etc. into nearby streams and rivers, which was even recommended by the infection regulations (e.g. 1625) and city magis- trates, e.g. of Ljubljana in 1599. Of course, no- body realised that water was a dangerous carri- er of infectious diseases. Livestock was usually slaughtered at home without paying attention to order and cleanliness. Drinking water for hu- mans and animals was taken from public wells, which were not covered but so poorly fenced that contaminated water and other rubbish got into them. Cemeteries were almost always located in settlements around the parish church. These were the normal conditions that prevailed in Slovenia until 1850, when Prussian-style health councils were established in Austria to take care of general hygiene and the proper care of patients (Travner 1934, 23, 24). Following this example, other authors re- ported similar conditions. For example, a histo- ry professor from Metlika, Zvonko Rus, uses his- torical sources to describe in literary form how the plague struck Metlika in his book Metličani, Part 1 (2021, 53–54): Behind the church of St Martin stands a plague sign, which is one of the oldest of its kind and is protected as a monument. In addition to the attacks by the Turks and Uskoks, Metlika was also ravaged by the Black Death. Imagine what Metlika looked like back then: narrow streets, no sewage system, no rubbish collection, no commu- nal services and no communal economy. On these streets, even if they were paved, the townspeople threw everything they didn’t need in the houses: rubbish, dead cats, the stinking contents of chamber pots, rags, swill and so on. This heated up on the street Se n so ry R ep r es en ta t io n s o f P la g u e 49 during the day, steamed up and spread the stench in the city air that people breathed in. Furthermore, half-naked children ran through the streets, peeing and pooing wher- ever they could. And the adults didn’t hes- itate for too long either. Hordes of hungry cats and dogs and whole swarms of rats were scattered across the city. Even in the houses, they probably didn’t pay too much attention to hygiene and bred lice and fleas. The inhab- itants of Metlika died like flies and could not be buried on the spot in the parish cemetery of the Three Parishes, but exactly where St Roch’s Church stands today, or on the site of the plague sign at St Martin’s Church. The inhabitants of Metlika were frequently af- flicted by plague, cholera, smallpox, typhus, dysentery and occasionally famine. The most severe outbreaks of plague occurred in 1431, 1510, 1646, 1647 and 1691 and then again from 1720 to 1730, i.e. for ten years.3 Travner explains (1934) that in the years 872 and 873, Slovenia, especially Lower Styr- ia, was hit by extreme heat and drought. At the same time, huge swarms of locusts flew in, devas- tating the Ptujsko polje in particular. The wind drove them into the Drava, but the waves threw them back onto land. Here, the carcasses of the locusts rotted and spread an unbearable stench. As a result, a major epidemic broke out in Ptuj and the surrounding area, killing many people. In the following years, similar conditions pre- vailed throughout Europe (Travner 1934, 91). In 1542 and 1543, large swarms of locusts also flew into Carniola and Styria, devouring everything that was green in a very short time. A great fam- ine followed. The rotting carcasses of thousands of animals polluted the air. In 1542, in the area around Celje, especially on the border with Car- niola, almost all landowners fled for fear of the plague epidemic. Between Maribor and Kam- nica at the end of the nineteenth century, there was a plague sign with the year 1543 as a remind- 3 Unless otherwise noted, all translations are by the author. er that infected corpses were buried in this place at that time (p. 96). Ptuj also experienced the horrors of the lo- cust invasion in 1672, exactly 800 years after the invasion of locusts in 872, with swarms again ar- riving in such massive numbers that they dark- ened the sun. Strong winds drove them into the Drava River, causing mass drowning. The waves then deposited countless carcasses along the shoreline, where decomposition produced an overwhelming stench. An epidemic followed, which only stopped the following year (Travner 1934, 112). During the plague, infected human corps- es often lay unburied for a long time on roads, fields and in thickets, so that they were torn apart by dogs and wild animals, as for example near Ptuj in 1682. Other bodies rotted for weeks and months in abandoned houses. Such cases oc- curred mainly in the countryside, where entire houses and settlements often died out, so that there was a lack of undertakers to bury the dead. In the cities, too, piles of corpses often lay in the streets. Everyone ran away from the infected corpses. They spread such a terrible stench that nobody could stay near them. There was also a high risk of infection. That is why everyone – ex- cept the gravediggers – was strictly forbidden to touch the corpses. The locals had to hire a brave man as quickly as possible to pull the corpse out of the house with an iron hook on a long pole. It was only in later times (especially after the provisions of the Infection Ordinance of 1710) that corpses were covered with sheets or placed in coffins made of thin wood and incensed. In- fected corpses were destined for their own cem- eteries outside the towns and villages, which the communities had to take care of. They dug large and deep plague pits in which the corpses were disposed of, sprinkled with quicklime and then raked. They often even buried the apparently dead. When the epidemic ended, common mon- uments (plague signs) were erected on the com- mon graves of the victims. Here and there the st u d ia u n iv er si ta t is h er ed it a t i, le t n ik 13 (2 02 5) , š t ev il k a 1 / v o lu m e 13 (2 02 5) , n u m be r 1 50 bodies were later exhumed and transferred to regular cemeteries, which had to be done secret- ly as the authorities did not allow this (Travner 1934, 46, 47). According to the Chronicle of the parish of St Vid, written by Matej Slekovec4 (as cited in Hojnik 2025, 300), the plague began to attack again with devastating force in 1645: Due to the townspeople’s lack of caution, the disease spread throughout St Vid and the Haloze region. The victims suffered from successive and consistent symptoms: violent stomach cramps attacked them one after the other, some had acute chest pains, while others developed buboes character- ised by bloody red spots on their bodies. The disease progressed with frightening speed – most of those affected succumbed within 24 hours after feeling a paralysing