Middennal elastolysis Case report MIDDERMAL ELASTOLYSIS K. Peris, G.P. Mazzochetti, S. Dietrich and S. Chimenti ABSTRACT Middermal elastolysis (MDE) is an acquired idiopathic non-inflammatory dermatosis, clinically characterized by areas of fine wrinkling of the skin, and histopathologically exhibiting a rniddermal los s of elastic fibers. We report two cases of idiopathic rniddermal elastolysis recently observed in our department. After considering the main differential diagnoses, we discuss the etiopathogenetic hypothesis underlying the most appropriate therapies. KEYWORDS middermal elastolysis, idiopathic INTRODUCTION Middermal elastolysis (MDE) is characterized by well circumscribed areas of fine wrinkling of the skin which histopathologically exhibit rniddermal loss of elastic fibers. The first reported case was preceded by a recurrent urticarial eruption, which led Shelley and Wood (1977) to postulate that dermal inflammation may have resulted in specific zonal destruction of elastic tissue (1). The histological exarnination showed a striking absence of elastic tissue in a band-like region, strictly lirnited to the rniddle derrnis of the involved area. Subsequently, Brenner et al. described a similar idiopathic loss of middermal elastic tissue leading to wrinkling of the skin and perifollicular protrusion in a 33- year-old, otherwise healthy white woman. However, no clinical or histologic evidence of inflammation was found, leading them to propose the term non-inflammatory dermal elastolysis for this entity (2). More recently, Brodet al. have pointed out an inflamma- tory pathogenesis of MDE (3), and Kirn and Su have acta dermatovene rologica A .P.A. Vol 5, 96, No 1 speculated that sun exposure may be one of the main causative factors (4). It has been proposed that the presence or absence of inflammation may mainly depend on the stage of the skin lesions at the tirne of presentation. The authors describe two cases of MDE : the first case a 39-year-old woman who presented with wrinkling of the abdorninal skin; the other one a 29-year-old woman with numerous yellowish papules on the chest, back and arms. CASEREPORT Case l. A 39-year-old woman with widespread areas of fine skin wrinkling occurring mainly on the arms and abdomen was exarnined . There was no previous history of skin diseases . Results of laboratory exarninations, che~t x- ray and ECG were normal. Thyroid function tests revealed no abnormalities. Anti- nuclear antibodies were within the normal range. Biopsy 27 Middermal elastolysis specimens of two lesions stained with hematoxylin and eosin showed no epidermal abnormalities, but disclosed the complete absence of elastic tissue in foci lirnited to the rniddermal region. The reticular derrnis appeared normal and no inflarnmatory cell infiltrate was present. Collagen fibers showed no alteration. Histochernical stain specific for elastic fibers confirmed that the absence of elastic fibers was lirnited to the rnid-derrnis (Fig. 1). Fig. 1. Histological stain far elastica shows the absence of elastic fibers to the middle dermis (1 Ox) Case 2. In a 29 year-old woman, numerous, asymptomatic, discrete, yellowish papules, 0.5-0.8 cm in diarneter appeared Fig. 2. Clinical aspects of middermal elastolysis 28 progressively on the upper chest, back, and arms (Fig. 2) . There was no previous history of skin disease. Results of laboratory exarninations, chest x-ray and ECG were un- remarkable. Thyroid function tests disclosed no abnor- malities. Antinuclear antibodies were within the normal range. A skin biopsy specimen was obtained from the left arrn. Hematoxylin eosin staining demonstrated a normal epiderrnis and a band-like rniddermal region with complete loss of elastic fibers. The loss of elastic tissue did not involve perifollicular areas, and the hair follicles were surrounded by well-preserved elastic fibers. A sparse superficial and deep infiltrate of lymphohistiocytic cells was also observed. Collagen fibers displayed no alteration. Histochernical stain with Verhoeff-van Gieson confirmed that the absence of elastic fibers was lirnited to the rnid-derrnis. Patient number 1 was treated according to the literature, using daily application of topical retinoid acid cream of increasing concentration. Patient number 2 was treated with topical retinoic acid cream once daily in conjunction with 70% glycolic acid once weekly. Although a discrete improvement of clinical rnanifestations was observedin both cases after 6 months of therapy, patient number 2 improved visibly sooner, beginning with the third month of treatment. This earlier improvement presumably resulted from the epidermolytic action of glycolic acid, and suggests enhancing the efficacy of other specific topical therapies (12). DISCUSSION MDE is a rare acquired idiopathic dermatosis that predorninantly affects rniddle-aged women. Lesions frequently involve the