I. MIHALIC POKOPEC et al.: EFFECT OF INOCULATION ON THE FORMATION OF CHUNKY GRAPHITE ... 275–281 EFFECT OF INOCULATION ON THE FORMATION OF CHUNKY GRAPHITE IN DUCTILE-IRON CASTINGS VPLIV MODIFIKACIJE NA NASTANEK GRUDASTEGA GRAFITA V ULITKIH IZ GNETLJIVEGA @ELEZA Ivana Mihalic Pokopec1, Primo` Mrvar2, Branko Bauer1 1University of Zagreb, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering and Naval Architecture, Ivana Lucica 5, 10002 Zagreb, Croatia 2University of Ljubljana, Faculty of Natural Science and Engineering, Lepi pot 11, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia branko.bauer@fsb.hr Prejem rokopisa – received: 2015-12-23; sprejem za objavo – accepted for publication: 2016-02-22 doi:10.17222/mit.2015.355 Chunky graphite is one of the most deleterious graphite degenerations in thick-walled ductile-iron castings. This defect normally appears in the thermal center of a casting and dramatically decreases the mechanical properties. Chunky-graphite formation is primarily caused by a reduction in the cooling rate and melt composition. An addition of subversive elements (Bi, Sb, Pb, Sn,...) associated with a small amount of Ce is known to be beneficial to avoid chunky graphite. In this study, the effects of Bi and Ce additions at different cooling rates on the graphite morphology and mechanical properties of ductile-cast iron EN-GJS-400-18-LT were investigated. Y-blocks with wall thicknesses of 25 mm and 75 mm and cylindrical blocks with a diameter of 200 mm and a height of 300 mm were cast. The presence of chunky graphite in the thermal center of the cylindrical blocks and a decrease in the mechanical properties were revealed, regardless of the presence of Bi. Keywords: chunky graphite, cooling rate, graphite morphology, thick-walled ductile-iron castings Grudast grafit je ena od najbolj {kodljivih degeneracij grafita v debelostenskih ulitkih iz gnetljivega `eleza. Ta napaka se obi~ajno pojavi v toplotnem sredi{~u ulitka in mo~no zmanj{a mehanske lastnosti. Nastanek grudastega grafita je posledica zmanj{anja hitrosti ohlajanja in sestave taline. Dodatek {kodljivih elementov v sledovih (Bi, Sb, Pb, Sn,...) v povezavi z majhnim dodatkom Ce je poznan kot ugoden za prepre~itev nastanka grudastega grafita. V tej {tudiji je bil prou~evan vpliv dodatka Bi in Ce pri razli~nih hitrostih ohlajanja na morfologijo grafita in mehanske lastnosti gnetljivega litega `eleza EN-GJS-400-18-LT. Uliti so bili Y-kosi z debelino stene 25 mm in 75 mm ter cilindri~ni kosi s premerom 200 mm in visoki 300 mm. Odkriti sta bili prisotnost grudastega grafita v toplotnem sredi{~u cilindri~nih kosov ter zmanj{anje mehanskih lastnosti, neodvisno od prisotnosti Bi. Klju~ne besede: grudast grafit, hitrost ohlajanja, morfologija grafita, debelostenski ulitki iz gnetljivega `eleza 1 INTRODUCTION Chunky graphite, CHG, is one of the most deleterious graphite degenerations in thick-walled ductile-iron cast- ings. CHG normally appears in the thermal center of large castings, and decreases the mechanical properties, in particular the tensile and fatigue strength and elonga- tion. Local, cell-type accumulations of compact graphite forms are characteristic for CHG.1 On the macro-scale, it is optically visible on cut or machined surfaces as a black spot. Microscopic observation shows that CHG consists of large cells of highly branched and intercon- nected graphite strings. A graphite nodule can usually be observed at the end of these strings. CHG grows along the c-axis with a spiral growth mechanism. Although the mechanism of growth is the same as with spheroidal graphite, its driving forces are different.2 A great number of studies have been conducted to describe the CHG formation, but a clear understanding of its appearance and a safe mastering of the