weakness. Only a few survived for several days and re- coveries were extremely rare. The corpses of the deceased were a gruesome sight, as they quickly turned black after death and gave off an overwhelming stench. ‘This is death,’ people whispered to each other as despair spread through the community. Some res- idents thought of fleeing, but quickly real- ised they had nowhere to go – conditions in the neighbouring region of Haloze were just as bad. By July 1645, the epidemic had already affected half of the houses in St Vid. The homes of those infected were quar- antined, marked with conspicuous white crosses, and supplies were delivered through the windows to minimise contact. When a death occurred, families resorted to secret burials, usually held at night behind their homes. The toll taken by the plague went beyond the human victims and devastat- ed the local economy. With so many people dead, agricultural labour in the vineyards and fields was neglected. The survivors 4 The first part of the chronicle was written by Matej Slekovec (1846–1903), who worked as a priest in the neighbouring parish of St Mark from 1887. In 1883, he published the section on the outbreak of the plague in the St Vid Chronicle and also published it in Slovenski gospodar (see: Slekovec 1883, 142). faced severe shortages and were unable to meet their tax obligations. In response to these circumstances, the parish priest of St Vid, Tomaž Zahely, asked the provincial government for tax relief for his parishion- ers – a request that was readily granted by the authorities. In addition to the descriptions of living conditions, hygiene and the tragedy of rotting corpses and their odour, some Slovenian-lan- guage literary works are based on the belief in the cleansing power of fire and smoke. Fire is often associated with rituals and ceremonies aimed at purifying or cleansing people, objects or spaces. Fumigation was the most important meth- od of preventing the plague. This practise was based on the belief that fire had purifying prop- erties and could clear the air. Various fragrant or smoky woods were used for this purpose, in- cluding cypress, pine, juniper, oak and beech. In addition to pleasant scents, unpleasant-smell- ing substances were also used, including castore- um, galbanum, sulphur, burnt leather, horns and gunpowder. Gunpowder was particularly prized and was used from the sixteenth to the late eight- eenth century (Byfleet 2023). The function and occurrences of the puri- fying fire were described in detail in James Fraz- er’s Golden Bough (1922) in the chapter on the ‘Need-fire’ and in several places in earlier ver- sions of the book. Frazer claims that the fire fes- tivals are all celebrated periodically at certain times of the year and date back to a very distant time. But apart from these regularly recurring celebrations, farmers in many parts of Europe resorted to a fire ritual at irregular intervals in times of hardship and distress, especially when their livestock was afflicted by a plague. Some- times the need-fire was referred to as a ‘wild fire’, no doubt to distinguish it from the tame fire produced by ordinary methods. Among the Se n so ry R ep r es en ta t io n s o f P la g u e 51 Slavic peoples it is called ‘living fire’. The history of fire can be traced from the early Middle Ages, when it was described by the Church as a pagan superstition, to the first half of the nineteenth century, when it was still occasionally practised in various parts of Germany, England, Scotland and Ireland. Among the Slavic peoples it seems to have lasted even longer. The usual occasion for the performance of this rite was the outbreak of the plague or cattle-disease, against which the need-fire was regarded as an infallible remedy (Frazer 1922, 638, 639). The Slavicist and philologist Radivoj Lenček (1943) confirms Frazer’s statements and adds that fire was used by all peoples in various rituals as a means of purification. Even in the non-periodic purification fires, which purified humans, animals and plants by burning and de- stroying harmful physical and spiritual elements (witches, sorcerers, evil spirits) that haunted all living beings, permanent, recurring fires were lit and corresponding rituals performed. Such fires, known as ‘living fire’ among Slavic peo- ples, were most often lit for infectious diseases, against which the ‘living fire’ was always an ef- fective apotropaic remedy.5 The ‘living fire’ was sacred, as its smoke and ashes were also used for various medicinal purposes. But the most effec- tive form of purification took place in the fire itself, by walking or jumping over the flames. Lenček adds that in Upper Bavaria, for exam- ple, cattle were driven through the solstice fire; the sick to get well, the healthy to be protected from the plague and other evils during the year. Sick cattle were often driven through the smoke and flames two or three times so that they were burnt to death. Every year on St Roch’s day, Pol- ish farmers drove their cattle through the ‘liv- ing fire’ three times a day to protect them from infectious diseases. Not only the cattle, but also the people could be purified in such a fire. Ac- cording to Lenček, this is proven by the numer- ous cases of boys and girls who jumped over bon- fires and ‘living flames’ on various occasions. In 5 Apotropaic remedy: a means of defence against evil which, according to folk belief, has the power to ward off and protect against misfortune. all such and similar cases, the purifying moment plays the greatest role (Lenček 1943, 61). Given the belief in the purifying proper- ties of fire, it is not surprising that some Slove- nian literary works contain detailed descriptions of the plague and the measures taken to com- bat it. These descriptions are based on the belief that fire has the ability to purify the air and drive away the plague, as well as the idea that smoke can purify the atmosphere. A vivid example of this can be found in the book The Black Death (1911) by Franc Ksaver Meško, a writer and priest. His history-based literary work depicts the period of the plague in Ptuj and the surrounding area and in Hajdina from May 1645 to autumn 1646. Literary figures also remember the plague epidemics in the period from 1623–1625. Meško writes (1931): The world around them presented them with a marvellous scene. Everywhere they looked, bonfires were burning and smoul- dering. They were lit for the first time – al- ready during earlier epidemics – by refu- gees from Ptuj in Haloze. It was an agreed sign to relatives and acquaintances that they were still alive. They were also lit by farmers living alone. According to the custom of the mountain dwellers, they signalled to their distant relatives that they had a corpse in the house. Because why should they signal that they are still alive? Thank God, who still drives away the danger and still tames the murderer! So, the original sign of life itself became a harbinger of death. Slowly, the fires began to be burnt everywhere, for many claimed that fire purifies the air and the smoke kills poisonous germs. So even now the land was full of fires, all shrouded in smoke. The author also refers to the doctors who helped the infected in various ways, including with incense: ‘The doctor distributed the med- icines he had brought with him: powder, various st u d ia u n iv er si ta t is h er ed it a t i, le t n ik 13 (2 02 5) , š t ev il k a 1 / v o lu m e 13 (2 02 5) , n u m be r 1 52 liquids and incense, with which the room and the whole house were to be fumigated so that the germs would stop and the risk of infection would decrease.’ (Meško 1931). In Croatia, popular belief in connection with the epidemic also included the belief that smoke and ashes could cleanse from disease, and so things were often ‘cleansed’ with ashes or smoke (Skenderović 2003, 169). Although med- icine already knew a great deal about the plague in the eighteenth century, people saw the occur- rence of the epidemic as the hand of God punish- ing them for their sins. This view was supported by the court itself, so that numerous royal letters also spoke of God’s punishment and called on subjects to repent and lead a moral life. Along- side this belief, which was supported by both the official government and the church, there were also many superstitions in which some character- istic beliefs emerged that had ancient, pre-Chris- tian roots. Examples of purification with smoke and ashes were everywhere, so it seems that this method was also accepted by the official author- ities at the time. The houses of the infected were often burnt, but the authorities simply sprayed some houses with vinegar, which was apparent- ly believed to destroy the infection (pp. 168, 169). The Capuchin monk Fedele from Zadar de- scribed in great detail the disinfection methods used to combat the plague in Split, Croatia, be- tween 1783 and 1784, when the city was com- pletely isolated for fifteen and a half months (Donadini 1988). These methods included var- ious forms of fumigation of the rooms. Fedele writes (Donadini 1988, 79): When the house is empty, the cobwebs are removed, the house is swept and all the rooms are exposed to the so-called pun- gent odours of incense for two days, with the doors and windows completely closed. These scents are obtained by placing tarred ribbons, sulphur and cow hooves in the burners. The whole house is then white- washed with lime and, after drying, in- censed twice more with scents, the first time with the pungent scents just mentioned and the second time with the so-called sweet fragrance, which is obtained from a mix- ture of frankincense, myrtle, sage, rose- mary and juniper berries. With this second scent, the task of deodorising the house is complete. Although all things can be com- pletely dissolved by boiling, soaking or air- ing, some people, out of excessive fear, allow all or most of these things that could oth- erwise be saved to burn. Using fire is really the most complete and quickest way that is more than safe. In this way, even the largest house can be completely and perfectly dis- infected in a few hours, and the whole city in a few days, so that it would not have to be subjected in any way to the health measures of the city. What I feared most was the dan- ger of a fire breaking out because the beams had caught fire and the rooms were filled with smoke. The fire that I feared so much had actually already broken out. So, if I had not come at the right time and warned the others, the fire would have spread quickly because of all the things that had accumu- lated and the constant wind. Another method of sanitising the air, which Father Fedele mentions with great reluctance, is the following (Donadini 1988, 84): Instead of the laborious and manifold fu- migation of houses, it would suffice for this purpose to expose the room to the evapo- ration and fumigation of quicklime thrown into water. Moreover, this lime dipped in water can later be used to whitewash the walls. And immediately there are extraor- dinary savings, not only in time and effort, but also in so many additional resources used today for this purpose, and finally in the firewood used when fumigating hous- es. At the same time, we have got rid of the danger of a fire which had already affect- ed one house here and would have spread to the whole street if the usual strong wind had blown that night. Se n so ry R ep r es en ta t io n s o f P la g u e 53 The Plague Altar of St Sebastian in the Church of St Andrew in Makole: Close View and Interpretation a) The upper part of the plague altar An example of visual art related to plague is the so-called ‘Plague altar’ of St Sebastian by the sculptor Jožef Štraub with a plague scene by an unknown painter in the lower part of the art- work, which was created between 1751 and 1756 and is located in the parish church of St Andrew in Makole in Slovenia. The side plague altar, which was badly dam- aged, dilapidated, worm-eaten and rotten, was restored in 2018 (Šiles and Radšel 2018). The wooden altar consists of a wooden background and polychrome statues of angels and saints. In the lower part, there are statues of St Charles Borromeo and St Roch. In the at- tic of the altar are four more angels, two smaller and two larger, as well as nine angel heads with wings. In the centre is a statue of Jesus Christ with the rays of the sun, with silvered clouds in the background (Šiles and Radšel 2018, 2). On the left side of the altar is a statue of St Charles Borromeo, who is known for having helped plague patients during the plague in Mi- lan in 1576, and on the right side is a statue of St Roch, the patron saint against the plague. The wooden painting on the altarpiece shows St Peter, who is depicted with a key be- cause he is traditionally regarded as the keeper of the keys to heaven, and St Sebastian, a patron saint against contagious and sudden infectious diseases. Black clouds can be seen above them, from which lightning bolts shoot down to earth. As it is said that ‘such diseases are like an arrow shot secretly’, St Sebastian is usually depicted ‘tied to a tree or a pillar with arrows in his body’ (‘Sveti Sebastijan (Boštjan) – mučenec’ n.d.). On this plague altar, he is holding arrows in his right hand, the tips of which are pointing away from him. ‘Initially, the