Razprave Tiie Changing Landscape of the U.S. Federal Government: Electronic Delivery of Information and Services Patricia Diamond Fletcher Abstract This paper will examine the current condition of electronic government (e-gov) in the U.S. Federal government. A brief examination of the legislative framework for e-gov will be presented. The current major initiatives at the Federal level of government will be examined with an emphasis on the nascent creation of best practices in electronic government. Izvleček V članku obravnavamo sedanje stan/e v elektronski upravi ameriške federalne vlade. Predstavljamo kratek pregled zakonodaje, ki se nanaša na e-upravo. Opisujemo tudi pomembnejše spodbude na federalni ravni s poudarkom na porajajoče se uveljavljanje učinkovitejših postopkov v elektronski upravi. The Legislative Framework for Electronic Government in the United States The United States Federal government is the largest information collector, creator, disseminator, and repository in the world. This underscores the classic comment made by Harlan Cleveland {1986) that in essence "government is information." The importance of information and information management to the Federal government has been recognized by many scholars, authenticated in their research (Dawes, et al, 1999; Fletcher, et al, 1993: Fletcher and Westerback, 2000; Hernon, et al,1997; Sprehe, 1987). The value of information to government has recently skyrocketed, however, as government becomes "electronic" and government information and services, ubiquitous. A complete review of all relevant Federal policy is beyond the bounds of this paper. A number of such comprehensive papers already exist, and for the purposes of this paper, only the critical recent legislation will be noted. As indicated above, the U.S. Federal government has a lengthy and rich history of legislative attention to government information and personal information freedoms and this focus on information policies continues into the present. The onset of computers and information technology, and the Internet as a mass communication media, has only increased tlie focus on and the importance of an informed and concentrated policy approach to information. Information creation, maintenance, access, disposal, security, and privacy frame and guide the information policy arena today. Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 The Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (PRA) (Public Law 104-13)is a lengthy and wide-ranging law, lirst enacted in 1980. It was revised in IL)86 with some changes, and then had a major revision in 1995, I lie PRA was enacted to reduce the paperwork burden on private citizens and businesses that interact with tin-government. It emphasizes the effective and efficient use of IT to achieve paperwork reduction. The second goal of the PRA is to create a government information management structure that recognizes the value ot information to government and manages it in a strategic manner, consistent with Federal agerïcy missions and goals. In its latest version, attention is given to the management and use of all forms of records and information, paper and electronic, to computer security, information privacy and information access, systems standards, and agency wide and government wide strategic information planning. The Office of Management and Budget guidance to Federal agencies for compliance with the PRA is given in OM11 Circular A-i 30. Government Paperwork Elimination Act of 1998 The Government Paperwork Elimination Act of 1998 (P,L. 105-277, Title XVII) was authorized with a minimum of attention and t'uss, yet it lias the potential to be one of the most influential pieces of legislation pertaining to the management and use of information 2001 -ŠtevilkaA -letnikIX u/nmibtiiA NFORMAT IKA Patricia Diamond Fletcher: The Changing Landscape oi the U.S. Federal Government: Electronic Delivciy of Information .irid Services technology—and to the creation of an electronic government, Once il is fully implemented, G Pi-A promises to create government processes that are more externally focused and citizén and business-centric. It sets up the conditions lor a process and performance oriented Federal government. With the passing of GFF,A, there is a formal recognition that government is and will continue to develop its electronic information presence. The Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996. Division D of the Department of Defense authorization is titled the information Management and Technology Reform Act of 1996, later renamed Clinger-Cohen after the bill's congressional supporters. Clinger-Cohen makes specific the development of information technology acquisition and investment practices and creates a top-level focus on Federal agency information management through the requirement lora Chief InforMatipn Officer, which is a direct report to the agency head This act was supplemented by Executive Order 13(111, Federal Information Technology Management. P.O. 1.30! I served to bolster the CIO structure with the creation of a Federal CIO Council, charged with creating cross-agency information platforms, maximizing the return and the reach of information technology across the Federal government. As will be mentioned later in this paper, the CIO Council has taken on a key role in creating and enabling electronic government processes. Privacy Act of 1974 The Privacy Act of 1974 (KH Stat. 1896; 5 U,S.C.552a) was enacted by Congress to legislatively, protect personally identifiable information created and maintained by Federal agencies. It created the right of an individual U.S. citizen, or lawfully alien, to access personal information about him or herself that is in most Federal government records. There are exclusions to this Act for information that is deemed sensitive or critical to U.S. national security. The Privacy Act also affirms the principles for fair information practices, principles generally accepted in the United States and Europe for access to, disclosure of, and accuracy