metal preparation to avoid CHG are not yet available. The main causes of a CHG formation are a slower cooling rate and the melt composition.3,4 With slower cooling rates and increasing section thicknesses, the size of the spherulites increases and their count per unit of area decreases. In such zones, CHG frequently develops as a result of graphite degeneration.1,5 A high carbon equivalent, approx. >4.1 % of mass fractions, and in- creasing contents of the elements such as Ni, Si, Cu, Ce, Ca, Al, P, Mg promote the formation of CHG.1,2,6,7 The CHG formation is also affected by the presence of low-level elements in the melt. It has been well do- cumented that the presence of either subversive ele- ments, such as Pb, Bi, Sb and As, or excessive RE amounts cause the degeneration of graphite spheriods, i.e., the CHG formation. However, the co-existence of subversive elements and RE in appropriate ratios will result in the retention of spheroidal graphite.8,9 It was found that small amounts of bismuth added to the melt promote the formation of spheroidal graphite. However, when its content exceeds the critical value, Bi is known as a detrimental element, which can cause degeneration of a good nodular graphite structure. This effect was attributed to the interaction between Bi and Mg, which blocks the spheroidization effect of Mg to a certain extent. This negative effect of Bi is mostly MATERIALI IN TEHNOLOGIJE/MATERIALS AND TECHNOLOGY (1967–2017) – 50 LET/50 YEARS Materiali in tehnologije / Materials and technology 51 (2017) 2, 275–281 275 UDK 67.017:621.039.532.2:669.11 ISSN 1580-2949 Original scientific article/Izvirni znanstveni ~lanek MTAEC9, 51(2)275(2017) neutralized with RE additions, especially Ce. The interaction effect between RE and Bi is achieved with the formation of various types of intermetallic compounds, e.g., Bi3Ce4, BiCe3, etc. Intermetallic compounds delete the effect of subversive elements, and also serve as nuclei for the graphite formation.5,9,10 According to reference11, adding 0.002–0.006 % of mass fraction of Bi with a certain amount of Ce, increases the nodule count and prevents the CHG formation in thick sections. But, when the amount of RE exceeds the value required for neutralization of the subversive elements, CHG may form.5 In reference10, it was found that a Ce/Bi ratio of 0.8–1.1 was sufficient to achieve a complete neutraliza- tion of the castings with a relatively long solidification time (e.g., 3200 s), while Ce/Bi ratios in excess of 1.1 were required for the castings with very short solidifica- tion times (e.g., 100 s). P. Ferro et al.5 studied the effects of an inoculant se- quence and inoculant chemical composition on a casting heavy-section microstructure. An in-stream inoculation with an inoculant containing RE and Bi was found to drastically reduce the formation of CHG. This result was attributed to the major fading resistance of such an inoculant compared to the standard ones. They found that Bi is suppressing or reducing the CHG formation by reducing the undercooling, which is considered the main reason for the CHG formation. In this case, Bi behaves in a similar way like Sb, whose effect was confirmed by P. Larrañaga et al.12 Bismuth also has the function to remove the oxygen absorbed at the interface between graphite and liquid iron, thus reducing the oxygen absorption and preventing the formation of CHG.5 Although it is known that the correlation between the ratio of RE/subversive elements and the appearance of chunky graphite in thick-walled ductile-iron castings exists, this area is still not fully investigated. More work is needed to provide a correct balancing of the RE/Bi ratio that would prevent the formation of chunky gra- phite. In the present work, the solidification behavior of large ductile-iron blocks with or without an addition of Bi and the same amount of Ce are compared by means of a microstructure observation and measuring of mecha- nical properties. Bi and Ce were supplied from different inoculants. 