saint was the patron saint against the plague, later together with St Roch, who slowly took his place’ (‘Sveti Sebasti- jan (Boštjan) – mučenec’ n.d.). St Sebastian is one of the most venerated saints. He is the protector (patron saint) against the plague. The rapid cessation of this disease in Rome in 680 is attributed to his intercession. In depictions of St Sebastian, arrows symbolise his role as protector against the plague and his martyrdom. These images, often showing him bound and pierced by arrows, reflect his unwa- vering faith and courage in the face of persecu- tion. The arrows, which in the past were invoked to protect against illness, symbolise both his suffering and the divine intervention that gives hope to those who suffer. Overall, they embody themes of martyrdom, protection, resilience and divine grace and emphasise the importance of St Sebastian in the context of suffering and heal- ing, especially in times of plague. The arrows of pestilence are deeply root- ed in many languages. The Hebrew words for plague (maggefah, negef, naga, makkah) all im- ply a blow. The English word ‘plague’ comes from the Latin plaga, which is derived from the Greek πληγή, meaning blow. Similarly, the French word fléau, which means both flail and plague, comes from the Latin flagellum and Greek θλίβω, af- flicted. In Arabic, the term for plague evokes the idea of being ‘stung’ or ‘pricked’, reminiscent of the snakes or arrows associated with the disease (Payne Crawfurd 1914, 8–9). St Roch, also known as St Rocco, is often invoked as a protector against plague and infec- tious diseases. His symbolism is rich and com- plex, reflecting both his life and the historical context in which he became a figure of venera- tion. St Roch is primarily regarded as the patron saint of those suffering from infectious diseas- es, especially the plague. This association stems from his own life story, in which he was involved in the plague outbreaks of the fourteenth cen- tury. His actions are an example of compassion and selflessness, qualities that play a major role in times of crisis. In artistic representations, St Roch is often depicted as a pilgrim with a shell, together with a staff and a dog. The dog symbol- ises loyalty and comradeship. In some stories, it is said to have brought him bread when he was in st u d ia u n iv er si ta t is h er ed it a t i, le t n ik 13 (2 02 5) , š t ev il k a 1 / v o lu m e 13 (2 02 5) , n u m be r 1 54 isolation because of the plague. This symbolism emphasises the themes of support and care, both divine and earthly. St Roch is often depicted with a wound on his thigh caused by the plague. This visible sign is a reminder of the human suf- fering and trials that occur during an epidem- ic. It also symbolises the healing that can come from faith and the importance of caring for the suffering. b) The lower part of the plague altar In addition to these obvious symbols of the plague, the lower part of the plague altar in Ma- kole shows harrowing scenes from everyday life during the plague epidemic. This part of the painting by an unknown author shows a plague scene in which the dying and sick lie or sit on the ground in various states of suffering (nine adults and one infant), while four men and a wom- an look after them, carry the deceased away on stretchers, or offer help to those still clinging to life. The dying or dead figures are depicted na- ked; only their genitals are covered with a cloth. This was a common artistic convention in Chris- tian religious paintings and symbolised respect for the deceased. This conscious artistic deci- sion preserves human dignity, even though it de- picts the most devastating circumstances of mass death. The cloth covering symbolises an impor- tant cultural and religious tradition that has pre- served decency in the depiction of death, even under the catastrophic conditions of the plague. Of particular note is the subtle yet dis- turbing motif of the infant next to a half-na- ked mother figure. This compositional choice is reminiscent of the gruesome reality documented in cultural narratives from the region – infants attempting to suckle from deceased mothers (Tomažič 1990, 66; Ramšak 2022, 669). While the painting preserves a certain religious deco- rum, the folk tales from the same cultural area of Pohorje offer more explicit descriptions of this phenomenon. The story The Merchant’s Son (‘Trgovčev sin’, Tomažič 1990) from Pohorje takes this mo- tif to an even more disturbing level by showing a desperate child feeding on the dead. What may appear to be exaggerated folklore finds its visual equivalent, albeit in a more restrained form, in the altar painting. Both depictions capture the same fundamental horror – the reversal of nur- turing motherhood through death, with the child instinctively seeking nourishment from the mother who can no longer give it. These textual-visual parallels show how both religious art and folktales address a collec- tive trauma, even if the religious art maintains certain boundaries of propriety that the folk- tales transgress by explicitly mentioning an un- conscious mother lying on the floor and a cry- ing child beside her, sucking blood from an open vein on her arm (Tomažič 1990, 66). The subtle suggestion of the image and the explicit descrip- tion of the narrative are complementary strate- gies for preserving the cultural memory of the profound disruption that the plague caused even in the most basic human relationship – that be- tween mother and child. On the left side of the painting, a woman is depicted covering her nose with a handkerchief in her right hand, probably due to the stench of dead. With her left hand, she offers the hand- kerchief to a sick man sitting on the ground. He stretches out his arms towards her to protect himself from infectious miasmas. This detail of the painting, showing the woman covering her nose to avoid inhaling miasma, indicates at least two things: firstly, that people were aware Figure 2: The lower part of the painting in the plague al- tar is by an unknown painter and depicts everyday life in times of plague. Makole, Church of St Andrew, Slovenia (a detail from Šiles and Radšel 2018, 26). Se n so ry R ep r es en ta t io n s o f P la g u e 55 of the transmission of the disease and that they took simple self-protective measures. That the stench must have been unbearable can also be inferred from other details of the scene, such as the green grass, bright green trees in the back- ground, and the bare-footed men with rolled- up sleeves carrying away the corpses, from which we can conclude that the painter has de- picted an epidemic tragedy in warm weather, such as