ijems|scientificarticle TheRoleofChallengeBasedLearning inImprovingtheEntrepreneurial MindsetofStudents:ACaseStudy darioberginc gea College–FacultyofEntrepreneurship,Slovenia dario.berginc@gea-college.si valentinajoštlešer gea College–FacultyofEntrepreneurship,Slovenia valentina.jost-leser@gea-college.si katjakraškovic gea College–FacultyofEntrepreneurship,Slovenia katja.kraskovic@gea-college.si Thearticlehighlightstheinfluenceofvariouselementsofen- trepreneurialeducationonstudents’entrepreneurialmindset.A casestudyofteachingentrepreneurshipatgeaCollege–Faculty ofEntrepreneurship(EntrepreneurshipProgramme),Slovenia, whichhasbeeninvestingforyearsininnovativeformsofteaching entrepreneurshipwithanemphasisonchallenge-basedlearning, ispresented.Weusedalongitudinalqualitativeresearchapproach toanalysechallenge-basedlearninginterventionsandprogressof thestudents’entrepreneurialmindset.Alongitudinalanalysiswas conductedbetween2017and2020.Theresultsshowedthatthe third-yearstudentsprovidedmoresolutionproposalscomparedto first-andsecond-yearstudystudents.Theirsolutionstotheprob- lemsthecompanyfacedinthecasestudyweremoremultidisci- plinary,interconnectedandtheyshowedmorematurityandcom- prehensivenessoftheoverviewofthesituation.Studentsinthe thirdyearalsoshowedahigherdegreeofentrepreneurialmind- set.Ourresultsconfirmedexistingstudiesthatchallenge-based learningactivitiespositivelyimpacttheentrepreneurialmindset andopensanewareaofresearchontheconnectionbetweenthe studycurriculum,challenge-basedlearninginterventions,andthe entrepreneurialmindsetofstudents.Wecannotgeneralizethe resultsmorewidely,buttheycanrepresentgoodpracticeforen- trepreneurshipfacultiesinplanningtheircurriculum. volume16|2023|number1|11–34 [12] DarioBerginc,ValentinaJoštLešer,andKatjaKraškovic KeyWords:entrepreneurialmindset,entrepreneurialeducation, challenge-basedlearning,casestudy,Slovenia https://emuni.si/ISSN/2232-6022/16.11-34.pdf introduction Currently,entrepreneurshipisapriorityforeconomic,social,and technologicalgrowth.Therefore,theinterestinunderstandingen- trepreneurshipprocesseshasincreasedsignificantly(López-Núñes etal.2022).Animportantpartofdevelopingentrepreneurialcom- petenciesisanentrepreneurialmindset.Theentrepreneurialmind- setisseenasawayofadaptablethinkinganddecision-makingin complex,uncertainanddynamicenvironments(Naumann2017),as the‘abilitytorapidlysense,act,andmobilize,evenunderhighlyun- certainconditions’(McGrathandMacMillan2000,15)andawayof thinkingortheabilitytoutilizeopportunitiesunderuncertaincon- ditions(Cui,Sun,andBell2021). Foradeeperunderstandingoftheconstructoftheentrepreneur- ialmindset,weneedtounderstandthefactorsthatinfluenceit. Anoverviewofthestate-of-the-artinresearchonentrepreneurial mindsethasshownsevenattributesandassociatedqualitiesinflu- encingentrepreneurialmindset:cognitivetuningandgoalorienta- tion,heuristic-baseddecisionlogic,alertness,priorknowledge,so- cialinteraction,meta-cognition,andcognitiveadaptability(Nau- mann2017).Withintheseattributes,wearemainlyinterestedinthe priorknowledgeattribute,whichfocusesonthequalityofusingab- stractknowledgeindifferentsituationsandfordifferentpurposes andisinfluencedbyexperience,educationandknowledge(Nau- mann2017).Outofthese,wewillespeciallyfocusoneducationand knowledge. Studiesinthisfieldhaveshownthateducationhasapositiveef- fectontheentrepreneurialmindset(Saadatetal.2021).Here,the qualityofeducationandtheaddedvaluethatstudentstakeaway fromeducationareimportant.Theresearchinthisareaconfirms thatlearningbasedondifferentchallenges,connectedwithpractice, hasapositiveeffectontheperceptionofknowledgeandthebuilding ijems TheRoleofChallengeBasedLearning [13] ofstudents’competencies(Salomon2008;Rutkien˙eandTandzegol- skiene2015;Pech,Řehoř,andSlabová2021). geaCollege–FacultyofEntrepreneurship(Slovenia)canbean exampleofgoodpracticeindevelopingtheentrepreneurialmind- setofstudentsthroughanadaptedstudyprocess,whichislargely basedonchallenge-basedlearning(Nichols,Cator,andTorres2016). Moreover,itisalsothekeyreasonthefacultyhasexhibitedgood practiceinteachingentrepreneurshipwithintheheinnovateini- tiative.Inadditiontopracticallyorientedlecturesandexercises, thestudyprocessincludescasestudies,presentationsofbusiness ideas,guestsfrompractice,excursionstocompanies,studentcom- petitionsandmanyotheractivitiesthathelptostrengthentheen- trepreneurialmindsetamongstudents(oecd2021). Thepurposeofthispaperistochecktheprogressofstudentsin thecontextofanentrepreneurialmindsetregardingdifferentinter- ventionsconnectedwithchallenge-basedlearning,aswelltohigh- lighttheimportanceofeducationinbuildingtheentrepreneurial mindsetofstudents–especiallythevariousinterventions(chal- lenge-basedlearning)thatarecarriedoutduringthestudy,andto highlightthoseinterventionsthathavethemostsignificantimpact ontheprogressoftheentrepreneurialmindsetofstudents. literaturereview EntrepreneurialMindset Entrepreneursthinkdifferentlyfromnon-entrepreneurs,andwhen makingdifferentdecisionsinanuncertainenvironment,theyusean approachthatisrecognizedasanentrepreneurialwayofthinking– entrepreneurialmindset(Hisrich,Peters,andShepherd2017).The entrepreneurialmindsetisseenasawayofadaptablethinkingand decision-makingincomplex,uncertainanddynamicenvironments (Naumann2017),theabilitytorapidlysense,act,andmobilize,even underhighlyuncertainconditions(McGrathandMacMillan2000) andawayofthinkingortheabilitytouseopportunitiesunderun- certainconditions(Cui,Sun,andBell2021). Anoverviewofthestate-of-the-artinresearchonentrepreneur- ialmindsethasshownsevenattributesandassociatedqualitiesin- volume16|2023|number1 [14] DarioBerginc,ValentinaJoštLešer,andKatjaKraškovic fluencingentrepreneurialmindset:cognitivetuningandgoalori- entation,heuristic-baseddecisionlogic,alertness,priorknowledge, socialinteraction,meta-cognitionandcognitiveadaptability(Nau- mann2017).Ifwesimplifythemodel,wecansaythatanindividual withahighlevelofentrepreneurialmindsetmustbegoal-oriented, determined,flexible,trainedandinvolvedinthesocialnetwork. Theseattributesaremorevisiblefromtheoutside,andtheycanalso bemeasured.Lessvisibleattributesaremetacognitionandcogni- tiveadaptability,whicharemoredifficulttomeasure,asNaumann (2017)alsopointsout. Anotherpieceofresearchthatincludedareviewoftheliterature onentrepreneurialmindsetfoundthatthreedistinctaspectshave arisenthroughtheyears:theentrepreneurialcognitiveaspect-how entrepreneursusementalmodelstothink;theentrepreneurialbe- haviouralaspect-howentrepreneursengageoractforopportunities; andtheentrepreneurialemotionalaspects-whatentrepreneursfeel inentrepreneurship(Kuratko,Fisher,andAudretsch2021).Accord- ingtothismodel,wecouldsaythatanindividualwithahighlevel ofentrepreneurialmindsethasahighlevelofcognitiveability,is adaptableandisalsoemotionallymature.Itisalwaysacombina- tionofallthreeattributes,someofwhichprevailmore,someless whileitisimportantthattheindividualtriesasbestaspossibleto makeuseofthoseattributesthatcharacterizethemthemost. Thebackgroundideaoftheentrepreneurialmindsetisthatev- eryone,notjustentrepreneurs,canactentrepreneurially.Itisas muchastateofmindascompetenceorskill.Itisaformofproac- tive,flexible,innovativeandmultidisciplinaryactioninallareas, notjustinbusiness.Anentrepreneuriallyorientedstudenthas greaterchancesofgettingajob;anentrepreneuriallyorientedem- ployeewillbemoreproductiveatwork;andanorganizationwith entrepreneuriallyorientedemployeeswillbemoresuccessfuland efficient. EntrepreneurialEducation Variousstudieshavefoundthatentrepreneurialeducation,which promotesanentrepreneurialmindset,playsasignificantrolein ijems TheRoleofChallengeBasedLearning [15] theeconomyandinincreasingeconomicgrowth.Entrepreneurship graduatesarethemainplayersinthedynamismandflexibilityof businessenvironments(O’Connor2013).Entrepreneurialskillsand competenciesareincreasinglyessentialelementsofentrepreneurial economics(Muñoz,Mosey,andBinks2011). Supposewedrawananalogywiththeentrepreneurialmindset andthethesisthattheentrepreneurialmindsetisnotreservedonly forentrepreneurs,butforallentrepreneuriallyorientedindividuals. Moreover,wecansaythatentrepreneurialeducationisnotonlyin- tendedforentrepreneurs,butalsoforallentrepreneuriallyoriented individuals.Researchalsosupportsthelatter.Entrepreneurshiped- ucationisincreasinglybeingseennotonlyasthepreserveofthe selectedfewwithentrepreneurialideas,butalsorelevanttoawider rangeofstudentsinhighereducation(O’Brien,Cooney,andBlenker 2019). Theresearchfoundthatentrepreneurshipeducationhadapos- itiveimpactontheentrepreneurialmindset(Ssadatetal.2021) andonstimulatingstudents’entrepreneurialinspirations(Cui,Sun, andBell2021).Furthermore,Pirha di,Soleimanof,andFeyzbakhsh (2021)proposedthatdevelopingentrepreneurialskillsandcharacter instudentscanhelptoeffectivelydeveloptheabilitytoassessthe desirabilityandfeasibilityofentrepreneurialopportunities,thus developingtheirentrepreneurialmindset.Entrepreneurshipedu- cationpositivelyaffectsthedevelopmentofstudents’creativityby solvingproblems,communicationskills,andopportunityidentifi- cation(Muñoz,Mosey,andBinks2011). Thestudyofcognitivemechanisms,suchaslearningandeduca- tionandtheirinteractionswiththeindividual’sexistingknowledge, constituteoneofthemostimportantpiecesoftheopportunity identificationpuzzle(Corbett2007),whichcanalsobeappliedto entrepreneurshipeducation.Entrepreneurshipeducationincreases theperformancelevelofdimensionssuchasattitude,knowledge, andskillsandtherefore,entrepreneurshipischosenasacareerpath (Kozlinska2012). Variousstudiesemphasizethattheentrepreneurialapproach mustalsofinditsplaceineducation.Modernuniversitiesshould volume16|2023|number1 [16] DarioBerginc,ValentinaJoštLešer,andKatjaKraškovic takeanentrepreneurialapproachtobecomeaplacewhereen- trepreneurshipeducationplaysthemainrole(Gibb2007).Otherre- searchhighlightstheimportanceofdevelopinganentrepreneurial ecosystemtailoredtotheneedsofthestudentstocomplementen- trepreneurshipeducation(Olutuaseetal.2018).Universitiespro- videentrepreneurship-specificeducationtoequipstudentswiththe entrepreneurialalertnessandrisk-takingassetsrequiredtopursue entrepreneurialcareers(Solesviketal.2013).Asystematiclitera- turereviewofcurriculacontentsandteachingmethodshasshown thatentrepreneurshipeducationiswidelysupportedtoproduce opportunitiesfordevelopingyoungandemergingentrepreneurs (SierlkhatimandGangi2015). Successfuluniversitiescombinetheoryandpracticeintheircur- ricula.Agoodtheoryisabasisforpracticalengagement,andtest- ingthetheoryinpracticeanditsconstantadditionenablesthe constructionofabettertheory.Theresearchpointsoutthatef- fectiveentrepreneurshipeducationshouldprovidestudentswith thetheoreticalgroundingandknowledgeaboutentrepreneurship andshouldenablestudentstoengagewithpracticalexperiences wherethisknowledgecanbecriticallyappliedtodeveloppractical entrepreneurialskills(BellandBell2020). Researchshowsthatpracticaleducationinentrepreneurshipis becomingmoreandmorerelevant.Engagingwithpracticalprojects canleadstudentstodeveloptheirself-efficacyunderthetangible achievementsofthistypeofpracticalactivity(Nowinskyetal.2019). Practicalentrepreneurshipeducationactivitiesfocusingoncreating valuecansupportstudentsinidentifyingentrepreneurialopportu- nities(Lackéus2020). Challenge-BasedLearning Thequalityofeducationlargelydependsonthemethodsuniversi- tiesusetolearnentrepreneurship.Manymethodshavevaryingde- greesofsuccessinbuildingentrepreneurialcompetenciesanden- trepreneurialmindset. Studieshaveshownthatstudyinghelpsinthedevelopmentof anentrepreneurialmindset(Nauman2017;Saadatetal.2021),but ijems TheRoleofChallengeBasedLearning [17] differentinterventionswithinthestudycontributedifferentlyto itsdevelopment.Theresearchhighlightsthatengagementwith businesssimulationsandentrepreneurialscenarios(Avramenko 2012;Solomon2008),presentingandpitchingentrepreneurialideas (Bliemel2013),studyingentrepreneurshipcasestudies(Changetal. 