2 EXPERIMENTAL PART The test castings used in this study were Y blocks, 25 mm and 75 mm in size and cylindrical blocks with a diameter of 200 mm and a height of 300 mm, Figure 1, to enable the investigation of the influence of different solidification times on the chunky graphite formation. The thermal modulus, i.e., the relation between the vol- ume and the cooling surface area (V/A) of a cylinder was 3.75 cm. Two moulds (M1, M2), with the same test castings, were produced from sodium silicate bonded sand. With the aim to limit the number of the parameters, all the samples were cast using the same melt. The melt was produced in a 5.6 t capacity medium-frequency induction furnace. The charge material consisted of grey pig iron (Sorelmetal®), steel scrap and returns as listed in Table 1. In order to increase the carbon and silicon con- tent and the nucleation ability of the melt, SiC (~92 % of the mass fractions of SiC) was added into the furnace with the metallic charge. Once the melting was finished, the chemical composition of the metal was adjusted according to the carbon and silicon evaluation obtained with a thermal analysis and spectrometric analysis carried out on the coupon for the other elements. Table 1: Charge materials used for melting Tabela 1: Vlo`ki, uporabljeni za pretaljevanje total mass (kg) pig iron (kg) steel scrap (kg) returns (kg) SiC (kg) 5600 4026 448 1120 6 72 (w/%) 8 (w/%) 20 (w/%) 0.1 (w/%) For both moulds, the spheroidising treatment was carried out in a dedicated ladle with a capacity of 200 kg by adding ~2 % of the mass fractions of the FeSiMg alloy (44–48 % of the mass fraction of Si, 3.5–3.8 % of mass fraction of Mg, 0.9–1.1 % of the mass fraction of Ca, 0.5–1.2 % of the mass fraction of Al, 0.6–0.8 % of the mass fractions of RE, and Fe bal.) using the sand- wich method at ~1480 °C. The FeSiMg alloy was positioned at the bottom of the casting ladle and then covered with steel scrap before pouring the iron from the furnace. 0.7 % of the mass fraction of Ni was also added to the casting ladle. The source of Ni is 99.9 % of the mass fractions of the Ni pure metal. In this type of industrial alloy, it is not possible to sustain the requested 95 % of the mass fraction of the ferritic matrix in the as-cast state, so it has to be heat treated. Ni is added to assure the requested tensile strength (above 400 N/mm2) and to improve the low-temperature ductility after the heat treatment of this alloy. Simultaneously with the spheroidising treatment, the first inoculation (preconditioning) was carried out by adding 0.2 % of the mass fraction of commercial inoculant I1. After the treatment, slag was removed from the melt surface and the melt was poured into the mould. The holding time was ~3 min. The second inoculation (in-stream) during the pouring of the mould was per- formed by adding 0.2 % of the mass fraction of inoculant I2, containing Ce, at ~1380 °C. The Mg recovery was about 75 %. In order to investigate the influence of the Bi-con- taining inoculant in the second mould, inoculation was additionally performed by adding commercial inoculant I3, in the form of a block fixed with the foundry adhesive to the bottom of the downsprue, as indicated in Figure 1. I. MIHALIC POKOPEC et al.: EFFECT OF INOCULATION ON THE FORMATION OF CHUNKY GRAPHITE ... 