42 KB1838 KB40 KB197820251999Van Peer, WillieZabukovec, Dušankaštevilka:1letnik:22str. 1-17ISSN:0351-1189COBISSID:9908834URN:URN:NBN:SI:doc-XUIDSFMGslSlovensko društvo za primerjalno književnostPrimerjalna književnostangleška književnostliterarna estetikaliterarna teorijaliterarni kanonliterarno vrednotenjeliterary theoryAli - ali? Ideologija in estetska kakovost v književni kanonizaciji|Either - or? Ideology and aesthetic quality in literary canonization. - Traditional explanations of literary canonization usually involve two concepts: power and beauty. To some, the canon is the result of power conflicts, resulting in a text selection that is largely dominated by ideological content. Rejecting this view as a political simplification that has little to do with the nature of literature, others invoke aesthetic quality as the main criterion for a text's inclusion in the canon. In this article I will argue that this opposition is itself a misconstruction - although the ideological component plays a dramatically different role from what has been assumed by (neo-)Marxist and poststructuralist scholars. I will illustrate my argument with an analysis of the content and form of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, as compared with its near-contemporary The Tragical Historye of Romeus and Juliet by Arthur Brooke. This analysis first follows a more traditional model of textual analzsis, which is thean further corroborated by an independent computer analysis of the same textsRazprava poseže v debate o literarnem kanonu. Izpostavljena je trditev, da so enostranski tako neomarksistični in poststrukturalistični pogledi na kanonizacijo literature kot rezultat konfliktov moči kot tudi stališča o estetski kvaliteti kot ključnem kriteriju. Z analizo Shakespearovega Romea in Julije ter sočasne obdelave zgodbe pri Artjurju Brokesu avtor razgrne presojo,kako je s potezami ideološkega in estetskega, in po njegovi izpeljavi odigrajo ideološke komponente v procesih kanonizacije drugačno vlogo, kot je trdila Barbara Herrnstein Smith (1988). Analizo dodatno podpre še s parametri računalniške analize obeh besedilTEXTznanstveno časopisjejournalsSlovenian National E-content AggregatorNational and University Library of Slovenia