2014),andlearningfromrolemodelsandguestspeakerscanall haveapositiveimpactontheentrepreneurialmindsetofstudents (Saadatetal.2021).Wecanfurtherconnectallthementionedinter- ventionsintoasingleconceptknownaschallenge-basedlearning. Challenge-basedlearningcanbedefinedasagrowingapproach ineducationandhasbeenpromotedasameansforstudentsto aligntheacquisitionofdisciplinaryknowledgewiththedevelop- mentoftransversalcompetencieswhileworkingonauthenticand sociotechnicalsocietalproblems(NicholsandCator2008;Nichols, Cator,andTorres2016).Further,thisflexibleapproachframes learningwithchallengesusingmultidisciplinaryactors,technology- enhancedlearning,multi-stakeholdercollaborationandanauthen- tic,real-worldfocus(GallagherandSavage2020).Inparticular,the real-worldfocushasaspecialaddedvalueinthisapproach,asstu- dentscanfaceproblemsfromreal(business)lifeduringtheirstud- ies. Thesystematicreviewofchallenge-basedlearningliterature(Gal- lagherandSavage2020)hasunderlinedthatthemostcommoneight emergingthemesarisingfromtheexplorationofchallenge-based learningresearchdefinitionswerethefollowing:globalthemes,real- worldchallenges,collaboration,technology,flexibility,multidisci- plinarityanddisciplinespecificity,challengedefinition,creativity andinnovation(GallagherandSavage2020). AccordingtoRutkien˙eandTandzegolskiene(2015),knowledge andskillacquisitionvariesconsiderablydependingontheteach- ingmethod.Studentsachievethelowestknowledgeandskillac- quisitioninthetraditionallecture,namelyonly5.Thisisfol- lowedbyreading(10),followedbyvideoandaudiocontent(20), projectpresentations(30)andgroupdiscussions(40–50).Stu- dentsachievethegreatestknowledgeandskillacquisitioninprac- ticalactivitiesandcasestudies(75)andlearningthroughconsul- volume16|2023|number1 [18] DarioBerginc,ValentinaJoštLešer,andKatjaKraškovic tationsandpersonalexperiences(90)(Rutkien˙eandTandzegol- skiene2015). Thestudy,conductedamongmaster’sdegreestudentsattheUni- versityPolitecnicodiTorino,Italy,andinvolving127studentswho answeredthequestionnairesadministeredbeforeandafterpartic- ipationinthechallenge-basedprogram,hasdemonstratedaposi- tiveandsignificanteffectofchallenge-basedlearningprogrammes ontheentrepreneurialmindsetandskillsofstudents,especiallyin financialliteracy,creativity,andplanning(Colombellietal.2022). Otherstudiesinthisareafocusedonspecificaspectsofchallenge- basedlearning.AsurveyofentrepreneurshipeducationatGeorge WashingtonUniversity(usa),conductedamong279respondents, hasshownthatthemostpopulartypeofteachingmethodinen- trepreneurshipcoursesofferedbycollegesanduniversitieswasthe creationofthebusinessplan,followedbyclassdiscussions,guest speakers,casestudiesandlecturesbybusinessowners(Solomon 2008). Furthermore,asurveyamong214studentsfromtheUniver- sityofSouthBohemiainČeskéBudějovice,aimedtofindoutwhat teachingmethodsrelatedtoentrepreneurshipwouldbewelcomed bymanagementstudents.Theresultsdemonstratedthattradi- tionalteachingmethodswererankedlast,suchasessaysandsem- inars,focusingontheoreticalknowledge.Activeteachingmeth- ods,whichincludedbusinesssimulators,role-playing,andspecial projectswherestudentscanconnecttheirknowledgetopractice, wererankedbest.Thesemethodscanalsosupportstudentsinrun- ningtheirbusinessesandeliminatethefearoffailure.Amodern approachtoteachingandusingnewmethodsisexcitingandstimu- latingforstudents(Pech,Řehoř,andSlabová2021).Hence,astudy conductedinSwitzerlandshowedthatactiveapproachestoeduca- tion(games,simulations)aresuitablefordevelopingcriticalthink- ingandmotivation(Gatti,Ulrich,andSeele2019). geacollege–facultyofentrepreneurship geaCollege–FacultyofEntrepreneurship(fromSlovenia)canbe anexampleofgoodpracticeindevelopingstudents’entrepreneurial ijems TheRoleofChallengeBasedLearning [19] mindsetthroughanadaptedstudyprocessanddifferentchallenge- basedlearninginterventions.Besidespracticallyorientedlectures andexercises,thestudyprocessincludescasestudies,presenta- tionsofbusinessideas,guestsfrompractice,excursionstocompa- nies,competitionsandmanyotheractivitiesthathelpstrengthen students’entrepreneurialmindset.geaCollege–FacultyofEn- trepreneurshipisapartofheinnovate(aself-reflectiontoolfor HigherEducationInstitution),aninitiativeoftheEuropeanCom- missioninpartnershipwiththeoecd.Itworksasaself-reflection toolforHigherEducationInstitutionsthatwishtoexploretheir innovativepotential.Theprojectaimstohelpgovernmentsand highereducationinstitutions(heis)enhancetheemploymentout- comesofgraduatesbybetteraligninghighereducationprovision andlabourmarkets.geaCollege–FacultyofEntrepreneurshipis activelyparticipatingintheprojecttodisplaygoodexamplesand learnabouttheinnovationofotherheistoinspireinnovationpo- tential.In2021,gcwasinvitedandparticipatedinprovidinggood practicesintheheinnovateCountryReview(oecd2021). Thementionedreport,inconnectionwithgeaCollege–Faculty ofEntrepreneurship,inparticularfocusedondeliveringmarket- orientedskillsandthenecessityofcooperationwithanetworkof