276 Materiali in tehnologije / Materials and technology 51 (2017) 2, 275–281 MATERIALI IN TEHNOLOGIJE/MATERIALS AND TECHNOLOGY (1967–2017) – 50 LET/50 YEARS The chemical composition of the used inoculants is reported in Table 2. The pouring temperature for both moulds was 1380 °C and the pouring time was 27 s. Just before pouring the melt to the mould, the chilled coupon was analysed with an optical emission spectro- meter (ARL 3460). The C and Si contents were deter- mined from the results of the thermal analysis using the ATAS® system. The chemical compositions are listed in Table 3. Each cylindrical block was afterwards sectioned along the vertical symmetry plane to evaluate the zone affected by CHG. As illustrated in Figure 2, the zone affected by CHG was easily located as the darker zone in the thermal center of the casting. Zones 1 and 2 were from the CHG area and zone 3 was from the border of the CHG area. Also, the samples obtained from these zones were prepared for the metallographic analysis; samples S1, S2 and S3 as shown in Figure 2. The metallographic analysis was done with an optical microscope (Olympus GX 51), equipped with a system for automatic image processing (Analysis® Materials Research Lab). All the metallographic parameters such as nodularity, nodule count, nodule size, area fraction of graphite, graphite particle size class distribution, graphite shape classification and ferrite/pearlite ratio were evaluated according to the Standard EN-ISO 945-1 2010. Finally, tensile-test bars were machined out from the core of each cylindrical block as indicated in Figure 2. Y blocks of 25 mm and 75 mm were also machined to obtain tensile-test bars. The samples for the metallographic analysis of the Y blocks were collected from the heads of the tensile-test bars. The microstructure in the vicinity of the fracture surface of the tensile-test bars was investigated under an optical microscope. The samples for the metallographic analysis were prepared with the standard methods of grinding, polishing and etching in 5 % nital. The microstructures I. MIHALIC POKOPEC et al.: EFFECT OF INOCULATION ON THE FORMATION OF CHUNKY GRAPHITE ... Materiali in tehnologije / Materials and technology 51 (2017) 2, 275–281 277 MATERIALI IN TEHNOLOGIJE/MATERIALS AND TECHNOLOGY (1967–2017) – 50 LET/50 YEARS Figure 1: Pattern used in the experiment Slika 1: Vzorec, uporabljen pri preizkusu Table 2: Chemical compositions of inoculants Tabela 2: Kemijska sestava modifikatorjev Inoculant Chemical composition, (w/%) Si Mg Ca Al Ce Ba RE Bi S O Fe I1 64–70 – 1.0–2.0 0.8–1.5 – 2.0–3.0 – – – – bal. I2 70–76 – 0.75–1.25 0.75–1.25 1.5–2.0 – – – (<1%) (<1%) bal. I3 71.33 0.79 3.96 1.20 Table 3: Chemical compositions of the melts, (w/%) Tabela 3: Kemijska sestava talin, (w/%) C Si Mn P S Mg Ni M1 3.68 1.65 0.13 0.034 0.01 0.049 0.741 M2 3.67 1.62 0.13 0.032 0.011 0.043 0.761 Figure 2: Central sections of cast cylindrical blocks M1 and M2 (zones 1, 2 and 3) Slika 2: Sredinski del cilindri~nih kosov M1 in M2 (podro~ja 1, 2 in 3) were analysed according to the Standard EN ISO 945-1:2008. Tensile tests were carried out on a tensile-testing machine (Fritz Heckert ZD-20) at room temperature on five samples taken from the Y blocks and two samples taken from the cylindrical blocks. The yield strength, tensile strength and elongation were determinated according to the Standard EN 1563. 3 RESULTS 3.1 Macro- and microstructures Usually CHG is easily detected after sectioning a casting. The presence of CHG is visible as a localized darkening of the surface, often revealed without any need of chemical etching. In Figure 2, the CHG macrostruc- tures of the cross-sections of the cylindrical blocks are clearly visible. CHG appeared in the thermal centers due to the slowest cooling rates, in both blocks, with and without Bi. The solidification time in the centre was 5140 s, determined from the results of the simulation in the ProCAST® software. Evident differences in the proportion of the areas