ACTA IlISTBIAE • 10 - 2002 • 2 received: 2002-U-03 ÍJDC 284.1/.2(44)T6l5":355.0l THE ASSAULT ON STE.-FERME (1615): DESECRATION AND DIVINE WRATH IN A LATE EPISODE OF THE WARS OF RELIGION Alisa A. PLANT Tulane University, University College, New Orleans, LA 70118. USA e-mail: aplant® iulane.edu ABSTRACT In late ¡615, a Huguenot army mounted a raid on the Benedictine monastery of Ste.-Ferine in Cayenne. Although vastly outnumbered, the monks were ultimately able to drive out the attackers, who then burned the town adjacent to the monastery. A published account of the assault appeared almost immediately. Contemporary interest was clearly high, for the vivid and detailed narrative was reprinted three times (once in 1615 and twice in 1616, including a Paris edition). The anonymous narrator reported that while pillaging the church, three Huguenots were struck dead as they tried to approach the Eucharist to desecrate it. The sudden instrusion of the active wrath of God into the narrative is both surprising and significant. The paper will investigate this curious episode in terms of the persistence of the fanatical religious violence that characterized the Wars of Religion, but which many historians have seen as having greatly diminished in the aftermath of the Edict of Nantes. Key words: violence, eucharist, Huguenots, catholics, wars of religion, France L'ASSALTO DEL SAINT FERME (1615): PROFAN AZI ONE E COLLERA DIVINA IN UNO DEGLIULTIMIEP1SOD1 DELLE GUERRE DI REL1G10NE S1NTESI Verso la fine del 1615 un 'artnata degli Ugonotti fece. irruzione net monastero benedettino di Ste.-Ferme, nellit zona di Guyenne. Nonostante i. monaci fossero in numero nettamente irtferiore, essi riuscirono comunque a respingere gli assaltaiori che dettero poi fuoco alia cittil adiacente al monastero. Un resoconto deU'assalto venne pubblicato quasi immediatamente dopo Vaccaduto, cosa che dimostra come l'interesse contemporáneo fosse notevole. dal momento che if. racconto dettagliato venne ristampato ben tre volte (una prima volta nel 1615 e due volte nel 1616. compresa un'edizione di Parigi). ¡I. narratore anonimo riportó che mentre gli Ugonotti 507 ACTA HISTOAE • 10 • 2002 • Z Alisa A. PLANT; THE ASSAULT ON STE.-FERME (1Ú15). DESECRATION AND DIVINE WRATH. .. 50Í-Í16 Saccheggiavano la chíesa, tre di loro vennero cohi da mane itnprowisa mentre ten-tavano di awicinarsi cdl'Eucaristía per profanarla. La repentina comparsa della collera divina nelía narratione é tanto insólita quanto significativa. L'articolo anal-izzerct perció questo curioso episodio secondo la persistenza de.Ua violenza fanatica religiosa che ha caratterizzato le Guerre di Religione, ma che molti storici hanno di-chiarato in forte diminuizione dopo l'Editto di Ñames. Parole chiave: violenza, eucaristía, Ugonotri, cattolici, guerre di religione, Francia In the years of Louis XIU's minority, there were widespread fears across France of a renewal of the civil wars that had caused such devastation in the second half of the sixteenth century. These fears were particularly acute in the south of France, where Protestantism had made the most headway, and where many Huguenots still lived. The Edict of Nantes, promulgated in 1598, had guaranteed religious toleration to members of the Reformed faith; the smallness of their overall numbers (roughly a million people, or no more than 6 percent of the French population) was offset by the political clout of their leaders, many of whom were prominent nobles (Benedict, 1991, 75-76). Still, most of the kingdom remained staunchly Catholic, as exemplified in the popular contemporary slogan, "une foi, une loi, un roi" - one faith, one law, one king. Thus it is not entirely surprising that the announcement of a pair of royal marriage alliances between France and ultra-Catholic Spain led to a spasm of religious violence in the southern part of the kingdom. Driven by the relative weakness of the French crown to seek a rapprochement with its former (and future) enemy, the queen regent, Marie de' Medici, brokered a double marriage in which young King Louis XIII was betrothed to the Spanish