publicandprivatepartners,practicallyorientededucation,collabo- rationwithexternalstakeholders,activitiesoftheCareerCentre, andprovidingentrepreneurshipsupportthroughbusinessincu- batorandcollaborationwithcompanies(e.g.,Studentchallenge competition).geaCollege–FacultyofEntrepreneurshiphasa longtraditionofpromotinganentrepreneurialmindsetinSlove- nia,bothamongyoungpeople(throughentrepreneurialworkshops inhighschools,theYoungEntrepreneurcompetition,andsoon) andamongadults.Studentslearnentrepreneurialskillsthrough variouspracticalactivities,suchaselectivecoursesdedicatedtoen- trepreneurship,butalsofromlecturesdeliveredbyentrepreneurial guestspeakers,visitstocompanies,problem-solvingchallenges andteachingmethodsintendedtoencourageanentrepreneurial mindset.ThegeaCollegefocusesonentrepreneurialteachingand learninginvariousprogrammes,includinglifelonglearningactiv- volume16|2023|number1 [20] DarioBerginc,ValentinaJoštLešer,andKatjaKraškovic ities,amsc,anewanddedicatedmba,aswellasanundergrad- uatebscEntrepreneurshipdegree.OfferedbyitsFacultyofEn- trepreneurship,thisthree-yearbscEntrepreneurshipprogramme usesavarietyofteachingapproaches,includingseminars,casestud- ies,workshops,presentations,groupdiscussionsandprojectwork. Itoffersbothmandatoryandelectivecoursesthatprovidecom- prehensivecoverageofentrepreneurshipandcanbecompletedby presentingadiplomathesisoradegreeexaminationonsolvingan entrepreneurialchallenge(oecd2021). researchproblemandmethodology Withtheresearch,wewantedtofindoutwhichelementsofen- trepreneurialeducationhavethemostpositiveeffectontheen- trepreneurialmindsetofstudentsofEntrepreneurshipatgeaCol- lege–FacultyofEntrepreneurship.Weformulatedthefollowing researchquestion:Towhatextentdodifferentinterventionsin challenge-basedlearninginfluencethestudents’entrepreneurial mindset? Weusedalongitudinalqualitativeresearchapproachtogather thedataforansweringtheresearchquestion: 1Wepreparedthecurriculaanddesignedchallenge-basedlearn- inginterventionsstudentsencounteredduringtheirstud- ies.Totestthechallenge-basedlearninginterventions,we usedthecurriculumofcoreandelectivecoursesoftheEn- trepreneurshipprogramme(table2). 2Totestprogressinthestudents’entrepreneurialmindset,we usedthemethodofsolvingacasestudy.Wecreatedalongi- tudinalanalysistrackingprogressinsolvingthecasestudyin allthreeyearsofstudy(table3). 3Weanalysedthequalitativedata–theopencodingmethod (Creswell,Hanson,andMorales2007) Usingtheopencodingmethod,weperformedacomplexcontent analysis(Krippendorff2021)ofallsolvedcasestudies.Thefirststep intheprocesswasanoverviewofallcasestudiesdonebystudents andcountingthenumberofallgivensolutions(table3).Thesec- ijems TheRoleofChallengeBasedLearning [21] table1 PresentationofCodesandCodeGroups Codes Codegroups Costreduction Acquisitionofnewcapital Creditreprogramming Obtainingnewcredit Finance Retentionofexistingcustomers Diversificationintootherindustries Additionalmarketingactivities Socialnetworking Marketing Analysisandcontrolofoperations Delegationofdecision-making Businessreorganization Outsourcingofexternalconsultants Management Sale,relocationorliquidationofthecompany Creatingabusinessplanandlong-termstrategy Reducingthevolumeofbusiness Searchforstrategicpartners Strategy Reorganisationofproduction Relocationofproductionabroad Outsourcingofproduction Reductioninproductionvolume Production Agreementwithexistingsuppliers Expandingtherangeofsuppliers Reorganisationofthesupplychain Optimisationofinventorymanagement Supplychain Continuedonthenextpage ondstepwascoding.Wecreatedcodesbasedonthesubstantivepro- posalsthatthestudentsprovidedassolutionstotheproblemsand challengesfacedbythecompany.Weidentified40codes,whichwe segmentedinto10groups.Thecodesandgroupsarepresentedin table1. Throughacombinationoftheoryinthefieldofentrepreneurial mindset(Hisrich,Peters,andShepherd2017;Naumann2017;Cui, Sun,andBell2021;Kuratko,Fisher,andAudretsch2021)andour ownanalysis,weidentifiedthreeindicatorswithwhichweevaluated thesolutionsofthecasestudiesforeachclassandforeachacademic year:themultidisciplinarityoftheproposals,theconnectivityof volume16|2023|number1 [22] DarioBerginc,ValentinaJoštLešer,andKatjaKraškovic table1 Continuedfromthepreviouspage Codes Codegroups Agreementwithexistingcustomers Reducingproductprices Introducingadditionaldiscounts Salethroughadvancepayment Sales Legalprotectionofcompanyinterests(patents,models,brands) Studyoflegalpossibilitiesofstrategicalliances Studyofthepossibilityofstatustrans.ofthecompany Examinationofthepossibilityofliquidationofthecompany Law Staffreorganisation Additionalemploymentofcompetentpersonnel Reducingthenumberofemployees Establishingincentiverewards Human resources Preparationofadigitalstrategy Raisingdigitalcompetences Digitizationofbasicbusinessprocesses Digitizationofmarketing Informatics (digitalisa- tion) theproposalsandthecomprehensivenessoftheoverviewofthe situation.Allindicatorsaredirectlyorindirectlyrelatedtoallkey characteristicsofanentrepreneurialmindset(Naumann2017):cog- nitivetuningandgoalorientation,heuristic-baseddecisionlogic, alertness,priorknowledge,socialinteraction,meta-cognitionand cognitiveadaptability.Theycanalsobelinkedtothreeaspectsof entrepreneurialmindset(Kuratko,Fisher,andAudretsch2021), wherebythemultidisciplinaryindicatorismoreanalogoustothe entrepreneurialcognitiveaspect,theconnectionindicatorismore analogoustotheentrepreneurialbehaviouristicaspect,andthein- tegrityindicatorismoreanalogoustotheentrepreneurialemotional aspect. Thequalityoftheproposalswasevaluatedwithaqualitative