L. KALINA et al.: CONDUCTOMETRY ANALYSIS – BENEFICIAL METHOD FOR DETERMINING ... 357–361 CONDUCTOMETRY ANALYSIS – BENEFICIAL METHOD FOR DETERMINING THE CHEMICAL COMPOSITION OF ALKALINE SILICATE SOLUTIONS KONDUKTOMETRIJA – KORISTNA METODA ZA DOLO^ITEV KEMIJSKE SESTAVE ALKALNIH SILIKATNIH RAZTOPIN Luká{ Kalina 1* , Vlastimil Bílek 1 , Michaela Flídrová 1 , David Markusík 1 , Libor Topoláø 2 , Josef Fládr 3 1 Brno University of Technology, Faculty of Chemistry, Purkyòova 118, 612 00 Brno, Czech Republic 2 Brno University of Technology, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Veveøí 331, 602 00 Brno, Czech Republic 3 Czech Technical University in Prague, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Thákurova 2077, 166 29 Prague, Czech Republic Prejem rokopisa – received: 2023-09-21; sprejem za objavo – accepted for publication: 2024-04-12 doi:10.17222/mit.2024.1005 The study deals with the methodology for determining the chemical composition of alkaline silicate solutions. Nowadays, the most widely used method in industry is titration, using the color change of an acid-base indicator. This technique is very accu- rate for the determination of the total alkalinity (i.e., Na2O, K2O, or Li2O). However, a problem arises in the determination of the SiO2 content, since the color change of the methyl red indicator is very slow and therefore the equivalence point is unclear. The main aim of this work is to present the benefits of conductometric titration, where the equivalence point is indicated by a sudden change in the conductivity. The applicability of the method was verified with other analytical techniques, such as ICP-OES and gravimetric analyses. Their results confirmed the values of the obtained silicate module (the molar ratio of SiO2 and alkaline ox- ide) in the cases of sodium, potassium and lithium water glasses. Based on the obtained results, one can say that conductometry is a very promising method providing an accurate, fast and instrumentally undemanding chemical characterization of alkaline silicate solutions, usable even in a manufacturing process. Keywords: conductometry, titration, chemical composition, alkaline silicate solutions V ~lanku avtorji opisujejo {tudijo, ki se ukvarja z metodologijo dolo~evanja kemijske sestave alkalnih silikatnih raztopin. Dandanes je titracija najbolj raz{irjena in uporabna metoda v industriji pri kateri ovrednotenje temelji na spremembi barve kislega indikatorja. To je zelo natan~na metoda za dolo~itev celotne alkalnosti (naprimer Na2O, K2O, ali Li2O). Vendar problem nastopi, ~e je potrebno dolo~iti koncentracijo SiO2, ker je sprememba barve metil oran`nega indikatorja zelo po~asna in je zato to~ka enakosti zelo nejasna. Glavni namen tega dela je bil predstaviti prednosti konduktometri~ne titracije pri kateri se to~ka enakosti dolo~i z skokovito spremembo prevodnosti raztopine. Uporabnost te metode so avtorji verificirali z uporabo drugih analitskih tehnik, kot sta ICP-OES (angl.: Inductively Coupled Plasma – Optical Emission Spectrometry) in gravimetrija. Eksperimentalni rezultati so pokazali medsebojno primerljivost vrednosti dobljenega silikatnega modula (molarnorazmerje med SiO2in alkalnimi oksidi) v primeruNa, KinLi vodnih stekel. Na osnovi dobljenih rezultatov avtorji zagotavljajo, da je konduktometrija obetajo~a metoda, ki zagotavlja natan~no, hitro in in{trumentalno nezahtevno kemijsko karakterizacijo alkalnih silikatnih raztopin, ki je uporabna celo v proizvodnih procesih. Klju~ne besede: analiza elektri~ne prevodnosti elektrolitov (konduktometrija), titracija, kemijska sastava, alkalne silikatne raztopine 1 INTRODUCTION Alkaline silicate solutions (water glasses) are impor- tant raw materials for many applications. They are widely used, e.g., in foundry, building, paper, and paint industry. 1–3 The most mass-produced alkaline silicate is sodium silicate, whose production in Europe exceeds 500,000 tons per year, followed by the production of po- tassium silicate, which is at a level of approximately 21,000 tons per year, and a maximum of 1,000 tons is at- tributed to the production of lithium silicate, which is a specialized chemical, whose use is limited to the area of coatings. 