Habsburg infanta Anne of Austria, and Louis's younger sister, Elisabeth, was promised to the future Spanish king Philip IV. Many French Huguenots believed that these marriage alliances portended the impending suppression of their religion, and they quickly took defensive action. Faced with armed rebellion, Marie de' Medici was forced to call an Estates General (1614) to quell dissent in the realm.1 The planned marriages went ahead nonetheless, and as the date for the exchange of princesses approached, the threat of violence again arose in the south. The prince of Conde issued a call to revolt in August 1615, and Huguenots across the kingdom tensely debated whether once again take up arms against their king. After "many 1 The tensions surrounding the Spanish marriages were only one part of a larger power struggle between the crown and (he Huguenot princes. Sec Tapic, ¡984,68-78: Holl, 1995, 174-7. 508 ACTA H1STRIAE • 10 • 20112 • 2 Alia A. PLANT: THE ASSAULT ON STE.-I-ERME (IGL1.I: DESKCRATÏON AND DIVINE WRATH..., S07.JW meetings, public as well as secret," a Huguenot army under the leadership of the duke of Rohan assembled in the town of Sainte-Foy, which had been a Protestant stronghold throughout the Wars of Religion (Discours veritable, 5). Meanwhile, Louis XIII - now technically reigning in his own right - traveled to Bordeaux in early October to meet his Spanish bride. The king and his party arrived in the city without mishap on October 7. and the marriages were solemnized by proxy on October 18 (Kicin-man, 1985, 22-24}.2 By ail accounts Louis eagerly awaited his nuptials, but intervening events served to remind him of the persistent dangers of both religious factionalism and the Spanish alliance. The Huguenot army was on the move toward Tonnems (southeast of Bordeaux), seizing garrisoned towns with Utile resistance (Clarke, 1966, 57). On October 12, only a few days after Louis's arrival in the south, die Huguenots mounted a raid against the Benedictine abbey of Ste.-Fermc, which was less than thirty miles from Bordeaux and only a few miles from Sainte-Foy. Knowledge of this episode survives because of an anonymous pamphlet that was published in Bordeaux soon after the attack, bearing the longwinded title: "True relation of the first exploit of arms in Guyenne in the abbey of Sainte Ferme, October 12, 1615, by some pretended reformers of state, containing their horoscope, and the marvel of God that appeared on the subject."3 The wealth of detail in this narrative suggests that its author was almost certainly an eyewitness, and quite possibly a participant, in. the events he described (Lantenay, 1879, 10). Written from a Catholic viewpoint, the text recounts a broad spectrum of violence, ranging from familial betrayal to murder, plunder, arson, and divine wrath. Yet the anonymous author was not content to understand the raid on Ste.-Ferme solely as an expression of sectarian struggle; he was also concerned with issues of political authority, as he made clear in his very first sentence: "There is a natural subordination of the state to religion, just as the body is subordinate to the soul, natural virtues to moral ones, and those to Christian virtues: thus the entire temporal regime is subject to the spiritual to such a degree that one cannot act against the soul except at the prejudice of the body. Likewise it is impossible to act against the true religion in any manner whatsoever without shocking the temporal state" (Discours veritable, 3). For this writer, the abortive "reformation" of the previous century, which had "bathed France in its own blood," provided ample demonstration of this organic metaphor (Discours veritable, 3). The Huguenots' violence was so worrisome precisely because it evoked memories of the aU-loo-recettt civil wars and the collapse of royal authority in the 1580s and early 1590s. The specter of confessional violence thus had newly politicized resonances that were all the stronger because the royal 2 The actual exchange of princesses took place on the French-Spanish frontier, in the middle of the Bi-dassoa ïtiver, ou November 9 3 The "Discours veritable" was likely pan of the larger pamphlet war thai accompanied the struggle for control of the regency governrnenl. Sec Sawyer. 