arrns, trunk and shoulders, while the face is generally spared. Usually, there is no farnily history or systernic involvement. There are no signs of atrophy or herniation. According to Trueb, the lesions can be classified as localized or generalized, congenital or acquired (5,6). Two morphologic patterns ofMDE have been described: type 1 lesions, as in our case 1, appear as tiny wrinkles arranged parallel to the skin cleavage lines. Histology reveals that the elastic tissue is preserved in the superficial derrnis but absent in the rniddle derrnis. Generally no inflarnmatory infiltrate is present. Type 2 lesions, as in our case 2, appear as small soft papules that consist of perifollicular protrusions. The diffuse los s of elastic tissue in the rniddle derrnis is interrupted by hair follicles surrounded by well-preserved elastic fibers (6). An inflarnmatory infiltrate may also be observed. Histo- logic sirnilarities between anetodermia and type 2 MDE suggest the possibility of a related pathogenesis, so that some authors consider type 2 MDE to be a clinical form of anetoderrnia (3). MDE should be differentiated from other disorders of acquired elastolysis. In fact, solar elastosis differs acta dermatovenerologica A.PA. Vol 5, 96, No 1 Middermal elastolysis from MDE by its onset in older patients and involvement of sun-exposed areas, by hyperplasia, abnormalities of elastic fibers, and by basophilic degeneration of the collagen in the papillary dermis (4). Anetodermia is characterized by the absence of widespread wrinkling, and by the presence of herniation as well as elastolytic features involving the entire dermis (7). Cutis laxa differs from MDE by the presence of lax pendulous skin, and the frequent involvement of internal organs (8). Postinflammatory elastolysis and cutis laxa differ fromMDE by their occurrence in African women, by the occurrence of preceding urticaria and/or papuloplaques, and by the presence of atrophy and severe disfigurement (9). The etiology of MDE is poorly understood. Immune reactions, defects in synthesis of elastic tissue, and the release of elastase by inflammatory cells have all been postulated as possible mechanisms (4). Some authors have also hypothesized that sun exposure could be a contributing factor in the genesis of this disorder. However, the extensive involvement of sun-protected areas and the absence of histological evidence of solar elastosis are not consistent with the latter view that the damage to elastin in MDE results from sun-exposure (3,4). Recently, Fimiani et al. have shown that ultra-violet A (UV-A) stimulation of fibroblasts from two patients with MDE does not change the quantity of elastolytic enzymes, butincreases the level ofthese enzymes in fibroblasts from healthy subjects (10). Lacking a well- understood pathophysiologic genesis for MD E, therapeutic measures are of an empiric nature. At this moment, the most promising treatment consists of topical retinoic acid cream in conjunction with the use of sunscreens (11). REFERENCES l. Shelley WB, Wood MG. Wrinkles due to idiopathic loss of middermal elastic tissue. Br J Dermatol 1977; 97: 441- 445 2. Brenner W, Gschnait F, Konrad K, Holubar K, Tappeiner J. Non-inflammatory dermal elastolysis. Br J Dermatol 1978; 99: 335-338 3. Brod BA, Rabkin M, RhodesAR, Jegasoty BV. Middermal elastolysis with inflarnmation. J Am Acad Dermatol 1992; 26: 882-884 4. Kirn JM, Su WPD. Middermal elastolysis with wrinkling: report of two cases and review of the literature. J Am Acad Dermatol 1992; 26: 169-173 5. Trueb RM, Burg G. ldiopathic middermal elastolysis. Dermatol 1993; 187:62-66 6. Maghraoui S, Grossin M, Crickx B, Blanchet P, Belaich S. Middermal elastolysis: report of case with a predominant perifollicular pattern. J Am Acad Dermatol 1992; 26: 490- 492 7. Cerroni L, Orlando GC, Peris K, Lunghi F, Chimenti S. Anetodermia di Schweninger-Buzzi Giorn lot Derm Ped 1990; 1: 23-29 8. Harris RB, Heaphy MR, Perry HO. Generalized elastolysis (cutis laxa). AmJ Med 1978; 65: 815-822 9. Lewis PG, HoodAF, Barnett NK et al. Postinflammatory elastolysis and cutis laxa. J Arn Acad Derrnatol 1990; 22: 40-48 10. Fimiani M, Mazzatenta C, Rubegna P, Lungarella G. Midderrnal elastolysis: Aspetti ultrastrutturali e ruolo delle proteasi elastolitiche. In Riassunti 69' Congresso SIDEV Sorrento, 1994 11. Rae V, Falanga V. Wrinkling due to middermal elastolysis. Arch Derrnatol 1989; 125: 950-951 12. Van Scott EJ, Yu RJ. Alpha hydroxyacids: therapeutic potential. Canadian J Dermatol 1989; 1: 108-112 AUTHORS' ADDRESSES Ketty Peris MD, Departrnent of Dermatology, University of L' Aquila, Via Vetoio-Coppito 2, 67100 L' Aquila, ltaly . Claudia Cotellessa MD, same address Giampero Mazzocchetti MD, same address Sergio Chimenti MD, Professor and Chairrnan of the Departrnent of Dermatology, University of L' Aquila, same address acta dermatovenerologica A.P.A. Vol 5, 96, No 1 29