4 Great demands are placed on its production, regarding its product quality, technological procedures, or certain parameters that the input raw material must meet. When processing water glasses to obtain a new product with desired properties, it is crucial to know the chemical composition of the water glass used. The analy- ses can be performed with different methods, of which the most commonly industrially used one is the titri- metric method based on the color change of the indica- tor. 5 This analysis includes a titration of a water glass sample with a volumetric solution of hydrochloric acid using methyl red as the indicator. The mentioned proce- dure determines the M 2 O alkali content (i.e., Na 2 O, K 2 O, or Li 2 O) very precisely, but the method is inaccurate for the determination of the SiO 2 content. The main problem is the color change of the indicator during the subsequent titration, which is very gradual and, therefore, the deter- mination of the equivalence point is ambiguous. From this point of view, a conductometric analysis based on titration with a volumetric solution of hydro- Materiali in tehnologije / Materials and technology 58 (2024) 3, 357–361 357 UDK 544.623:543.242 ISSN 1580-2949 Original scientific article/Izvirni znanstveni ~lanek MTAEC9, 58(3)357(2024) *Corresponding author's e-mail: kalina@fch.vut.cz (Luká{ Kalina) chloric acid appears to be a very promising method, which could solve the above-mentioned problem. The method is based on the fact that in solutions of electro- lytes the electric-current conduction is realized by the movement of ions. Therefore, the conductivity can be re- ferred to as ionic or electrolytic. 6 However, what is very important for conductometric titrations is the fact that different ions can have different conductivities, so there can be changes in conductivities during the titration. The specific conductivity of an electrolyte solution depends not only on the type of ion, but also on its concentration. The most concentrated solutions of titration agents are used for the determination in order to avoid deformation of the linear dependence by diluting the titrated solution. The end of the titration is determined by the break in the titration curve. 7 The aim of this article is to verify the applicability of conductometry analysis for the purpose of fast and accu- rate determination of the chemical compositions of vari- ous types of alkaline silicate solutions on an industrial scale. The measured results were compared with the cur- rently used titrimetric method based on the color change of the acid-base indicator and subsequently verified us- ing the ICP-OES and gravimetric determinations. 2 EXPERIMENTAL PART 2.1 Materials The sodium (Na-WG), potassium (K-WG) and lith- ium (Li-WG) silicate solutions (water glasses) used for the chemical analyses described below were supplied by the SChem a.s. company. The silicate modules as well as alkali and silica contents provided by the manufacturer are summarized in Table 1. Table 1: Chemical-composition data of water glasses according to the supplier w M2O (w/%) w SiO2 (w/%) Ms Na-WG 16.65 31.66 1.96 K-WG 25.50 28.38 1.75 Li-WG not specified not specified 2.64 2.2 Conductometric titration The procedure itself consists of two titrations, one of which determines the content of M 2 O and the other the content of SiO 2 . When water glass is titrated with a stan- dard volumetric solution of hydrochloric acid and the sil- icate modulus (molar ratio of SiO 2 and alkaline oxide) of the water glass is approximately 2, or higher, only reac- tion (2) applies, so only one sudden change in the con- ductivity appears in the obtained titration curve, which corresponds to the total M 2 O. An example of an obtained titration curve is shown in Figure 1, where the intersec- tion point of two linear parts corresponds to the volume of volumetric solution of HCl at the equivalence point – V HCl in Equation (3). SiO 3 2– +H + HSiO 3 – (1) HSiO 3 – +H + H 2 SiO 3 (2) The determination process itself proceeded as fol- lows. An amount of approximately1gto2gofawa - ter-glass sample was weighed on an analytical balance, and transferred to a 400 mL plastic beaker using distilled water. It was filled up with water to a volume of approxi- mately 200 mL. The resulting solution was placed on a magnetic stirrer. The solution was titrated conducto- metrically (Mettler Toledo conductometer In Lab 731) w i t h1Mh y drochloric acid. Conductivity values were recorded at each addition of 0.5 mL of volumetric HCl solution. The percentage of M 2 O was calculated with Equation (3): w cV M m MO HCl HCl MO s 22 = ⋅ ⋅ 1 2 1000 100 (3) where w M2O represents the percentage weight amount of M 2 O in the water-glass sample (w/%), c HCl is the con- centration of the HCl measuring solution (mol·L –1 ), V HCl is