524 KB55 KB201320172014Hejč, DavidPotěšil, LukášSkulová, Soňaletnik:12številka:2/3str. 123-142ISSN:2335-3414COBISSID:4370350URN:URN:NBN:SI:doc-8G2B9QI0enFakulteta za upravoMednarodna revija za javno upravoadministrative procedureappealcentral administrative authoritycentralni upravni organCzech RepublicČeškapritožbaremonstranceugovorupravni postopekRemonstrance against decisions made by central administrative bodies in the Czech Republic|The remonstrance is traditional standard (ordinary) remedial measure which can be (only) applied after the first instance decision has been issued by central administrative body. The article is heading to verify the hypothesis whether the remonstrance does reflect the principle of two instances in entirety. As the finding of the research it can be pointed out that the remonstrance represents relative exclusion of the principle of two instances, which is applied only in a modified form, as the remonstrance is not decided by any higher, independent administrative authority, but by the identical central administrative body, namely by its head, not by its remonstrance committee, which issues "only" recommendations/advices. We concluded that possible solutions are either transformation remonstrance committees into administrative bodies/tribunals, or rules providing the central administrative bodies do not make first instance decisionsUgovor je tradicionalno redno pravno sredstvo, ki se lahko (izključno) uporablja po izdani odločitvi centralnega upravnega organa. Namen članka je preveriti hipotezo, ali ugovor v celoti odraža načelo dvostopenjskega odločanja. Glede na ugotovitve raziskave lahko ugotovimo, da pomeni ugovor relativno izključitev tega načela, ki se uporablja samo v omejeni obliki, saj o ugovoru ne odloča neki višji, neodvisni upravni organ, temveč isti upravni organ, ki je izpodbijani akt izdal, čeprav je njegov predstojnik; ne pa pritožbena komisija, ki izdaja ''samo'' priporočila/nasvete. Ugotovili smo, da sta mogoči rešitvi preoblikovanje pritožbenih komisij v upravne organe/tribunale ali sprejetje pravil, po katerih centralni upravni organi ne bi bili pristojni za odločanje na prvi stopnjiTEXTznanstveno časopisjejournalsSlovenian National E-content AggregatorNational and University Library of SloveniaUniverza v Ljubljani, Fakulteta za upravo