late spring, summer or early autumn. The woman in the picture holding a handker- chief to her nose indicates not only protection against stench, but also an understanding of the concept of miasma. This scene reflects the contemporary un- derstanding of disease transmission, which was based on the miasma theory. In this context, it is interesting to mention Marko Anton Plenčič (1705–1786), a Slovenian doctor who studied medicine in Padua and worked at the Faculty of Medicine in Vienna, who was firmly convinced that all infectious diseases were caused by living pathogens. In 1762, his first book was published under the title Opera medico physica.6 Plenčič’s practical experience in treating patients with in- fectious diseases and the influence of his pro- fessor, Carlo Cogrosi, who had written a book on contagious diseases in cattle in 1714, made him realise that his ideas were correct. Plenčič carried out experiments with variolisation and proved that variola was caused by a specific path- ogen. He was also convinced that the scarlet fe- ver infection was caused by airborne germs that entered the body through the skin or respiratory organs. Plenčič applied his idea of specific path- ogens of infectious diseases to veterinary med- icine, agriculture and the economy. One hun- dred years before Pasteur, Plenčič explained the causes of infection with contagious diseases in humans, animals and plants and described the characteristics of disease agents (Stropnik 1998, 153–156). 6 Full title: Opera medico physica, in quatuor tractatus digesta, quorum primus contagii morborum ideam novam una cum addita- mento de lue bovina, anno 1761. epidemice grassante sistit. Secundus de variolis, tertius de scarlatina, quartus de terræ motu, sed præcipue illo horribili agit, qui prima novembris anno 1755. Europam, Africam, et Americam conquassabat. The book was translat- ed into Slovenian in 1998 under the title O bolezenskem kontagiju: nova ideja. This theory about the transmission of dis- eases through the air, which dates back to antiq- uity, was well known among the people, which is why the painter depicted it as protecting the res- piratory tract with a handkerchief. Based on the painting, which shows a plague scene, we can analyse the symptoms de- picted to determine the probable nature of the plague. What we can observe in this artwork is that several plague victims are being cared for or carried away. Most importantly, howev- er, there are no visible buboes (swollen lymph nodes) nor dark skin lesions (plague spots), the victims appear to be lying down or being car- ried and the scene suggests acute onset and high mortality. Given the absence of the buboes typical of bubonic plague and the apparently rapid pro- gression suggested by the scene, it is probably pneumonic plague. Pneumonic plague is trans- mitted directly from person to person through respiratory droplets, has an acute onset, has an extremely high mortality rate if untreated, does not produce the characteristic buboes of bubon- ic plague, and the primary symptoms are res- piratory/pulmonary rather than visible external manifestations. Since the first symptoms of pneumonic plague (European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control n.d.) appear 1 to 3 days after infec- tion, with chest pain, production of thick mucus in the lungs, shortness of breath and death with- in 24 hours, it is possible that the woman in the painting is covering her airways with a handker- chief because she is even the slightest bit aware of the disease, since this form of plague was trans- mitted by droplets. It could be a sign of her fear of infection and her desire to protect herself and others during the epidemic. The painting ap- pears to depict the horrific reality of caring for and disposing of victims during an outbreak of pneumonic plague. st u d ia u n iv er si ta t is h er ed it a t i, le t n ik 13 (2 02 5) , š t ev il k a 1 / v o lu m e 13 (2 02 5) , n u m be r 1 56 The depiction of naked dead and sick peo- ple whose genitals are covered for reasons of de- cency on the plague altar also shows that peo- ple were aware of the risk of infection through clothing and it is supported with other sources. The nakedness of the dead and sick depicted on the plague altar can be explained by the hygiene measures taken to contain the disease. Žepič, who analysed pandemic criminal law (2022), notes that although European coun- tries faced devastating plague pandemics, there was no significant criminal intervention by the state in pandemics until the sixteenth centu- ry, except in some Mediterranean coastal towns and northern Italian cities. The prosecution of sanitary offences was the responsibility of the sanitary magistrates, who had broad criminal jurisdiction. The ‘pandemic criminal law’ was characterised by harsh punishments reminis- cent of martial law, by the criminalisation of both commission and omission, of intentional and negligent offences and by the abandonment of the principle of legality when this was already an established legal principle (Žepič 2022, 50). The Plague Statute that Visconti issued for Reg- gio in Modena in 1374 stipulated that infected persons had to leave town immediately and iso- late themselves in the countryside until they re- covered or died. The isolation lasted at least ten days and also applied to those who were in con- tact with the infected persons. The property of infected persons was confiscated, contaminat- ed movable property was destroyed and wilful spreaders could expect to have their property confiscated. The admission of infected refugees was prohibited under threat of the death penal- ty (pp. 53–54). With this kind of pandemic criminal law, we can explain why the dying and dead are de- picted naked on the plague altar in Makole. Their clothes were destroyed, burnt, so that the infection could not spread further. The white smoke on the left side of the art- work – which at first glance could be mistak- en for a fluffy white cloud – could have a dou- ble meaning. On closer inspection, however, we can see that the smoke is actually rising from the top of the hill and stands out against the sky. On the one hand, it could be the smoke from burnt, infected clothing, which is also con- firmed by the depiction of the naked bodies. On the other hand, it could be a representation of the miasma itself, as in popular belief the plague was associated with the appearance of mist, smoke or vapour. This interpretation could stem from the be- lief, based on observations of the plague in Swit- zerland, Austria, Germany and Iceland (Kro- pej-Telban 2022, 30; Gunnell 2001, 49; Travner 1934, 76.), that the plague