the consumption of volumetric solution of HCl (mL), M M2O is the molar mass of M 2 O (g·mol –1 ), and m s is the weight of the water-glass sample (g). For the determination of SiO 2 , before starting the conductometric titration, a suitable excess of the corre- sponding alkali metal hydroxide (LiOH, NaOH, or KOH) was added to the water glass, which also brought equation (1) into play; as a result, two breaks are visible on the titration curve. The first break corresponds to the titration of OH - and SiO 3 2– , while the second one corre- sponds to the titration of HSiO 3 – . An example of the ob- tained titration curve is shown in Figure 2, where the in- tersection points of three linear parts correspond to the volume of volumetric solution of HCl – V 1HCl and V 2HCl . Subsequently, the percentage of SiO 2 was calculated with Equation (4), w cVV M m SiO HCl SiO s 2 HCl HCl 2 = ⋅− ⋅⋅ () 21 1000 100 (4) L. KALINA et al.: CONDUCTOMETRY ANALYSIS – BENEFICIAL METHOD FOR DETERMINING ... 358 Materiali in tehnologije / Materials and technology 58 (2024) 3, 357–361 Figure 1: Example of a measured conductometric curve for the deter- mination of M 2 O where w SiO2 represents the percentage weight amount of SiO 2 in the water-glass sample (w/%), c HCl is the con- centration of the HCl measuring solution (mol·L –1 ), V 1 HCl is the consumed volume of the HCl solution (mL) corresponding to the titrated sum of OH – and SiO 3 2– ions, V 2 HCl is the consumed volume of the HCl solution (mL) corresponding to the titrated amount of HSiO 3 – , M SiO2 is the molar mass of SiO 2 (g·mol –1 ), and m s is the weight of the water-glass sample (g). 2.3 Titrimetric method with an acid-base indicator The principle of total alkalinity determination is the titration with a standard volumetric solution of hydro- chloric acid, in the presence of methyl red as the indica- tor. Approximately1go ft h ew ater-glass sample was weighed on the analytical balance, and transferred to a plastic beaker with a volume of 400 mL. 50 mL of dis- tilled water and 5 drops of the methyl red indicator were added to the sample. Subsequently, the solution was ti- trated with 1M HCl to the equivalence point, i.e., until a red-violet coloration appeared. The percentage of M 2 O was calculated with Equation (3), where w M2O represents the percentage weight amount of Li 2 O, Na 2 OorK 2 Oin the water-glass sample (w/%), c HCl is the concentration of the HCl measuring solution (mol·L –1 ), V HCl is the con- sumption of the volumetric solution of HCl (mL), M M2O is the molar mass of M 2 O (g·mol -1 ), and m s is the weight of the water-glass sample (g). The principle of the silica-content determination is in an addition of sodium fluoride, which reacts with silicic acid, forming an equivalent quantity of sodium hydrox- ide (5) followed by neutralization with a solution of hy- drochloric acid (6). H 2 SiO 3 +6NaF+H 2 O Na 2 SiF 6 + 4NaOH (5) NaOH + HCl NaCl + H 2 O (6) 100 mL of a 5-% sodium fluoride solution was added to the solution created during the determination of total alkalinity. The resulting solution was titrated with 1M HCl to the equivalence point, i.e., to a red color. Subse- quently, the percentage of SiO 2 was calculated with Equation (7), w cVVM m SiO HCl SiO s 2 2 = ⋅−⋅ () 10 40 (7) where w SiO2 represents the percentage weight amount of SiO 2 in the water-glass sample (w/%), c HCl is the con- centration of the HCl measuring solution (mol·L –1 ), V 1 is the consumed volume of the HCl solution (mL), V 0 is the volume of the HCl solution (mL) added for the blank test, M SiO2 is the molar mass of SiO 2 (g·mol –1 ), and m s is the weight of the water-glass sample (g). 2.4 Induction coupled plasma-optical emission spec- troscopy (ICP-OES) The high accuracy of the chemical determination of sodium silicate solutions was achieved using ICP-OES (Horiba Scientific Ultima 2). Exactly 0.10 mL of the wa- ter-glass sample was added to a 100 mL plastic volumet- ric flask using an automatic pipette. The flask was filled with distilled water to its calibration mark. The prepared solution was diluted 1000×. The sample was then sub- jected to an ICP-OES determination by transport via a peristaltic pump to a nebulizer and further carried by ar- gon to a torch. The measured concentrations of elements were obtained in mg·L –1 . These values were converted to molar concentrations of the given oxides, from which the silicate modulus was calculated. 