1900 509 ACTA IlISTBIAE • 10 - 2002 • 2 AIÎMI A. PLAN'!; THE ASSAULT ON STE.-FBRMB (1615). DESECRATION AND DIVINE WRATH. 507-516 government was already weak: a return to war could mean a return to near-anarchy. The narrator's explication of the multiple levels of violence at Ste.-Ferme must be understood in terms of the connections between his political and religious concerns. The Huguenot assault on Ste,-Ferme was far from spontaneous. The monastery was chosen as a target for a number of reasons: it was richly furnished and well provisioned; it was peopled by monks and well-to-do villagers, who presumably would offer little resistance; and its buildings were so sturdy that, once taken, the abbey could serve both ns a meeting place and (if necessary) as a defensive stronghold for Huguenots. The primary motives behind the raid were thus greed and the. desire for a secure refuge, not an intent of physical violence against the monks themselves. The army's leaders tried to leave little to chance, even sending a spy — a relative of one of the monks in the abbey - to reconnoiter. His findings were so encouraging that within hours of his report, the Huguenot army - comprised of five thousand men, both infantry and cavalry - was at the gates of the monastery (Discours veritable, 6 -7). Upon seeing the army, the abbey's sentry raised the alarm. The monks, 'overcome with fright, hastily threw themselves into the church, pursued so quickly that they barely had time to shut themselves in" (Discours veritable, 7). Yet the church provided no safe haven. As the narrator observed, "The heretic, no less equipped with arms than with malice, attacks the Church everywhere, even unto the strongest site and the final refuge" (Discours veritable, 7). In this case, the assault was literal: the Huguenots blew in the church door with explosives. The little band of monks and others in the church, only fifteen strong, fled to the upper vaults. Interestingly, although the narrator suggests that the abbey was completely surprised by the Huguenot raid, a few of the abbey's defenders had the time (and presence of mind) to arm themselves with harquebuses. The church became a shooting gallery, as the desperate monks began firing at the intruders below. Here the narrator revealed the first intimation of divine displeasure at ihe Huguenots, for God (acting through the intervention of the abbey's guardian angel) "directed their blows so helpfully" that the monks shot nearly everyone they aimed at - almost always with fatal results (Discours veritable, 8). Despite this carnage. however, some of the Huguenots remained firm in their original resolve to loot the church. They began pillaging the altar, seizing valuable chalices and other ornaments. At that point, one unlucky Huguenot noticed a monstrance containing the Host - which, of course, Catholics regarded as the physical body of Christ. As the anonymous author reported, "He ran to ravish it With great difficulty he raised his hand to this effect, when from above was sent to him a benediction so dry, and so hard, that it instantly tore out his sacrilegious soul" (Discours veritable, 9). A second Huguenot, and then a third, also tried to seize the Eucharist, with no better luck. As the anonymous author triumphantly recorded. "Voilà, three corpses under the holy Sacrament" (Discours veritable, 9). Shocked by the untimely deaths of their corelig- 510 ACTA HISTRIAE ■ 10-20(12- 2 AliSib A II .ANT- Tilt" ASSAULT ON STB.-FERME Ofrli V. DESECRATION AND DIVINE WRATI-J.,.. 