could also appear in the form of mist, smoke, vapour or a cloud that settles in the valley and kills people and livestock (Kropej-Telban 2022, 30). From the mouths of people dying of the plague, it escapes like a cloud of blue vapour, which can penetrate various ob- jects and, when it comes out, causes the plague (Travner 1934, 76), which corresponds to the de- scription of a miasma. Vinko Möderndorfer, who was the author of the first comprehensive systematic work on the folk medicine of the Slovenes (1964), also ex- plains that fire was considered a natural disin- fectant. In some places, when the plague spread, every stranger who entered the place had to pass through the fire and only then were they allowed to come into contact with the people. In Lower Carniola (Dolenjska), on the evening of the bon- fire, everyone jumped over the fire three times to be protected from the plague. In Bela Kraji- na, bonfires were lit in the courtyard during the plague and the cattle were driven through them (Möderndorfer 1964, 31). The ethnographer Jožef Pajek reports that the tradition of light- ing bonfires on Easter morning, called ‘vuzen- ice’, survived in Styria until the end of the nine- teenth century, and at the same time people firmly believed that the plague would not reach the place where the smoke from these bonfires was lit and that the buckwheat would not with- er (Pajek 1884, 84). By zooming in and focusing the image, we can also understand the sense of horror of the Se n so ry R ep r es en ta t io n s o f P la g u e 57 moment. The two men on the right, carrying the corpse on a stretcher, are visibly affected by the situation. The first (on the right), who almost lit- erally walks out of the painting, has wide-open, almost bulging eyes, and the man behind him is screaming in horror and crying in agony, which we can see through his open mouth. The figure’s protruding eyes are also strikingly reminiscent of exophthalmos, a medical condition charac- terised by an abnormal protrusion of the eye- balls and usually associated with Graves’ disease – an autoimmune disorder affecting the thyroid gland. My main interpretation focuses on how the depicted features effectively convey the psy- chological horror of the plague and the traumat- ic burden of dealing with the dead. The bulging eyes and agonised facial expressions powerfully convey the overwhelming horror and suffering that prevails during epidemics. As a secondary observation, the figure’s facial hair (a goat beard) could possibly be a goitre (enlargement of the thyroid gland), given the painter’s obvious ana- tomical inaccuracies elsewhere, such as the poor- ly executed right arm of the deceased being car- 7 The art historian Marjan Zadnikar (1964, 20) cites this chapel from the painting of the plague altar in the parish church in Ma- kole as an example of the existence of columnar signs (slopno znamenje) in the eighteenth century ried. This secondary medical interpretation is speculative and certainly not the primary angle through which I am analysing the work. Never- theless, it creates an interesting, if unintended, parallel between the historical artistic depic- tion and contemporary medical understanding. While I acknowledge that I may be projecting modern medical knowledge onto historical art, the primary meaning remains the artist’s power- ful depiction of plague terror, with any medical subtext only serving to enrich our appreciation of how effectively the visual elements convey hu- man suffering during historical epidemics. The columnar sign with a pyramid roof and a niche7, the only masonry object in the paint- ing, indicates that the painted scene is of local significance and originates from Makole or its surroundings, as Christian columnar signs of spiritual significance built in this way are often found along country roads and are particular- ly common in alpine and pre-alpine areas. The presence of a columnar sign with a pyramid roof and a niche in the background and the religious symbolism above this painting suggest that re- Figure 3: The main motifs of plague altar in the church of St Andrew in Makole, Slovenia (mind map created by Moj- ca Ramšak (2025)) st u d ia u n iv er si ta t is h er ed it a t i, le t n ik 13 (2 02 5) , š t ev il k a 1 / v o lu m e 13 (2 02 5) , n u m be r 1 58 ligious institutions played an important role in plague epidemics. The depiction of real, sensory scenes of the plague and the supernatural world, such as an- gels and saints, on the plague altar serves as a link between the spiritual and the material. It is no coincidence that the real world with the plague scenes is depicted in the lower part of the painting, because in a religious context, everyday life, human experiences and emotions, which the viewer can understand and experience on a physical level, are metaphorically ‘below’, while the metaphysical level of the depiction with pro- tectors against the plague and guardian angels is ‘above’. In art and religion, real-life scenes can be used to illustrate moral values (in this case, helping others) or historical events that are im- portant to the community (in this case, plague epidemics). By combining real scenes with super- natural symbols such as angels and saints, a space for reflection and spiritual experience is created that encourages the viewer to think about their place in the world and their relationship with higher powers. It could be said that the depiction of real plague scenes in the context of art and re- ligion serves as a means of communication, en- abling the viewer to understand and tap into deeper religious truths by connecting the mate- rial and spiritual levels. The viewer can identify with the scenes of suffering and at the same time seek solace in supernatural symbols. This inter- action between the viewer and the art can lead to a personal spiritual experience. The plague al- tar as a work of art not only presents the spiritual aspect, but also offers the viewer psychological support in difficult times. The artistic expression acts as a therapeutic tool that has helped people deal with fear and uncertainty in times of plague epidemics. Many altars with patron saints against the plague were erected in the surroundings of Ma- kole (e.g. in many places on Pohorje and at its foot, such as St Barbara (in Malahorna), St Blaise (in Slovenska Bistrica), St Francis Xavier (in Vi- tanje, Slovenska Bistrica, Kot and Slovenske Konjice), St George (in Slovenske Konjice, Rito- znoj, Slovenska Bistrica and Hoče), St Roch (in Vitanje, Janževski Vrh, Kovača vas and Prihova), St Sebastian (in Vitanje, Slovenska Bistrica, Pr- ihova and Golika), and St Valentin (in Gorenje pri