2.5 Gravimetric determination of SiO 2 For the gravimetric determination of SiO 2 , approxi- mately1gofthew ater-glass sample was weighed and transferred to a porcelain dish with 20 mL of distilled water. The solution in the porcelain dish was covered with a watch glass and 10 mL of concentrated HCl was slowly added to it. The dish was then placed on a hot plate, where the decomposition of the sample was com- pleted at a temperature of 80 °C. Subsequently, the watch glass was rinsed with distilled water and a few drops of concentrated HNO 3 . The dish was left on the hot plate until the solution was evaporated to dryness, then the dish was placed in an oven preheated to 105 °C for 10 min to completely dehydrate the precipitated silicic acid. After being removed from the oven, the dish was placed again on the hot plate and moistened with 5 mL of con- centrated HCl. After 3 min, 100 mL of hot water was poured into the solution. The excluded silicic acid was filtered through ashless filter paper with a high pore den- sity. The filter was washed 3 times with 5 mL of hot 1-% HCl solution. The paper filter with expelled silicic acid was inserted into an annealed crucible and placed in a triangle high above a Meker burner. The annealing pro- cess was lasted until the contents of the crucible dried and the filter paper was ashed. Then the crucible was placed in a laboratory furnace, where it was annealed to L. KALINA et al.: CONDUCTOMETRY ANALYSIS – BENEFICIAL METHOD FOR DETERMINING ... Materiali in tehnologije / Materials and technology 58 (2024) 3, 357–361 359 Figure 2: Example of the measured conductometric curve for the de- termination of SiO 2 a constant weight at 1100 °C; after cooling it down in a desiccator, the crucible with silica was weighed to the nearest 0.1 mg. The entire procedure was repeated 3 times. From the obtained values, the percentage of SiO 2 in the water-glass sample was calculated with Equa- tion (8), w mm m SiO s 2 =⋅ − 100 21 () (8) where w SiO2 represents the percentage weight amount of SiO 2 in the water-glass sample (w/%), m 1 is the weight of an empty annealed porcelain crucible (g), m 2 is the weight of the annealed sample and crucible (g), and m s is the weight of the water-glass sample (g). 3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The titrimetric method using the color change of the acid-base indicator was chosen as the most widely used industrial analysis of alkaline silicate solutions for the verification of the chemical composition declared by the manufacturer. Total alkalinity determination for different types of water glasses provided results without any sig- nificant deviation (Table 2). The color change of the methyl red indicator showed a sharp transition from yel- low to red at the equivalence point. However, complica- tions occurred during the silica content determination. According to the work procedure described in the experi- mental part, the neutralization process with the hydro- chloric acid solution changes the indicator color again L. KALINA et al.: CONDUCTOMETRY ANALYSIS – BENEFICIAL METHOD FOR DETERMINING ... 360 Materiali in tehnologije / Materials and technology 58 (2024) 3, 357–361 Figure 3: Color transition in the determination of the SiO 2 content by the titrimetric method Table 2: Chemical compositions of used water glasses determined with the titrimetric method using the color change of the acid-base indicator titrimetric method (color change from yellow to red) titrimetric method (color change from yellow to orange) Na-WG K-WG Li-WG Na-WG K-WG Li-WG w Na2O w SiO2 w K2O w SiO2 w Li2O w SiO2 w Na2O w SiO2 w K2O w SiO2 wLi2O wSiO2 1 17.00 39.08 25.97 35.95 3.31 20.25 16.73 32.91 25.17 28.44 3.27 17.33 2 16.70 39.46 25.80 35.94 3.33 20.35 16.67 32.89 25.32 28.88 3.20 17.36 3 16.17 39.65 26.11 36.06 3.28 20.25 16.69 32.50 25.51 27.92 3.26 17.34 4 16.47 39.77 26.25 36.19 3.32 20.37 16.79 31.93 25.40 28.15 3.24 17.37 5 16.49 39.65 26.11 36.23 3.14 19.16 16.48 31.95 25.19 28.96 3.24 17.34 6 16.86 39.84 25.89 36.13 3.26 20.24 16.19 31.87 25.10 28.80 3.25 17.40 Avg. 16.62 39.57 26.02 36.08 3.27 20.10 16.59 32.34 25.28 28.53 3.24 17.35 SD 0.30 0.27 0.17 0.12 0.07 0.47 0.22 0.49 0.16 0.42 0.02 0.03 Ms 2.46 2.17 3.05 2.01 1.77 2.66 Ms (ICP-OES) 1.84 1.74 2.60 1.84 1.74 2.60 Table 3: Chemical compositions of used water glasses determined with the conductometric analysis conductometric analysis Na-WG K-WG Li-WG w Na2O w SiO2 w K2O w SiO2 w Li2O wSiO2 1 16.81 32.06 25.61 28.36 3.22 17.15 2 17.02 32.60 25.48 28.92 3.24 17.16 3 16.56 31.97 25.31 28.13 3.23 17.15 4 16.92 32.15 