affected by CHG in these two cast blocks were observed, as shown in Figures 2 and 3. The diameter of the area affected by CHG at the top of zone 1 for M1 was 129 mm, and 78 mm for M2, Figure 3. The area affected by CHG appeared in an ellipsoid shape in the cross-section along the vertical symmetry plane, for both blocks. The CHG zone for M1 starts 58 mm from the bottom of the block, and 87 mm for M2, as can be seen in Figure 2. An addition of Bi caused a significant reduction of the CHG-affected zone, at the lower cooling rates in the centre of a block. The microscopic observation showed that CHG occurred locally, having typical cell-type structures, Figure 4. These cells were relatively large, with the apparent diameter in the range of 0.5–1.5 mm, with a sharp transition between the non-affected and the affected zones, Figures 4 and 5. Inside the CHG area, zones with spherical graphite were found. Distribution of CHG is generally not uniform within the affected zone. The samples with a Bi addition showed a pronounced eutectic growth in zones 1 and 3, while in the samples without a Bi addition, it was more difficult to distinguish specific cells in zones 1 and 2, Figure 4. The nodules around the CHG area in zones 1 and 2 showed a regular shape, while in zone 3 more degenerated nodules were found. As can be seen from Table 4, after long solidification times, from 3670 s to 5140 s, a significant graphite deterioration occurred with the graphite nodularity in the vicinity of 50 %, and a very low nodule count, below 50 I. MIHALIC POKOPEC et al.: EFFECT OF INOCULATION ON THE FORMATION OF CHUNKY GRAPHITE ... 278 Materiali in tehnologije / Materials and technology 51 (2017) 2, 275–281 MATERIALI IN TEHNOLOGIJE/MATERIALS AND TECHNOLOGY (1967–2017) – 50 LET/50 YEARS Figure 3: Cross-sections of cast blocks at the top of zone 1: a) M1 without Bi, b) M2 with Bi Slika 3: Prerez ulitega kosa na vrhu podro~ja 1: a) M1 brez Bi, b) M2 z Bi Table 4: Graphite-microstructure data for cylindrical blocks in CHG area according to EN-ISO 945-1 Tabela 4: Podatki o mikrostrukturi grafita v cilindri~nih kosih v podro~ju CHG, skladno z EN-ISO 945-1 Mould Zone (Figure 2) Shape Size Nodula- rity (%) Nodule count (mm–2) Area frac. of graphite (%) Size distribution 3 (max. 500 μm) 4 (max. 250 μm) 5 (max. 120 μm) 6 (max. 60 μm) 7 (max. 30 μm) 8 (max. 15 μm) M1 1 V,III(35 %) 6 47 65 10.7 0 3 107 426 789 1284 2 V,II (35 %) 5 48 38 10.8 2 11 87 330 473 741 3 IV 6 51 47 11.1 1 8 67 392 753 1287 M2 1 V,II (40 %) 6 45 25 10.4 0 5 105 472 729 807 2 6 49 42 8.9 0 12 99 365 463 396 3 V,II (45 %) 6 40 43 10.3 0 10 135 459 788 694 nodules/mm2 (except in zone 1 of M1). The obtained nodule count was substantially below the recommended minimum nodule count for heavy-section castings, which is more than 60 nodules/mm2. The results were slightly inferior for the samples with the Bi addition. The results of the nodule count cannot be related with the solidi- fication time. The lowest nodule count was observed for cylindrical block M2. With the decrease in the nodule count for the cylinders, the size of the nodules increased, Figure 4. Also, the Bi addition reduced the amount of ferrite, from approx. 90 to 80 %, Table 5. Table 5: Ferrite/pearlite ratio of cylindrical blocks in CHG area according to EN-ISO 945-1 Tabela 5: Razmerje ferit/perlit v cilindri~nih kosih v podro~ju CHG, skladno z EN-ISO 945-1 Mould Zone(Figure 2) Ferrite area % Pearlite area % M1 1 91.4 8.6 2 91.8 8.2 3 90.6 9.4 M2 1 85.3 14.7 2 81.4 18.6 3 79.8 20.2 I. MIHALIC POKOPEC et al.: EFFECT OF INOCULATION ON THE FORMATION OF CHUNKY GRAPHITE ... Materiali in tehnologije / Materials and technology 51 (2017) 2, 275–281 279 MATERIALI IN TEHNOLOGIJE/MATERIALS AND TECHNOLOGY (1967–2017) – 50 LET/50 YEARS Figure 5: Fracture surface of a test bar (M1-2) Slika 5: Prelom preizkusne palice (M1-2) Figure 4: Microstructures from zones 1, 2, 3 from blocks M1 and M2 Slika 4: Mikrostrukture iz razli~nih podro~ij 1, 2, 3, iz kosov M1 in M2 Figure 6: Microstructures of Y-blocks, 25 mm: a) M1 without Bi, b) M2 with Bi Slika 6: Mikrostrukturi Y-kosa, 25 mm: a) M1 brez Bi, b) M2 z Bi In the Y blocks of 25 mm and 75 mm, CHG did not appear, Figure 6. The nodule count of the Y blocks was in a range from 74 to 405 nodules/mm2. The nodularity was from 60 % to 73 %. The bismuth addition negatively affected the microstructure regarding the nodule count, while the nodularity was positively affected. 3.2 Tensile test Table 6 gives the tensile-test results for the CHG area in the cylindrical blocks. The samples containing CHG were characterized by a significant reduction in the elon- gation and tensile strength compared to the CHG-free samples from the Y blocks. The samples from the Y blocks showed elongation values in the vicinity of 18 %, while the samples containing CHG achieved elongation values in a range of 3.5–7.5 %. The tensile strength values for the CHG area were reduced by 20–25 %, while the yield strength was reduced by 10 %. Hardness was hardly affected at all. Table 6: Mechanical properties in the CHG area Tabela 6: Mehanske lastnosti v podro~ju CHG Mould Specimen RmN/mm2 Rp0,2 N/mm2 A5 % HB M1 1 323 269 4.2 140 2 317 269 3.5 - M2 1 345 249 7.5 123 2 331 259 5.5 - The effect of the Bi addition on the mechanical properties can be seen. In the CHG area, the Bi addition resulted in better elongation and tensile-strength proper- ties, while the yield strength and hardness were slightly reduced, Table 6. In the Y blocks, the Bi addition posi- tively influenced the elongation properties, while the strength properties were reduced. Visual testing of the fracture surfaces of the tensile- test bars pointed out local dark areas of various sizes. The macroscopic observation of CHG corresponded very well with the microscopic observations, Figure 5. On the fracture surface, eutectic cells of chunky graphite sur- rounded with normal spheroidal graphite were detected. 4 DISCUSSION High concentrations of Ce, Ca, Si and Ni are the usual reasons of the CHG formation. Excessive Ce, in the absence of subversive elements in heavy-section ductile iron will almost always cause a CHG formation. In thin-section castings, the risk of a CHG formation is minimum due to short solidification times. Most MgFeSi alloys contain some level of RE, especially Ce, to promote a high nodule count, improve nodularity and counteract the effects of anti-nodularising elements. This is usually good for thin-section parts, but it is a problem for the sections thicker than 50 mm. There is a unified opinion found in the literature that an addition of Bi (up to about 0.003 % of mass fraction) can prevent the formation of degenerated graphite in thick- section castings.14 To eliminate the detrimental effect of RE, the most important task to do is to achieve the right balance between the presence of RE and the subversive elements.1,7 Note also that the amount of Bi required to counteract the detrimental effect of RE (Ce) is casting section-size dependent. In this study the Bi addition did not totally suppress the CHG formation, but the added amount reduced the area affected with CHG. The amount of Bi was too low and the presumption is that the right balance between Ce and Bi would prevent the formation of CHG. The microstructure analysis of the CHG area in the cylindrical blocks showed similar results with and without a Bi addition. The present results indicate that the addition of Bi to heavy-section ductile-iron castings exhibited a beneficial effect of a decreasing CHG area as reported in other