methodbythreedifferentevaluators.Weratedtheindicatorson ascalefrom1to5,where1meanslow,2sufficient,3average,4good and5excellent.Anevaluatorreadeachsolvedcasestudyofevery studentandrateditagainstthethreeindicators:themultidisci- plinarityoftheproposals,theconnectivityoftheproposalsandthe ijems TheRoleofChallengeBasedLearning [23] table2 ReviewofCurriculaandChallenge-BasedInterventionsinallThree YearsofStudy Item styear ndyear rdyear Numberofcore coursesinwhich students(individ- uallyorinateam) createandpresent practicalproject work Inoutofcom- pulsorycourses, besideshome- work,exercises andcasestudies, thereisalsoprac- ticalprojectwork. Inoutofcom- pulsorycourses, besideshome- work,exercises andcasestudies, thereisalsoprac- ticalprojectwork. Inbothcompul- sorycourses,be- sideshomework, exercisesandcase studies,there isalsopractical projectwork. Numberofelective coursesinwhich students(individ- uallyorinateam) createandpresent practicalproject work Oftheelectivecoursesofferedinthestudiedyears(in –,in–,andin–),all includedpracticalprojectworkthatstudentshadtopre- pareandpresent,eitherindividuallyorinateam. Numberofguests (managers,entre- preneurs,scien- tists)frompractice    Numberofcom- panyexcursions  Continuedonthenextpage comprehensivenessoftheoverviewofthesituation.Finally,wecal- culatedtheaverageofallthreeindicatorsforeachyearofstudyfor everyacademicyear(table4). CurriculaandInterventions WeanalysedthecurriculaofthecoreandelectivecoursesoftheEn- trepreneurshipprogram(1stBolognalevel,bachelor’sdegree),inall threeyearsofstudy.Throughlessonplansandothersupportingin- formation,wedesignedchallenge-basedlearninginterventionsthat studentsencounterduringtheirstudies. TestingProgressthroughSolvingaCaseStudy Inordertotesttheimpactofvariousinterventionsontheprogress ofstudents’entrepreneurialmindsets,weconductedalongitudi- volume16|2023|number1 [24] DarioBerginc,ValentinaJoštLešer,andKatjaKraškovic table2 Continuedfromthepreviouspage Item styear ndyear rdyear Challenge- basedinter- ventionsac- cordingto yearofstudy ()Introduc- torycourse: abcofen- trepreneur- ship. ()Atest ofmea- suringen- trepreneurial compe- tences. ()Student challenge project(prac- ticalbusiness case:team preparation andpresen- tation). ()BusinessPlan(practicalbusiness caseforthestartup:teamprepara- tionandpresentation). ()PlanningCompanyGrowths– practicalbusinesscaseforgrowing company:teampreparationandpre- sentation. ()SolvingEntrepreneurialChal- lenges(forstudentswhochoose diplomaexamsinsteadofa diploma). ()Mandatoryinternshipinthe company. Commonin- terventions ()ParticipationintheactivitiesofgeaTopTalents(tailored programmeforgiftedstudents). ()Thepossibilityofinclusioninabusinessincubator(devel- opmentandrealisationofabusinessideawiththehelpofmen- torsandexpertconsultants). ()Participationincareercentreactivities. ()ParticipationintheactivitiesoftheInternationalOffice (Erasmusmobility). nalanalysisofsolvingthecasestudyinallthreeyearsofstudy(1st Bolognalevel,Entrepreneurshipprogramme).Studentssolvedthe samecasestudyatthebeginningofthe1styear,attheendofthe 2ndyearandattheendofthe3rdyear.Weanalysedthreeacademic yearsstudied:2017–2018,2018–2019and2018–2020.Fromthedif- ferencesintheiranswersatcertainpointsintime,wedetermine theirprogressinthedevelopmentofanentrepreneurialmindset andwhichinterventionsineachyearhadthemostimpactonsaid progress.Theaimoftheexaminationistodeterminewhetherstu- dentsshownewlygainedknowledgewhenadvancingtoahigher year.Thesuccessfulsolutionofabusinesscaserequirestheacqui- sitionofcompetenciesthataredefinedinthecurriculaoftheEn- trepreneurshipprogramme, Theresultsofthemeasurementanalysisshowastudent’sprog- ressinentrepreneurshipskills,understandingofthefinancialas- ijems TheRoleofChallengeBasedLearning [25] table3 NumberofCaseStudyParticipantsandNumberofProposals perStudentbyYearofStudyandAcademicYear Academicyear Casestudyparticipants Proposalsperstudent st nd rd Total st nd rd –     . . . –     . . . –     . . . pectsofbusinessandbusinessgrowth,managementandunder- standingofbusinessstrategies,andalsothestudent’sabilitytocon- nectknowledgefromdifferentsubjectsandthus,alsotheiranalyti- calskills. Thecasestudyreferredtoarealcaseofatransportfamily-owned companyfromSlovenia,facingvariousproblems:fromfinancial, marketing,humanresourcesissuestomanagerialandmore.The studentshadtoputthemselvesintheroleofconsultantsandpro- posevarioussolutions,withthehelpofwhichtheywouldrestorethe companytostability,firstintheshortterm,theninthelongterm. Thestudentshad1hourtosolvetheproblem.Theresearchhasthese limitations:wedidnotmeasureeachstudent’sprogressindividually, butthroughcumulativeresponsesfromallthestudentstogether. Intable3,wepresentthenumberofstudentswhoparticipated insolvingthecasestudyandthenumberofproposedsolutionsper studentbyyearofstudyandacademicyear. Inthe2019–2020academicyear,wemanagedtosignificantlyin- creasethenumberofcasestudyparticipants,especiallyamongfirst- yearstudents.Thereasonispartlyduetolargerenrolment,and partlybecauseofthemorefocusedpromotionofparticipationin theresearch.Theresultsoftheanalysisshowedthatwiththeyears ofstudyacrossallthreeyears,thenumberofproposedsolutionsper studentgrows. Itcanbeseenfromtheresultsthatthelowestlevelofmultidis- ciplinarityandconnectivityofproposals,andoverviewofthesitua- tion,isachievedbyfirst-yearstudents,whilethehighestlevelisby third-yearstudents,acrossallthreestudiedyears. volume16|2023|number1 [26] DarioBerginc,ValentinaJoštLešer,andKatjaKraškovic table4 AssessmentoftheQualityoftheProposalsAccordingtotheThree Indicators