Zrečah and Prihova) (Ramšak 2019, 45–52, 104–106; 2022, 670). In the parish of Makole, which includes 13 villages, there are 16 chapels and three signs, f3 f4 Figure 4: The idea structure of plague altar in the church of St Andrew in Makole, Slovenia (mind map created by Mojca Ramšak (2025)) Se n so ry R ep r es en ta t io n s o f P la g u e 59 2 of which are plague signs (Žnidar 2012, 62). At the crossroads in the village of Savinsko, there is a pillar-shaped plague sign from the turn of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, which, ac- cording to the locals, is more than 500 years old and has been restored several times (pp. 77–78). On the main Poljčane-Majšperk road, near the former Marolf Inn under Štatenberg Castle, there is a column-shaped plague sign from the second half of the seventeenth century (p. 98). Plague signs, individual saints, and patron saints against the plague, which can be found in churches, chapels and other monuments, bear witness to the historical presence of the disease, the fear it caused and the deep belief in the power of healing through the intercession of the saints. Throughout history, the presence of plague signs and the veneration of certain saints reflect the profound impact the disease had on communi- ties, often leading to the adoption of rituals and prayers to gain divine protection. These prac- tises not only served as a source of comfort in times of crisis, but also emphasised the cultur- al and spiritual importance of faith in overcom- ing adversity. Conclusion To summarise, the plague altar from the par- ish church in Makole, Slovenia, is a poignant reminder of the profound impact of epidemics on both art and everyday life. This artistic rep- resentation not only reflects the fears and strug- gles of communities in times of crisis but also epitomises the resilience and hope that emerge in the face of adversity. The altar is a testament to how art can capture the collective memory of a society struggling with loss and uncertainty, while providing solace and a sense of continui- ty. As we navigate our own challenges in the cur- rent post-Covid-19 era, the lessons we learn from such historical artefacts remind us of the endur- ing human spirit and the way creativity can pro- vide solace and meaning amidst the chaos of an epidemic. Acknowledgement The article was written as part of the project Smell and Intangible Cultural Heritage (J7- 50233), funded by the Slovenian Research and Innovation Agency (ARIS). References Atalić, B. 2019. ‘Svetci zaštitnici protiv epidemija kuge: analiza primjera iz sakralnih baština Rijeke i Osijeka.’ Acta Medico-Historica Adriatica 17 (2): 213–232. Barthes, R. 1981. Camera Lucida: Reflections on Photography. Hill and Wangs. Bratož, U. 2020. ‘Človek v primežu epidemije: doživljanje kuge v Kopru in Gorici v 17. stoletju.’ Arhivi: glasilo Arhivskega društva in arhivov Slovenije 43 (2): 271–286. Byfleet, R. 2023. ‘Plague.’ Encyclopedia of Smell History and Heritage, 19 October. https:// encyclopedia.odeuropa.eu/items/show/28. Christopoulou-Aletra, H., A. Togia, and C. Varlami. 2010. ‘The ‘smart’ Asclepieion: A Total Healing Environment.’ Archives of Hellenic Medicine 27 (2): 259–263. Donadini, I. 1988. ‘Otac Fedele iz Zadra: kuga u Splitu 1783–1784.’ Kulturna baština 18:68– 89. Eliade, M. 1987. The Sacred and The Profane: The Nature of Religion. Harvest, Brace and World. European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control. n.d. ‘Plague.’ https://www.ecdc .europa.eu/en/plague. Frazer, J. G. 1922. The Golden Bough: A Study in Magic and Religion. Palgrave Macmillan. Godec Čizmarevič, M. 2022. ‘Tema kuge v slovenskem pripovedništvu od realizma do socialnega realizma.’ Master’s thesis, University of Maribor. Golec, B. 2022. ‘Kužne epidemije na Dolenjskem med izročilom in stvarnostjo.’ In Iz zgodovine epidemij, edited by B. Šterbenc Svetina and M. Preinfalk. Zveza zgodovinskih društev Slovenije. Golec, J. 1934. ‘Zlato in kuga pod križem.’ Slovenski gospodar 68 (51): 3–6. st u d ia u n iv er si ta t is h er ed it a t i, le t n ik 13 (2 02 5) , š t ev il k a 1 / v o lu m e 13 (2 02 5) , n u m be r 1 60 Gunnell, T. 2001. ‘Mists, Magicians and Murderous Children: International Migratory Legends Concerning the “Black Death” in Iceland.’ In Northern Lights: Following Folklore in North-Western Europe: Essays in Honour of Bo Almqvist, edited by S. Ó Catháin. University College Dublin Press. Hojnik, J. 2025. Dravčani: zgodovina Dravcev in njenih prebivalcev. Univerzitetna založba Univerze v Mariboru. Horvat, M. 2011. ‘Kuga.’ In Slovenski lingvistični atlas 1: človek (telo, bolezni, družina), edited by J. Škofic, K. Kenda-Jež, and Mojca Kumin Horvat. Založba ZRC, ZRC SAZU. Jankrift, K. P. 2016. ‘Medicine and Healthcare.’ In Brill’s Encyclopedia of the Middle Ages Online. Brill. Kostanjšek Brglez, S. 2019. ‘Umetnostnozgodovinska podoba makolskih cerkva.’ In Zbornik Občine Makole: ob 250-letnici župnije Makole, edited by T. Kmet. Občina Makole. Kostanjšek Brglez, S. 2022a. ‘S kužnimi in drugimi boleznimi povezani svetniki na Slovenjebistriškem I.’ Bistriške novice 22 (270): 52–53. Kostanjšek Brglez, S. 2022b. ‘S kužnimi in drugimi boleznimi povezani svetniki na Slovenjebistriškem II.’ Bistriške novice 22 (271): 40–41. Kropej-Telban, M. 2022. ‘Pripovedi o kugi in zdravilne prakse proti tej bolezni v ljudskem izročilu.’ Kronika: časopis za slovensko krajevno zgodovino 70 (special issue): 27–40. Lenček, R. 1943. ‘Dvoje kužnih obredij iz l. 1854.’ Etnolog 16:60–64. Meško, F. K. 1911. Črna smrt. Slovenska matica. Meško, F. K. 1931. ‘Črna smrt: zgodovinska povest.’ Slovenski gospodar 65 (41). https:// sl.wikisource.org/wiki/%C4%8Crna_smrt. Miethke, J. 2016. ‘Society.’ In Brill’s Encyclopedia of the Middle Ages Online, edited by G. Melville and M. Staub. Brill. Möderndorfer, V. 1964. Ljudska medicina pri Slovencih. Slovenska akademija znanosti in umetnosti. Mušič, D. 1982. ‘Verbec, David, pl. (med 1577 in 1578–1643).’ Slovenska biografija. http:// www.slovenska-biografija.si/oseba /sbi771431/#slovenski-biografski-leksikon. Otorepec. 1965. Gradivo za zgodovino Ljubljane v srednjem veku. Vol. 10. https://www.dlib.si /details/URN:NBN:SI:DOC-SM7VZCGZ Pajek, J. 1884. Črtice iz duševnega žitka štajerskih Slovencev. Matica slovenska. Payne Crawfurd, R. 1914. Plague and pestilence in literature and art. Clarendon. Pregelj, I. 1920. Plebanus Joannes. Mohorjeva družba. Ramšak, M. 2019. Zdravje in bolezen na Pohorju. Pivec. Ramšak, M. 2022. ‘Medicine and Fairy Tales: Pohorje Fairy Tales as a Source about Diseases and Health.’ Acta Histriae 30 (3): 655–680. Rus, Z. 2021. Metličani. 