241 KB0 KB200620202007Domajnko, Jernejaštevilka:1/2letnik:18str. 7-31ISSN:1581-6036COBISSID:1612631URN:URN:NBN:SI:doc-PGX9M1WEslPedagoški inštitutSlovensko društvo raziskovalcev šolskega poljaŠolsko poljeargumentacijadebatakritično mišljenjeretorikaučenjeDebatna argumentacija| študij primera televizijske debatne oddaje za mlade|The paper presents debate taught in debate clubs from the perspectives of rhetoric and dialectics and from the perspective of the modern theoretical approach which is a combination of the two formerly mentioned ancient disciplines. This is pragma-dialectics founded by Frans H. van Eemeren and RobGrootendorst. The paper also sees debate in terms of persuasion discourse where we argue that debate clubs and tournaments influence a person's ability of persuasion, foremost logos, which is a rational part of persuasion. Types of argumentation, schemes of argument and methods of reasoning are emphasized since we would like to point out the connection between these theoretical constructs and arguments used by Slovenian debaters. We do this by analyzing arguments in broadcasts for young people called Tekma, debatna oddaja za mlade which were a shortened version of the Karl Popper debate formatČlanek obravnava debato, kot se poučuje v debatnih klubih, z vidikov retorike in dialektike ter z vidika modernejšega teoretskega pristopa, ki je kombinacija omenjenih starodavnih ved. Gre za pragma-dialektiko, ki sta jo zasnovala Frans H. van Eemeren in Rob Grootendorst. Avtorica prav tako obravnava debato v okviru prepričevalnega diskurza, pri čemer je njena glavna teza, da debatni klubi in debatni turnirji vplivajo na posameznikovo sposobnost prepričevanja, predvsem na logos, ki je razumski del prepričevanja. Vrste argumentacije, oblike argumentov in metode sklepanja so še posebej izpostavljene, saj želi pokazati na povezanost teh teoretskih konstruktov z argumenti, ki jih uporabljajo slovenski debaterji in debaterke, preko analize argumentov v mladinskih oddajah Tekma, debatna oddaja za mlade, ki so zasnovane kot skrajšane oblike debatnega formata Karl PopperTEXTznanstveno časopisjejournalsSlovenian National E-content AggregatorNational and University Library of SloveniaSlovensko društvo raziskovalcev šolskega polja