25.52 28.62 3.25 17.14 5 16.80 32.37 25.49 28.83 3.26 17.17 6 17.01 32.08 25.43 28.76 3.24 17.15 Avg. 16.85 32.20 25.47 28.60 3.24 17.15 SD 0.17 0.24 0.10 0.30 0.01 0.01 Ms 1.97 1.76 2.63 Ms (ICP-OES) 1.84 1.74 2.60 from yellow to red. However, as can be seen (Figure 3), the color transition in this case is very unclear at differ- ent stages of the titration. In the first phase, the equiva- lence point is determined as a bright red-violet color- ation, which corresponds approximately to the seventh shade in Figure 3 (from left to right). The results of the SiO 2 content showed a relatively small deviation (Table 2 – left side); nevertheless, the total silica content and subsequently calculated silica modulus differed consider- ably from the declared composition (Table 1). For this reason, the approach to determining the equivalence point was changed. It was found from several measure- ments that the equivalence point belongs to an orange shade from Figure 3 (the fourth from the left). Such de- termination has already produced results corresponding to the declared chemical composition as well as the re- sults obtained from ICP-OES analyses. The problematic determination of the silica content gives reason to use another method of evaluation such as conductometric analysis. Its results are included in Ta- ble 3. Both the alkali metal and silica contents are al- ways in good agreement with the values given by the manufacturer. The volume consumptions of the HCl vol- umetric solution were determined from the intersections of linear parts of conductometric curves and not from color transitions. This fact allows a more accurate mea- surement in contrast to the titrimetric method using an acid-based indicator where the accuracy may be affected by subjective color perception. Moreover, measurement deviations are very low, and the results are more consis- tent with the results of ICP-OES. The accuracy of the achieved results was also as- sessed from gravimetric determinations of SiO 2 . The av- erage values of three measurements were 32.07 w/% of SiO 2 in sodium water glass, 28.34 w/% in potassium wa- ter glass, and 17.16 w/% in lithium water glass. Com- paring these results with those of the conductometric analysis, marginal differences were observed. The verifi- cation using the mentioned analyses proves that conductometry provides meaningful results and can also be used advantageously in industrial practice. 4 CONCLUSIONS The presented method for determining the chemical composition of the used water glasses, based on a conductometric analysis, provides satisfactory and accu- rate results, verified with other analytical methods. The currently used titrimetric method using the color change of the acid-base indicator had been shown to be mislead- ing, especially in the determination of SiO 2 . Another rea- son for its unsuitability lies in the use of sodium fluoride, which is classified as a highly toxic substance. On the contrary, in the determination of total alkalinity of alka- line silicate solutions, this method provides representa- tive results. For this reason, a combination of the conductometry analysis and the titrimetric method based on the color change of the acid-base indicator can also be considered. Acknowledgment This outcome was achieved with the financial support within the project GA22-04828S “Advanced lithium sili- cate sealers: on the way to sustainable building materi- als”. 5 REFERENCES 1 J. T. Fox, F. S. Cannon, N. R. Brown, H. Huang, J. C. Furness, Com- parison of a new, green foundry binder with conventional foundry binders, Int. J. Adhes., 34 (2012), 38–45, doi:10.1016/j.ijadhadh. 2011.11.011 2 G. Lagaly, W. Tufar, A. Minihan, A. Lovell, Silicates, Wiley-VCH, 2000 3 M. Collepardi, The New Concrete, 2 nd ed., Grafiche Tintoretto, 2010, 436 4 L. Kalina, V. Bílek, M. Sedla~ík, V. Cába, J. Smilek, J. [vec, E. Bartoní~ková, P. Rovnaník, J. Fládr, Physico-Chemical Properties of Lithium Silicates Related to Their Utilization for Concrete Densifiers, Materials, 16 (2023), doi:10.3390/ma16062173 5 P. Anto{, A. Burian, Vodní sklo, 1 st ed., Sand Team, Ústí nad Labem 2002, 135 6 B. S. Bahl, G. D. Tuli, A. Bahl, Essentials of Physical Chemistry, 1 st ed., S. Chand Limited, 2000, 865 7 V. Bednaøík, M. Vondru{ka, Konduktometrické stanovení slo`ení vodního skla, Chemické listy, 102 (2008), 444–446 L. KALINA et al.: CONDUCTOMETRY ANALYSIS – BENEFICIAL METHOD FOR DETERMINING ... Materiali in tehnologije / Materials and technology 58 (2024) 3, 357–361 361