Yearofstudy Indicators Academicyear ––– styearofstudy Multidisciplinarity . . . Connectivity . . . Comprehensiveness . . . Average . . . ndyearofstudy Multidisciplinarity . . . Connectivity . . . Comprehensiveness . . . Average . . . rdyearofstudy Multidisciplinarity . . . Connectivity . . . Comprehensiveness . . . Average . . . researchfindings Thelongitudinalanalysisoftheresultsofthecasestudyactually showednoticeableprogressinthestudents’entrepreneurialmind- setduringtheyearsofstudy,anditisalsopossibletoassesswhich challenge-basedlearninginterventionshadthemostimpacton theirprogressinaspecificyear.Theresearchconfirmedandsup- plementedmanystudiesinthisfieldthathadalreadyfocusedon theimpactofchallenge-basedlearninginterventionsontheen- trepreneurialmindsetofstudents(Solomon2008;Avramenko2012; Bliemel2013;Rutkien ˙eandTandzegolskiene2015;Gatti,Ulrich,and Seele2019;Pech,Řehoř,andSlabová2021). Theanalysisfindingshighlightedthatineachyear,students madeprogressinsolvingthecasestudy,bothquantitativelyand qualitatively.Studentsinthesecondyeargavemoreproposedsolu- tionsthanstudentsinthefirstyearandstudentsinthethirdyear gavemoreproposedsolutionsthanthoseinthesecond(table3). Fromthepointofviewofthequalityoftheproposals(themultidis- ciplinarityoftheproposals,theconnectivityoftheproposalsand thecomprehensivenessoftheoverviewofthesituation),asmea- ijems TheRoleofChallengeBasedLearning [27] suredbytheevaluators,theproposalsofstudentsinthesecond yearwereofbetterqualitycomparedtothoseofthefirstandthe proposalsofstudentsinthethirdyearofbetterqualitycompared tothoseofthesecond(table4).Inshort,thethird-yearstudents providedmoresolutionproposals,andtheirsolutionsweremore multidisciplinaryandconnected,whileatthesametime,theypro- videdamorematureandcomprehensiveoverviewofthesituation inthecompanyandpossiblesolutionstotheproblemsthecompany facedinthecasestudy.Therefore,studentsinthethirdyearexhib- itedahigherdegreeofentrepreneurialmindset(Naumann2017; Kuratko,Fisher,andAudretsch2021). Ifwegointoamoredetailedanalysis,wecanseethatatthebe- ginningofthestudy,studentsweremorefocusedonquickpartial solutionsandshowedfewersolutions.Theresultsunderlinethat theyneedamorecomprehensiveoverviewofthesituationandtake amultidisciplinaryapproachtoalesserextent. Attheendofthesecondyear,studentsalreadystartlookingfor morelong-termsolutions.Theyalsoprovideseveralsolutionsre- latedtofinanceandmarketing.Theirprogressislargelytheresult ofthethreefinanceandtwomarketingcoursestheytakeinthesec- ondyearandparticipatinginthestudentchallenge(practicalteam projectwork),whichisalsocarriedoutinthesecondyear. StudentsinthethirdyearoftheEntrepreneurshipprogramme showamorebalancedselectionofmeasures.Itisacombination ofquicksolutions,aswellasmorestrategicallyorientedsolutions (businessplancreation),wherethedifferencefromtheanswers givenbystudentsinthefirstandsecondyearsisclear.Inaddition, theanalysisshowsthatthefirstandsecond-yearstudentsmention farfewersolutionsthantheirthird-yearcohorts,andthefrequen- ciesofsolutionsaremuchmorebalancedamongthethird-yearstu- dents.Itcouldbesaidthatthird-yearstudentslookattheproblem morecomprehensively(acombinationofhumanresource,financial, marketingandmanagementsolutions)andhaveabetteroverview ofthesituationthanthefirstandsecondyears,whichcertainly showsgreatprogressinthestudents’competenciesandmultidis- ciplinaryknowledge,aswellintheabilitytogiveamorecompre- volume16|2023|number1 [28] DarioBerginc,ValentinaJoštLešer,andKatjaKraškovic hensiveoverviewofthesituation.Weestimatethattheirprogress comparedtothesecondyearislargelytheresultoftwomandatory coursesthatarestrategicallyandinterdisciplinaryoriented(Busi- nessPlanandPlanningCompanyGrowth),aswellastheinternship inthecompanythattheycarryoutinthethirdyearofstudy.Our resultscanthusconfirmthestudy’sresultsthathaveshownapos- itiveandsignificanteffectofchallenge-basedlearningprogrammes onstudents’entrepreneurialmindsetsandskills,especiallyinfi- nancialliteracy,creativityandplanning(Colombellietal.2022).In addition,creatingabusinessplanis,insomestudies,themostpop- ulartypeofteachingmethodinentrepreneurshipcoursesoffered bycollegesanduniversities(Salomon2008).Wecanalsoconfirm thefindingsofstudiesthatengagementwithbusinesssimulations andentrepreneurialscenarios(Avramenko2012;Solomon2008)as wellaspresentingandpitchingentrepreneurialideas(Bliemel2013; Rutkien˙eandTandzegolskiene2015),haveapositiveimpactonthe entrepreneurialmindsetofstudents.Ourfindingsalsoconfirmthe studiesthatdemonstratedthegreatimportanceofactiveteach- ingmethods,suchasbusinesssimulators,role-playing,andspecial projectswherestudentscanconnecttheirknowledgetopractice (Pech,Řehoř,andSlabová2021),aswellastheimportanceofthe activeapproachtoeducationfordevelopingcriticalthinkingand motivation(Gatti,Ulrich,andSeele2019).Furthermore,theright combinationofthesemethodscansupportstudentsinrunning theirbusinessesandeliminatethefearoffailure(Pech,Řehoř,and Slabová2021). Wealsoevaluatethesignificantimpactofsomechallenge-based learningactivitiesthattakeplaceeverystudyyear.Theanalysisof thecurriculashowedthatin12corecourses(outof18),besidesother regularsubjectactivities(homework,exercises,casestudies,etc.), studentsalsohadtocreateandpresentaproject,eitherindividually orinateam.Thelatteralsoappliestoallelectivecourses,theyears ofwhichwereanalysed. Here,weemphasizesolvingvariouscasestudiesinallcoursesof theEntrepreneurshipprogramme.Studentsmostlysolvethematic casestudiesbetweenlecturesandinateam,whichalsodevelops ijems TheRoleofChallengeBasedLearning [29] teamcompetencies.Eachgrouppresentstheresultsofthesolu- tion,followedbyagroupdiscussion.Existingresearch(Salomon 2008;Changetal.2014;Rutkien ˙eandTandzegolskiene2015)also supportedcasestudiesasapopularandeffectivetypeofteaching methodinuniversityentrepreneurshipprogrammes. Weseethehighaddedvalueofchallenge-basedlearningatthe geaCollege–FacultyofEntrepreneurshipmainlyinthemixofmul- tidisciplinaryapproaches,cooperationwithvariousstakeholdersof thefaculty(especiallycompaniesandsuccessfulentrepreneurs),and aboveall,inanauthentic,real-world,whichisalsostronglyhigh- lightedinexistingresearchinchallenge-basedlearning(Gallagher andSavage2020). Visitsbyguestsinthelecturehall(managersandentrepreneurs) arealsoconsideredimportantinterventionsthathavebeencarried outthroughouttheyears.Guestscanopenupnewhorizonsforstu- dents,inspirethemintheircareerpathandproviderolemodels fromwhomstudentscanlearn.Existingstudies,whichemphasize theimportanceofincludingguestspeakersandlecturesbybusiness ownersinthestudyprocess(Salomon2008;Saadatetal.2021),also confirmedthis.Excursionstocompaniesalsorepresentasimilar addedvalue.Studentsneeddirectcontactwithcompanies,toview theworkprocess,andtalkwiththefounder. Activitiesthatoccurcontinuouslyprovideessentialadditional impactonstudents’progress.Studentscan,therefore,takepartin themindifferentyearsofstudy.Letushighlightherethepossibility ofparticipatinginthegeaTopTalentsprogramme(tailoredpro- grammeforgiftedstudents),inthefaculty’sbusinessincubatorand CareerCentreaswellasInternationalOfficeactivities.Studentswho aremoreactiveand,toagreaterextent,involvedintheaforemen- tionedactivitiesprogressfasterindevelopingtheirskills,compe- tenciesandentrepreneurialmindset. Weshouldespeciallyhighlighttheimportanceofstudentsjoin- ingthefaculty’sbusinessincubator,wheretheycandevelopandre- alisetheirbusinessideawiththehelpofmentorsandconsultants. Existingstudiesconfirmthat,thegreatestknowledgeandskillac- quisitionisachievedthroughconsultationsandpersonalexperi- volume16|2023|number1 [30] DarioBerginc,ValentinaJoštLešer,andKatjaKraškovic ences(90ofgainedknowledge)(Rutkien˙eandTandzegolskiene 2015). Finally,theprofessorsalsohaveanimportantinfluenceonthe progressoftheentrepreneurialmindsetofstudents.Thevastma- jorityofprofessorsatgeaCollege–FacultyofEntrepreneurship havepracticalexperience.Thismeansthattheycansharetheirown experiencesfrompracticewithstudentsandcanalsopreparethe curriculumfortheircoursesinaverypracticalway.Experiencefrom practicealsomeansanactivenetworkofacquaintances,whichhelps themtointegrateguestsfrompracticeintothestudyprocessandor- ganiseexcursionstocompaniesandsimilarchallenge-basedlearn- ingactivities. conclusion Theresearchdemonstratedthatchallenge-basedlearningactivi- tieshaveasignificantaddedvalueinteachingentrepreneurship andhaveapositiveeffectontheprogressoftheentrepreneurial mindsetofstudents,whichconfirmsexistingresearchinthisfield (Colombellietal.2022).Ourresultsalsoconfirmedseveralother studiesthatchallenge-basedlearningactivitiespositivelyimpact theentrepreneurialmindsetandopenupanewareaofresearch ontheconnectionbetweenthestudycurriculum,challenge-based learninginterventions,andtheentrepreneurialmindsetofstu- dents. Throughvariouschallenge-basedlearningactivities,students makegreatprogressintheirentrepreneurialmindset.Howmuch addedvaluetheywillactuallyimplementintheir(entrepreneurial) careerlargelydependsontheirengagement.Thisisalsotheanswer toourresearchquestion,whichweformulatedatthebeginning:dif- ferentinterventionsinchallenge-basedlearningcaninfluencethe entrepreneurialmindsetofstudentstoagreatextentiftheytake advantageofalltheopportunitiesthatthefacultyoffers.Webe- lievethatchallenge-basedlearninginterventions,besidesthepro- grammeandprofessors,areinthemselvesagreatmotivatoranden- gagerforstudentstocontributetheirmaximumandgetthemost outofthiscooperation. ijems TheRoleofChallengeBasedLearning [31] Itisveryusefulforentrepreneurshipuniversitiestoencourage anddevelopnew,innovativeapproachestoentrepreneurshiplearn- ingthathaveaconnectiontopractice,i.e.,companies.Suchactivi- tiesimprovethepositioningandcompetitivenessofuniversitiesin theeconomicspaceandhaveapositiveeffectontheeconomyit- selfandeconomicentities.Companiesalsorequirecooperationwith pedagogicalandresearchinstitutions,sincetheyneednewknowl- edgeandgoodworkers,whileuniversitiescanbethegeneratorsof goodworkers.Challenge-basedlearningcanthusrepresentasuit- ableapproachofcooperationbetweenfacultiesandtheeconomy, inwhicheveryonegains:faculties,theeconomyandstudents.Asa result,basedonthefastercirculationofknow-how,thisisalsore- flectedinthequalityofcompetitivenessofcountriesandregions usingthisapproach,whichalsohaspositivemacroeconomicconse- quences. Thekeylimitationoftheresearchisthatitisacasestudyanal- ysis,sowecannotgeneralisetheresultsforthewiderpopulation ofentrepreneurialuniversities.Fromthispointofview,werecom- mendcreatingmorecasestudiesontheinfluenceofchallenge-based learningontheentrepreneurialmindsetofstudents.Quantitative researchinthisareawouldalsobewelcome,coveringalargersample ofentrepreneurshipfaculties,testingthehypothesesputforward onthem,andlookingfordifferencesbetweenfaculties. Withmoreresearchintotheeffectivenessandefficiencyofchal- lenge-basedlearningmethods,facultiescouldimprovetheircur- ricula,andasaresult,studentswouldgainmoreentrepreneurial competencesand,inthisway,furtherenhancetheirentrepreneurial mindsets. references Avramenko,A.2012.‘EnhancingStudents’EmployabilitythroughBusiness Simulation.’EducationandTraining54(5):355–67. Bell,R.,andH.Bell.2020.