1. zv. Mestna skupnost Metlika. Skenderović, R. 2003. ‘Kuga u Požegi i Požeškoj kotlini 1739. godine.’ Scrinia Slavonica 3 (1): 157–170. Slekovec, M. 1883. ‘Kuga na slovenskem štajerskem.’ Slovenski gospodar 17/18:142. Smole, M. 1957. ‘Kuga na Kranjskem v XVI. stoletju.’ Kronika: časopis za slovensko krajevno zgodovino 5 (2): 97–98. Snoj, M. 2014. Slovar jezika Janeza Svetokriškega. Založba ZRC, ZRC SAZU. Stabej, J. 2014. Slovensko-latinski slovar po: Matija Kastelec – Gregor Vorenc, Dictionarium Latino-Carniolicum (1608–1710). Založba ZRC, ZRC SAZU. Stabej, J. 2023. Hieronymus Megiser: Slovensko- latinsko-nemški slovar po Thesaurus polyglottus (1603). Revised ed. Založba ZRC, ZRC SAZU. Stropnik, Z. 1998. ‘Marko Anton Plenčič (1705–1786).’ In Marko Anton Plenčič, O bolezenskem kontagiju: nova ideja. Medicinska fakulteta. ‘Sveti Rok – romar in spokornik.’ n.d. Svetniki, mučenci in blaženi krstni zavetniki. https:// svetniki.org/sveti-rok-romar-spokornik/ ‘Sveti Sebastijan (Boštjan) – mučencec.’ n.d. Svetniki, mučenci in blaženi krstni zavetniki. https://svetniki.org/sveti- sebastijan-bostjan-mucenec/ Se n so ry R ep r es en ta t io n s o f P la g u e 61 Šerbelj, F. 1983. ‘Umetnostni spomeniki v občini Slovenska Bistrica.’ In Zbornik občine Slovenska Bistrica I, edited by F. Šerbelj. Skupščina občine Slovenska Bistrica. Šiles, A., and J. Radšel. 2018. ‘Poročilo o restavriranju stranskega oltarja sv. Boštjana. Župnijska cerkev sv. Andreja Makole.’ Unpublished typescript, Celje. Tomažič, J. 1990. Pohorske pravljice. Mohorjeva družba. Travner, V. 1934. Kuga na Slovenskem. Življenje in svet. Turkington, C., and B. Lee Ashby. 2007. ‘Plague.’ In The Encyclopedia of Infectious Diseases, edited by M. Tibayrenc. Wiley. Umek, E. 1958. ‘Kuga na Štajerskem v letih 1679– 1683.’ Kronika: časopis za slovensko krajevno zgodovino 6 (2): 80–84. Valvasor, J. V. 1689. Die Ehre des Hertzogthums Crain. Endter. Verbec, D. 1618. Exercitationum medicarum, super disputatione quadam de peste, liber unus. Kraus. Zadnikar, M. 1964. Znamenja na Slovenskem. Slovenska matica. Zmazek, M. 2022. ‘Kuga na Slovenskem.’ Kamra: digitalizirana kulturna dediščina slovenskih pokrajin, 29 March. https://www.kamra.si /digitalne-zbirke/kuga-na-slovenskem/. Železnik, U. 2007. ‘Zdravje in bolezen v de Albertisovi knjigi o kugi.’ Annales: anali za istrske in mediteranske študije. Series historia et sociologia 17 (1): 29–46. Železnik, U. 2013. ‘Zamejevanje epidemij kuge v pristaniških mestih severnega Jadrana: primerjava med beneško Istro in Avstrijskim primorjem v 18. stoletju.’ Povijesni prilozi 45:313–331. Železnik, U. 2015. ‘Kuga in prestopki zoper zdravje: iz fragmentov sodnih procesov (Koper, 1630–31).’ Acta Histriae 23 (4): 713– 734. Žepič, V. 2022. ‘Pandemic Criminal Law’ in Continental European Legal History.’ Journal on European History of Law 13 (2): 50–63. Žnidar, P. 2012. ‘Znamenja in kapelice v studeniški in makolski župniji.’ Degree thesis, University of Maribor. Summary This article explores the sensory experiences asso- ciated with death during plague outbreaks with- in a specific historical and geographical context. The author focuses on the plague altar from the mid-eighteenth century in the Haloze Church of St Andrew in Makole, Slovenia, created between 1751 and 1756 by the sculptor Jožef Štraub. Par- ticular attention is given to the lower part of the altarpiece, painted by an unknown artist, which depicts harrowing scenes of everyday life during plague epidemics. The plague altar conveys religious messages and reflects contemporary knowledge and belief in miasma theory, particularly understandings of plague odour, plague regulations, and civil protec- tion organisation. The lower painting shows nine adults and one infant in various states of suffering, while four men and a woman provide care or carry away the deceased on stretchers. Notably, a wom- an covers her nose with a handkerchief due to the stench of corpses, indicating awareness of airborne disease transmission according to miasma theory. The analysis employs Roland Barthes’ con- cepts of punctum and studium, using the viewer’s personal emotional response as a starting point for broader historical and public health interpreta- tion of plague in the region. The article surveys the history of plague in Slovenian territories from the earliest eighth-century records to the final eight- eenth-century outbreaks, examining cultural and spiritual responses to epidemics, including beliefs in the purifying power of fire and smoke. The altar represents a connection between spiritual and material worlds, with realistic scenes of suffering in the lower part symbolising earth- ly experience, while saints and angels in the upper part represent supernatural protection. The work serves as visual communication of collective trau- ma and hope during difficult times. Povzetek Članek obravnava čutne izkušnje, povezane s smrtjo v času kuge, in jih umešča v določen zgodo- st u d ia u n iv er si ta t is h er ed it a t i, le t n ik 13 (2 02 5) , š t ev il k a 1 / v o lu m e 13 (2 02 5) , n u m be r 1 62 vinski ter geografski okvir. Avtorica se osredotoča na kužni oltar iz sredine 18. stoletja v haloški cerkvi sv. Andreja v Makolah v Sloveniji, ki ga je med leto- ma 1751 in 1756 ustvaril kipar Jožef Štraub. Poseb- no pozornost namenja spodnjemu delu oltarne sli- ke neznanega avtorja, ki prikazuje grozljive prizore vsakdanjega življenja med kužno epidemijo. Kužni oltar ne prenaša le verskih sporočil, temveč odraža tudi takratno znanje in vero v teo- rijo miazme, zlasti razumevanje vonja kuge, pred- pisov o kugi in organizacije zaščite prebivalstva. Spod nji del slike prikazuje devet odraslih oseb in enega otroka v različnih stanjih trpljenja, med- tem ko jim štirje moški in ena ženska nudijo po- moč ali odnašajo umrle na nosilih. Posebej opazna je ženska, ki si zaradi smradu trupel pokriva nos z robčkom, kar kaže na zavedanje o prenašanju bo- lezni po zraku v skladu z razumevanjem miazme. Analiza temelji na Barthesovih konceptih punctum in studium, kjer osebni čustveni odziv gledalca služi kot izhodišče za širšo zgodovinsko in javnozdravstveno razlago kuge v regiji. Članek vključuje pregled zgodovine kuge v slovenskih de- želah, od najzgodnejših zapisov iz 8. stoletja do zadnjih izbruhov v 18. stoletju, ter preučuje kultur- ne in duhovne odzive na epidemije, vključno z ve- rovanji o čistilni moči ognja in dima. Oltar predstavlja povezavo med duhovnim in materialnim svetom, kjer realni prizori trpljen- ja v spodnjem delu simbolizirajo zemeljsko izku- šnjo, medtem ko svetniki in angeli v zgornjem delu predstavljajo nadnaravno zaščito. Delo služi kot vi- zualno sporočilo o kolektivni travmi in upanju v težkih časih.