of personally identifiable information. Freedom of Information Act of 1966 The Freedom of Information Act (80 Stat. 250; 5 U.S.C. 552) was enacted by Congress in 1966 to create a more effective process for the public to obtain access to Federal government records. The latest amendment to this act occurred in 1996 with the major modifications being the Electronic Freedom of Information Act that affirmed the applicability of the Act to records in all formats and media, including electronic. Federal agencies are required und er the Act to disclose records requested in writing by any person. Federal agencies may withhold information if it falls within one of the nine exemptions and three exclusions contained in the statute. This Act applies only to federal agencies and does not create a right of access to records held by Congress, the courts, or by state or local government agencies. The Computer Security Act of 1987. The Computer Security Act (lfll Stat. 1724) requires that Federal agencies develop comprehensive set uri-ty plans for all systems that contain sensitive information. It further states that the National Institute of Standards and Technology in the Department of Commerce, set the security standards to be applied to all systems containing such sensitive information, excepting systems that contain national security information, intelligence, crypto logic or military information which are to be kepi secret for purposed of national defense and national policy, These are the major legislative tools, which relate to electronic government at U.S. Federal agencies. At a minimum, they set up the requirements for information access, use, maintenance, security and privacy. Other policy tools, such as the Computer Matching and Privacy Protection Act of 19mb>uA NFORM A TIKA 2001 ■ ilevilka 'i - Letnik IX Patricia Diamond Fletcher: The Changing Landscape of the U.S. Federal Government: Lite Ira rue Delivery ol Information and Services The Internal Revenue Service's eFile The desire to connect the I ax paying public to an easy, fast, and paperless tax return process has long been a goal Of Congress and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), fhe eFile, a cooperative venture among the IRS, [lie public, certified public accountants, taxpayer software vendors, and other tax professionals, is one of the more public and wide-ranging instantiations of Hie desire to reduce the tax process burden to all parties. The vision for eFile is" lo revolutionize how taxpayers transact and communicate with the IRS." The program does this in a variety of ways, using the Internet, computer software and telephone technologies as interaction and filing media. Factors that were critical to the development and the success of this project include the: « IRS Commissioner Charles Rossotti, ■ Strong leadership of the Electronic Tax Administration Director, ■ Strategic planning focus of the agency, ■ Citizen access priority, . IRS Restructuring and Reform Act (RRA) of 1998 ■ Promotion ot' electronic tiling (sec. 2001c) • Forms availability via Internet (sec. 2003d), ■ Government Paperwork Elimination Act, ■ Ability to stimulate "out-of-the-box" thinking, ■ Tax expertise of partners, ■ Direct marketing campaign of eFilfe to the general public, ■ Electronic 1 ax Administration Advisory Commission, and ■ Internet technology. According to a June, 2000 ETAAC report to Congress: The Website itself, www.irs.gov, lias achieved a remarkable visibility in a short period of time. Date from the Internal Revenue Services indicates that there were more than 1.5 billion hits to the website from January through April 16,2001, which represents a 57 percent increase in usage from the same time period in 2000. The visitors to the website averaged eleven minutes per visit, with most of them going to the page for electronic tax tiling. The number of documents and forms that were downloaded from the web site was 103 million for January and February 2001; a two-fold in crease front the same time period in 2000. I he IKS also experienced a large growth in electronic tiling in 2000, with a 20.5 percent increase in e-filed returns over the preceding year. Other aspects of the electronic tiling program also demonstrated improved service and information delivery improvement in 2000. A goal ot' l he Tax Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998 was for the IRS to achieve 100 percent electronic 2001 - Stevilka (accessed on the World Wide Web. September 22. 2000). Reiyea, Harold C. (May 7, 2001). Electronic Government: A Concpetual Overview. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Scrvicc. Remarks by the President in the First Internet Webcast; June 24, 2000. (accessed on the World Wide Web October 10. 2000). Sprehe, J. T. (1987). Developing Federal Information Resources Management Policy: Issues and Impact for Information Managers," Information Management Review, Vol. 2, pp. 33-41. Webcast of November 15. 2000 CIO Council Meeting. (accessed on the World Wide Web, November 20, 2000). * Pat net,i Diamond Fletcher is associate professor in the Department of Information Systems. UMBC, University of Maryland, Baltimore County. She has published extensively tn the area of government information policy and electronic government. She is currently studying new models of multi-partner collaboration for electronic government projects, a multi national project funded by the National Science Foundation under the direction of the Center for Technology in Government. Fletcherh on sabbatical leave from UMBC to conduct research at the US General Accounting Office for the 2001 academic year. She is working with the IT Policy Team and involved in studies initiated by Congress on information privacy and security act compliance and an evaluation of the effectiveness of the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 in Federal agencies Fletcher received her MLS and PhD from the School of Information Studies at Syracuse University. ♦ 2001 ■ álevllka 4 ■ letnik IX iifxmibi id N FOR M ATI KA