works.5,13,14 5 CONCLUSION Based on the results obtained in this study, the following main conclusions can be drawn: • CHG occurred in the thermal center of a heavy- section ductile-iron casting; • a Bi addition has a positive influence on the CHG suppression in thick-section areas, while maintaining good mechanical properties in thin-section areas; • the Bi addition also improved the tensile strength and elongation in the CHG area; • for the investigated section size, the addition of Bi was too low to totally suppress the CHG formation. Acknowledgements This work was partially supported by the foundry MIV d.d., Vara`din. 6 REFERENCES 1 H. Löblich, Effect of nucleation conditions on the development of chunky graphite in heavy ductile iron castings, Giessereiforschung, 58 (2006) 3, 28–41 2 O. Knustad, L. Magnusson Åberg, Chunky graphite, effects and theories on formation and prevention, 14th Inter. Foundry Confe- rence, Opatija, Croatia, 2014 3 R. Källbom, K. Hamberg, M. Wessen, L.-E. Björkegren, On the solidification sequence of ductile iron castings containing chunky graphite, Materials Science and Engineering A, 413–414 (2005), 346–351, doi:10.1016/j.msea.2005.08.210 4 J. Lacaze, L. Magnusson, J. Sertucha, Review of microstructural features of chunky graphite in ductile cast irons, Keith Millis Symp. on Ductile Cast Iron, Nashville, USA, 2013, 360–368 5 P. Ferro, A. Fabrizi, R. Cervo, C. Carollo, Effect of inoculant con- taining rare earth metals and bismuth on microstructure and mechanical properties of heavy-section near-eutectic ductile iron castings, Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 213 (2013), 1601–1608, doi:10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2013.03.012 I. MIHALIC POKOPEC et al.: EFFECT OF INOCULATION ON THE FORMATION OF CHUNKY GRAPHITE ... 280 Materiali in tehnologije / Materials and technology 51 (2017) 2, 275–281 MATERIALI IN TEHNOLOGIJE/MATERIALS AND TECHNOLOGY (1967–2017) – 50 LET/50 YEARS 6 K. Hartung, O. Knustad, K. Wardenaer, Chunky graphite in ductile cast iron castings – Theories and examples, Indian Foundry Journal, 55 (2009), 25–29 7 R. Källbom, K. Hamberg, L. E. Björkegren, Chunky Graphite - Formation and Influence on Mechanical Properties in Ductile Cast Iron, Proc. of Gjutdesign 2005, Espoo, Finland, 2005 8 S. Mendez, D. Loper, I. Asenjo, P. Larrañaga, J. Lacaze, Improved analytical method for chemical analysis of cast iron, Application to castings with chunky graphite, ISIJ International, 51 (2011), 242–249 9 P. C. Liu, C. R. Loper Jr., T. Kimura, H. K. Park, Study of chunky graphite in heavy section ductile iron, AFS Transactions, 83–51 (1983), 119–126 10 E. N. Pan, C. Y. Chen, Effects of Pb and solidification conditions on the graphite structure of heavy-section ductile cast iron, AFS Transactions, 103 (1995), 265–273 11 M. Koch, Chunky Graphite, Effects and theories on formation and prevention, 2013 Keith Millis Symp. on Ductile Cast Iron, Nashville, USA, 2013 12 P. Larrañaga, I. Asenjo, J. Sertucha, R. Suarez, I. Ferrer, J. Lacaze, Effect of Antimony and Cerium on the Formation of Chunky Gra- phite during Solidification of Heavy-Section Castings, Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A, 36A (2009), 654–661, doi:10.1007/ s11661-008-9731-y 13 E. N. Pan, C. Y. Chen, Effects of Bi and Sb on graphite structure of heavy-section ductile cast iron, AFS Transactions, 104 (1996), 845–858 14 J. Riposan, M. Chisamera, S. Stan, Performance of heavy ductile iron castings for windmills, China Foundry, 7 (2010) 2, 163–170 I. MIHALIC POKOPEC et al.: EFFECT OF INOCULATION ON THE FORMATION OF CHUNKY GRAPHITE ... Materiali in tehnologije / Materials and technology 51 (2017) 2, 275–281 281 MATERIALI IN TEHNOLOGIJE/MATERIALS AND TECHNOLOGY (1967–2017) – 50 LET/50 YEARS