‘ApplyingEducationalTheorytoDevelopa FrameworktoSupporttheDeliveryofExperientialEntrepreneurship Education.’JournalofSmallBusinessandEnterpriseDevelopment27(6): 987–1004. Bliemel,M.J.2013.‘GettingEntrepreneurshipEducationoutoftheClass- volume16|2023|number1 [32] DarioBerginc,ValentinaJoštLešer,andKatjaKraškovic roomandintoStudents’Heads.’EntrepreneurshipResearchJournal4(2): 237–60. Chang,J.,A.Benamraoui,andA.Rieple.2014.‘Learning-by-Doingasan ApproachtoTeachingSocialEntrepreneurship.’ Innovations in Educa- tionandTeachingInternational51(5):459–71. Colombelli,A.,S.Loccisano,A.Panelli,O.Pennisi,Orazio,andF.Serraino. 2022.‘EntrepreneurshipEducation:TheEffectsofChallenge-Based LearningontheEntrepreneurialMindsetofUniversityStudents.’Ad- ministrativeSciences12(1):10. Corbett,A.C.2007.‘LearningAsymmetriesandtheDiscoveryofEn- trepreneurialOpportunities.’ Journal of Business Venturing22(1):97– 118. Creswell,J.W.,W.E.Hanson,andA.Morales.2007.‘QualitativeResearch Designs:SelectionandImplementation.’ TheCounselingPsychologist35 (2):236–64. Cui,J.,J.Sun,andR.Bell.2021.‘TheImpactofEntrepreneurshipEduca- tionontheEntrepreneurialMindsetofCollegeStudentsinChina:The MediatingRoleofInspirationandtheRoleofEducationalAttributes.’ TheInternationalJournalofManagementEducation19(1):1–13. Gallagher,S.,andT.Savage.2020.‘Challenge-BasedLearninginHigherEd- ucation:AnExploratoryLiteratureReview.’ Teaching in Higher Educa- tion.https://doi.org/10.1080/13562517.2020.1863354. Gatti,L.,M.Ulrich,andP.Seele.2019.‘EducationforSustainableDevel- opmentthroughBusinessSimulationGames:AnExploratoryStudyof SustainabilityGamificationandItsEffectsonStudents’LearningOut- comes.’JournalofCleanerProduction207:667–78. Gibb,A.2007,‘CreatingtheEntrepreneurialUniversity:DoWeNeed aWhollyDifferentModelofEntrepreneurship.’In Handbook of Re- searchinEntrepreneurshipEducation,editedbyA.Fayolle,67–103.Chel- tenham:EdwardElgar. Hisrich,R.,M.Peters,andD.Shepherd.2017.Entrepreneurship.NewYork: McGraw-Hill. Kozlinska,I.2012.‘FundamentalViewoftheOutcomesofEntrepreneur- shipEducation.’FacultyofEconomicsandBusinessAdministration WorkingPaper90,UniversityofTartu. Krippendorff,K.2021. ContentAnalysis:AnIntroductiontoItsMethodology. ThousandOaks,ca:Sage. Kuratko,D.,G.Fisher,andD.Audretsch.2021.‘UnravelingtheEntrepre- neurialMindset.’SmallBusinessEconomics57(4):1681–91. Lackéus,M.2020.‘ComparingtheImpactofThreeDifferentExperiential ApproachestoEntrepreneurshipinEducation.’InternationalJournalof EntrepreneurialBehaviorandResearch26(5):937–71. López-Núñez,M.I.,S.Rubio-Valdehita,andE.M.Díaz-Ramiro.2022.‘The ijems TheRoleofChallengeBasedLearning [33] RoleofIndividualVariablesasAntecedentsofEntrepreneurshipPro- cesses:EmotionalIntelligenceandSelf-Efficacy.’ Organizational Psy- chology13(1):1–12. McGrath,R.G.,andI.C.MacMillan.2000.The Entrepreneurial Mindset: StrategiesforContinuouslyCreatingOpportunityinanAgeofUncertainty. Boston,ma:HarvardBusinessPress. Naumann,C.2017.‘EntrepreneurialMindset:ASyntheticLiteratureRe- view.’EntrepreneurialBusinessandEconomicsReview5(3):149–72. Nichols,M.,K.Cator,andM.Torres.2016.Challenge Based Learner User Guide.RedwoodCity,ca:DigitalPromise. Nowiński,W.,M.Y.Haddoud,D.Lančarič,D.Egerová,andC.Czeglédi. 2019.‘TheImpactofEntrepreneurshipEducation,Entrepreneurial Self-EfficacyandGenderonEntrepreneurialIntentionsofUniversity StudentsintheVisegradCountries.’StudiesinHigherEducation44(2): 361–79. Muñoz,C.,S.Mosey,andM.Binks.2011.‘DevelopingOpportunity-Iden- tificationCapabilitiesintheClassroom:VisualEvidenceforChanging MentalFrames.’ Academy of Management Learning & Education10(2): 277–295. oecd.2021.‘SupportingEntrepreneurshipandInnovationinHigherEd- ucationinSlovenia.’oecd,Paris.https://www.oecd.org/cfe/smes /HEInnovate-Slovenia.pdf. Olutuase,S.O.,P.Brijlal,B.Yan,andE.Ologundudu.2018.‘Entrepreneurial OrientationandIntention:ImpactofEntrepreneurialEcosystemFac- tors.’JournalofEntrepreneurshipEducation21(1):1–14. O’Connor,A.2013.‘AConceptualFrameworkforEntrepreneurshipEduca- tionPolicy:MeetingGovernmentandEconomicPurposes.’ Journal of BusinessVenturing28(4):546–63. O’Brien,E.,T.M.Cooney,andP.Blenker.2019.‘ExpandingUniversityEn- trepreneurialEcosystemstoUnder-RepresentedCommunities.’ Jour- nalofEntrepreneurshipandPublicPolicy8(3):384–407. Pech,M.,P.Řehoř,andM.Slabová.2021.‘StudentsPreferencesinTeach- ingMethodsofEntrepreneurshipEducation.’ JournalonEfficiencyand ResponsibilityinEducationandScience14(2):66–78. Pirhadi,H.,S.Soleimanof,andA.Feyzbakhsh.2021.‘UnpackingEntrepre- neurialAlertness:HowCharacterMattersforEntrepreneurialThink- ing.’JournalofSmallBusinessManagement61(1):155–86. Rutkien˙e,A.,andI.Tandzegolskiene.2015.‘Students’AttitudeTowards LearningMethodsforSelf-SufficiencyDevelopmentinHigherEdu- cation.’In Society, Integration, Education,348–57.Rezekne:Rezekne AcademyofTechnologies. Saadat,S.,A.Aliakbari,A.MajdAlizadeh,andR.Bell.2022.‘TheEffect ofEntrepreneurshipEducationonGraduateStudents’Entrepreneurial volume16|2023|number1 [34] DarioBerginc,ValentinaJoštLešer,andKatjaKraškovic AlertnessandtheMediatingRoleofEntrepreneurialMindset.’ Educa- tionandTraining64(7):892–909. Sirelkhatim,F.,andY.Gangi,2015.‘EntrepreneurshipEducation:ASystem- aticLiteratureReviewofCurriculaContentsandTeachingMethods.’ CogentBusinessandManagement2(1):1–11. Solesvik,M.Z.,P.Westhead,H.Matlay,andV.N.Parsyak.2013.‘Entrepre- neurialAssetsandMindsets:BenefitfromUniversityEntrepreneur- shipEducationInvestment.’EducationandTraining55(8–9):748–62. Solomon,G.2008.‘EntrepreneurshipEducationintheUnitedStates.’In EntrepreneurshipandHigherEducation,editedbyJ.Potter,95–118.Paris: oecdPublishing. ijems