507-JI ljena pripoved o napadu. Tedanji interesi so bili očitno veliki, kajti živa in izčrpna pripoved je bila natisnjena trikrat (enkrat leta ¡615 in dvakrat leta 1616. tudi v pariški izdaji). Anonimni pripovedovalec je poročal, kako so bili ubiti trije hugenoti, ko so se približali evharistiji z namenom, da jo oskrunijo. Nenadni "vdor" aktivne jeze božje v pripoved je neskladen. Pričujoči članek preučuje nenavadno epizodo nezadržnega fanatičnega verskega nasilja, ki je bilo značilno za verske vojne, a je. po mnenju 514 ACTA ti)STRIAE • 10 ♦ 2002 • 2 Afo» A plant. the ASSAl'lt ON ste..ferme4i6ij): DESECRATION and divine WRATH. .. J07-5I* mnogih zgodovinarjev močno ¡¡plahnela, potem ko je bil izdan natski edikl. Pripoved o napadit na Saint-Ferme govori ne le o vztrajnosti, marveč tudi o globini sektaškega rivahtva - konflikt, katerega osnovni argument je bil pravzaprav vprašanje, čigav bog je močnejši. Hvyenntov po dolgih desetletjih nasilja še vedno ni minila želja po oskrunjanjit katoliških lokaliiei in obrednih predmetov, katolikov pa želja po povezovanju takšnih dejavnosti z aktivno jezo božjo. Ključne besede; nasilje, evkaristija, katoliki, verske vojne, Francija REFERENCES Anonymous (1615): Discours veritable du premier exploit d'armes faict eu Guienne, en l'Abbaye de Saincte Ferme, le 12 Octobre 1615. par quelques prétendus Reformateurs d'Estat, contenant leur Horoscope, & la merueille de Dieu qui a paru sur ce sujet. Paris, chez Louys Hebert, rue S. lacques, au soufflet verd. Benedict, Ph. (1991): The Huguenot Population of France, 1600-1685: The Demographic Fate and Customs of a Religious Minority. Philadelphia, Transactions of the American Philosophical Society, 81, Pari 5. Bercé, Y.-M, (1990): History of Peasant Revolts: The Social Origins of Rebellion in Early Modern France (trans. Amanda Whiimore). Ithaca, N.Y., Cornell University Press. Clarke, J. A. (1966): Huguenot Warrior: The Life and Times of Henri de Rohan. 1579-1638. The Hague. Martinus Nijhoff. Crouzet, D. (1990): Les guerriers de Dieu: La violence au temps des troubles de religion, vers 1525-vers 1610. 2 vols. Paris, Champ Vallon. Davis, N. Z. (1975): The Rites of Violence. In; Society and Culture in Early Modern France. Stanford, Stanford University Press. Diefendorf, B. (1991): Beneath the Cross: Catholics and Huguenots in Sixteenth-Century Paris. New York, Oxford University Press. El wood, C. (1999): The Body Broken: The Calvinist Doctrine of the Eucharist and the Symbolization of Power in Sixteenth-Century France. New York, Oxford University Press. Garcia, C. (1979): La oposicion y conjuncion de ios dos grandes lumïnares de la tierra, o, La Antipatia de Franceses y Espanoles (1617). Alberta, Canada, Alta Press. Ginzburg, C. (éd.) and Bologna Seminar (1991): Ritual Pillages: A Preface to Research in Progress. In: Muir, E., Ruggiero, G. (eds.): Microhistory and the Lost Peoples of Europe. Baltimore, Johns Hopkins Press. 515 ACTA H1STRIAE • 10 • 20112 • 2 AllwA. PLANT: THE ASSAULT ON STE.-FCKME (I61S): DESECRATION AND DIVINE WRATH.... 507-516 Hanlon, G. (1993): Confession and Community in Seventeenth-Century France: Catholic and Protestant Coexistence in Aquitaine. Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press. Holt, ML P. (1995): The French Wars of Religion, 1562-1629. Cambridge. Cambridge University Press. Jouanna, A. (1989): La devoir de révolte: La noblesse française et la gestation de l'État moderne, 1559-1661. Paris, Fayard. klcimnan, R. (1985): Anne of Austria, Queen of France. Columbus. Ohio State University Press. Lantenav de A. (1879): Préface. Discours veritable du premier exploit d'armes faict en Guienne, en l'Abaye de Saincte Ferme, le, 1?. October 1615. par quelques prétendus Réformateurs d'Estat, contenant leur Horoscope, et la merveille de Dieu qui a paru sut ce sujet. Bordeaux. Féret et fils. Muir, E. (1997): Ritual in Ear'y Modem Europe. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press. Raemond F. de (ed.) (1623): L'histoire de la naissance, progrèz, et décadence de l'hérésie de ce siècle. Rouen, lean Bcrthclin. Rubin, M. (J99I): Corpus Chrisli: The Eucharist in Late Medieval Culture. Cambridge. Cambridge University Press. Sawyer, J. K. (1990): Printed Poison: Pamphlet Propaganda, Faction Politics, and the Public Sphere in F.arlv Seventeenth-Century France. Berkeley, University of California Press. Tapie, V.-L. (1974, 1984): France in (he Age of Louis XIII and Richelieu (trans. D. McN. Lockie). Cambridge, Cambridge University Press. 516